←
Stuart3,002 posts
Stuart avatar

Stuart

@StuartMaggs

Private client law and tax, Fellow of Agricultural Law Association. All views personal and subject to change based on evidence.

◷ Joined November 2012▧ 49 Photos and videos
Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·20 Nov 2024

#FamilyFarmTax talking points - a helpful guide: 1. "It's only 500 farms". No, that's APR claims above £1m made in one year, 2021/22. Many more people than that are affected by the rules. The CLA estimated the total number is 70,000 farms. On the Government's own numbers it's about 16,000 (500 x one generation of 32 years). The true figure is that it's likely tens of thousands are affected. 2. "There's a £3m exemption". No, that only applies if both spouses are alive, they can split the farm between them, they amend their wills before dying, both they are their children are in stable marriages (or they are prepared to use complex trust structures). It will not be possible for all couples to achieve this. 3. "Family farms are protected". No, DEFRA says the average family farm is 217 acres. At £11,300/acre that's £2.45m. Together with equipment and a farmhouse, that's likely well over £3m which is the maximum level of the exemption. Farms well below that level are affected and will need to take steps to restructure the way they are organised or face inheritance tax bills when the older generation dies. 4. "How can your income be that low? The price of land must be high because of tax avoiders." The current 100% exemption for land and businesses have applied since 1992. The price of land didn't start to rise significantly until 2005, when the Single Farm Payment was introduced. Tax rules only have a minor affect on land value, which is driven by multiple factors including development, rollover relief, environmental needs, and that they're not making more of it 5. "This only affects the very wealthy and tax avoiders" At one end lifestyle buyers may well be within the £1m exemption per person, at the other the very wealthy can still plan by making gifts. The people who cannot avoid it are family farmers who need to retain access to the farm income. 6. "Wealthy farmers can just pay their fair share of tax" An average farm income is about 1%. Even if you pay over 10 years, the inheritance tax payments will often take all the income, and so part of the farm will need to be sold. This reduces efficiency and makes the farm less viable for the future. What have I missed?

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 17

I’m not sure that’s how international law works. If the opposition parties are clear that they won’t abide by it then the EU would incorporate the risks of it not being paid, and an incoming Government would explain that it had informed the other State in advance that they had no intention of paying it. It’s a political stunt, I think, not a prohibition restricting future negotiations.

🚨 NEW: The UK will have to pay a "Farage penalty" worth millions of pounds to the EU if it ever pulls out of Andy Burnham's deal set to be signed on Friday

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 17

I don’t suggest this isn’t true - trade friction will normally impact prices. But given this is being trumpeted as the main benefit rather than increasing the profitability of business and facilitating greater reinvestment (which is probably a stronger argument I feel), they should at least quantify the saving per shop. I have no idea what it is - 5%? 1%? 0.1%?

3 days til the UK-EU Summit. Costs in supermarkets have gone up since Brexit - partly thanks to unnecessary paperwork. At the Summit, the government will agree to slash that paperwork, reducing costs and creating more export opportunities.

0:35
Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 11

I'm thrilled to see tax education happening in schools - I think it's a fantastic idea and we should certainly see more like this. It's so important that kids are prepared for the real world (ideally by their parents ofc). Any explanation of tax should balance the coercive power of the State against the benefits derived for the people. It's not difficult to explain to kids, but they should absolutely learn both sides of the scales, as well as what happens if you have too little or too much tax in an area.

Government School Materials Sell High Taxes to Eight-Year-Olds order-order.com/2026/11/09/g…

Post attachment
Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 10

One thing I’ve learned about opinion polls is that if you make a big fuss when they move in your favour, you look like a right idiot when they move against you. Unless there’s an election in the next 6 weeks it’s probably best to glance briefly and then ignore them.

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 2

I shared my views with the @SundayTimes on the Budget Day plans to bring forward payments of income tax for many taxpayers, including tradespeople, landlords, investors and farmers. The issue isn't so much higher taxes, although there will be a painful transitional year, but earlier payments. For many, that shift in timing could place significant pressure on cashflow and make it harder for some businesses to manage their finances. Read the full story here: thetimes.com/money/tax/artic… Thank you Megan Harwood-Baynes for the article.

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Nov 1

Emma Reynolds, Chief Secretary to the Treasury, says that employers are not working people. And that putting yet another 2p on income tax for landlords and savers is somehow not income tax. She’s the no.2 minister in the Treasury and attends Cabinet. This is not alright. Throughout the Budget process she must have been fully briefed on its impact so that when she steps out to defend it she can do so without totally messing up. This is not a misstatement on a complex point. This is not an error on a series of figures where one goes awry. This is a fundamental misstatement of the structure of the the UK economy and its tax system. This is serious failing in basic competency. I regularly defend politicians I disagree with over missteps and oversights. On this occasion i think Emma Reynolds should consider her position.

'I don't think employers are working people.' @CamillaTominey grills Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Emma Reynolds MP, over whether Labour has breached its manifesto pledge in the Budget. 📺 Freeview 236, Sky 512, Virgin 604

3:29
Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 30

The frustration of living in a community shouldering project after project of enormous national infrastructure is hard to convey. Decades of uncertainty followed by announcements one after the other. None of the projects seem to talk to each other, and none of them give useful timescales - all those things that allow you to minimise or cope with upheaval. The disregard for the local community is appalling.

We're deeply disappointed by the approval of the Sea Link project. Throughout the process, Suffolk communities, residents and local councils have raised legitimate concerns which have not been adequately addressed. suffolk.gov.uk/council-and-d…

Post attachment
Farmers Guardian avatar
⟳ Stuart retweeted
Farmers Guardian@FarmersGuardian·Oct 29

What does the Autumn Budget mean for the future of your business? Following the Chancellor's decision not to announce further changes to agricultural Inheritance Tax reliefs, Farmers Guardian is hosting a free webinar examining the practical implications of the Budget for British agriculture. In partnership with NFU Mutual, our expert panel will explore tax, succession planning, farm finances and the steps businesses can consider in response. Our speakers include Sean McCann of NFU Mutual, Stuart Maggs of Howes Percival, Herefordshire farmer Martin Williams and NFU deputy president Paul Tompkins. Thursday, October 29 | 7-8pm | Free online webinar Register here: ow.ly/mLKT5101NGx

Post attachment
Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

Following the proposed changes to payment of tax under self assessment, I've tried to model the potential real world impact on sole traders and partners. It's not easy because life is complicated. Many businesses don't have a great first half of the year, making most of their profit from October onwards. These are going to suffer the worst - being forced to pay tax on income they haven't even earned yet. There will also be a painful transitional year, although the Government is considering ways to soften the impact without changing the overall effect. Some relatively modest changes, like paying tax monthly with a 3 month delay, could make a big difference to whether businesses can cope. The Government has stated it is continuing to work with stakeholders on the timing and frequency of payments. It should accept that the natural business cycle means demanding tax on income before it is earned would be wrong, and any change to current rules must accommodate that commercial reality. gov.uk/government/consultati…

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

The new changes to drag forward income tax charges mean that many if not most people will be paying income tax on money they haven't earned yet. Very few business have 1/12 of their profit available to distribute in April. Even if it's quarterly, how many businesses have 1/4 of their annual profit in the bank by the end of June? If the Treasury knew anything about seasonality or billing cycles, they'd never have proposed this change.

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

If you see anyone comparing the reduction in BADR (slashing the benefit of this relief from £140k to only £30k per person under this Government) with the new Founders Relief (for which practically no-one will qualify), then they haven't read the Budget briefings carefully enough

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

The hidden tax measure in the Budget is huge for people paying tax under self-assessment - sole traders, partners, landlords, retired investors. For 6th April 2028-29, you currently pay 50% of your income tax late in the tax year in question (in January 2029), 50% just after the year end (in July 2029) with any make-up payment in January 2030. Under the new proposals you will pay your tax perhaps monthly or quarterly (TBC) from April 2029 onwards. A rough analysis suggests the impact is to draw about 50% of your tax bill forward, a huge cashflow boost to HMRC and a significant funding issue for the self-employed. The Treasury recognises this, and expects to raise £1.3bn of additional tax in 29/30 as a result of this change. The cashflow impact of the accelerated charge will send some businesses to the wall.

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

The new Founders Relief claims to be pro-entrepreneur, and to an extent it is. But the reality is that the Treasury expects that no more than a few hundred people a year will qualify. The expected cost is £260m/annum, and the potential saving is £1.4m per person. Very few will qualify.

Stuart avatar
Stuart@StuartMaggs·Oct 28

Proposed “administrative” change to self assessment will have a big hit on farmers, investors and the self employed from 2029. It appears HMRC wants to accelerate the payment of self assessment tax meaning these people will have to find their tax payments earlier, and potentially on money they haven’t even earned yet! Great for HMRC’s cash flow, much worse for the people having to fund cash earlier.