←
Kerry Sun2,256 posts
Kerry Sun avatar

Kerry Sun

@SunKerry

Common law respecter and DPhil student @OxfordLawFac.

◷ Joined August 2012▧ 186 Photos and videos
Peter Copeland avatar
⟳ Kerry Sun retweeted
Peter Copeland@CopelanPeter·5h

Canada's elected politicians have become far too comfortable surrendering their responsibility to govern. In a new essay for @WDiminishment, I argue that our legislatures have increasingly abandoned the field on contentious social questions, leaving courts only too happy to fill the vacuum. The problem is far deeper than judicial activism. It ultimately lies in a conception of rights that treats human beings as free-floating individuals with ever-expanding claims to autonomy, leaving judges to adjudicate an endless contest of broad, open-ended rights claims that necessarily conflict with each other and the general welfare, when they are so ill-conceived. Under this framework, questions about drug addiction, parental authority, public order, and sex-specific spaces are presented as technical legal problems rather than moral and political judgments about what is right and good. Governments have become so fearful of anything their lawyers label a "Charter risk" that they increasingly govern by anticipated judicial permission. This gets the constitutional order backwards. Rights are not limitless abstractions. They exist in relation to concrete goods—family life, public safety, truth-seeking, and the conditions of human flourishing. And it is principally legislatures that must give those rights practical meaning through laws, institutions, and clearly assigned responsibilities to the various agents that must fulfill them. Provincial governments should stop asking judges for permission to govern. They should legislate boldly, defend the legitimate distinctions their laws make, and use the notwithstanding clause if necessary. @BCConservCaucus new government has plenty of opportunity and political capital to do so on drug abuse, homelessness, sexual orientation and gender identity curriculum, pronouns and gender affirming care, among others. @MLInstitute macdonaldlaurier.ca/reassert…

Peter Copeland avatar
⟳ Kerry Sun retweeted
Peter Copeland@CopelanPeter·7h

“According to then-Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, by refusing the exemption, the minister had deprived the staff and users of Insite of their interests in life, liberty and security of the person. Because this deprivation was “arbitrary” and “grossly disproportionate,” the court held, the government had violated Section 7. This reasoning is critically flawed. It amounts to saying that, because a policy chosen by a previous government was considered good public policy, it is unconstitutional for a subsequent government to undo that choice and to adopt a different approach to drug addiction, or other social issues. The mere fact that Insite was deemed effective, from a judge’s standpoint, does not mean that the government acted arbitrarily in terminating the facility. The refusal to continue Insite’s exemption was, in fact, based upon perceptible reasons of public health and safety, namely, the Harper government’s desire to prevent rather than perpetuate drug addiction through injection facilities." The implications extend far beyond drug policy. Courts have increasingly used section 7 of the Charter to second-guess legislative choices on everything from prostitution and public disorder to bicycle lanes. "This places "Parliament in the position of having to defend its policy choices, not on the grounds of their being based in reason, but as satisfying the courts’ policy criteria. In essence, it denies the political branches their constitutional role in formulating and choosing laws and policy. " These are the very issues @SunKerry and others will continue to highlight through MLI's Judicial Foundations Project, which is examining the increasingly blurred boundary between judicial interpretation and democratic policymaking. Kudos to @CarsonJerema , @sarkonakj and the @nationalpost for a series on these important themes! @MLInstitute macdonaldlaurier.ca/the-cour…

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

Kudos to the National Post for its journalists' commentary on court decisions and for launching this series, all of which contributes to public understanding of the impacts of judicial power on Canadian democracy. nationalpost.com/opinion/sup… ca.news.yahoo.com/supreme-er…

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

Grateful to the @nationalpost editors for the invitation to participate in this important series, which highlights ten problematic decisions from the Supreme Court. My piece on the Insite judgment and its effect on the judicialisation of policy is published today (links below).

Supreme Errors: A new series from NP Comment where we tell it like it is. We are naming the worst decisions of the Charter era. Parliament’s power is being eroded. We spotlight how that happened. 🧵 nationalpost.com/opinion/sup…

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

Here the B.C. court, in effect, substituted its view of sufficient ‘denunciation’ for Parliament's. But Parliament is constitutionally entitled to choose and to rebalance criminal sentencing policy, including by imposing a period of parole ineligibility on multiple murderers. 7/7

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

It's telling that the B.C. court seemed to leap from its view that the exclusion went ‘beyond what is necessary to achieve Parliament’s sentencing objectives’ to the conclusion it violated s. 12, without really considering whether the exclusion was grossly disproportionate. 6/

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

...the measure is 'grossly disproportionate' under s. 12. The SCC once held that this threshold would be satisfied ‘only in the clearest of cases’ (R. v. Smith, [1987] 1 S.C.R. 1045), a proposition that, albeit often repeated by the courts, is honoured more in the breach now. 5/

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

But the court's reasoning entirely undercuts Parliament's ability to choose and to tailor criminal sentencing. It is not constitutionally required to freeze the shape of the sentencing regime simply because some offenders may suffer some detriment. The question is whether... 4/

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

In other words, the court seems to think that because the faint hope clauses promote Parliament's sentencing goals—and conversely, excluding some offenders may undermine those goals—it follows that it would be unconstitutional for Parliament to roll back or narrow the clause. 3/

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

The court essentially concludes that because ‘Parliament’s goals in the sentencing regime are denunciation, deterrence, and protection of the public,’ and ‘the faint hope provisions [do] not undermine those goals,’ this mechanism should be available to all murderers [141]. 2/

Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 17

Madam Justice Brown's reasoning, striking down the exclusion of multiple murderers from the ‘faint hope’ clause, amounts to: - ‘There are many circumstances in which people commit two murders’ [137]; - ‘Our provisions are significantly harsher than some other countries’ [143]. 1/

The B.C. judge who ruled that it is unconstitutional to prohibit multiple murderers from applying for early parole under the "faint hope" clause releases her decision: bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/sc/26/22…

Jamie Sarkonak avatar
⟳ Kerry Sun retweeted
Jamie Sarkonak@sarkonakj·Nov 17

It was just in 2022 (below) that the Supreme Court said that it was constitutionally offensive to put Alexandre Bissonnette in prison for a minimum of 40 years for murdering six people in their mosque. The court said 25 years was the longest he could go without the possibility of parole. Now in B.C., this judge has declared that even 25 years is too high a guarantee. She considers 15 years to be the appropriate starting point for parole eligibility. The next frontier of this argument will ask for a 10-year minimum. And so on, and so on. decisions.scc-csc.ca/scc-csc…

Post attachment
Kerry Sun avatar
Kerry Sun@SunKerry·Nov 12

Call for papers closing next month — please get in touch if interested.

The Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s Judicial Foundations Project is planning a one-day symposium on “Judicial Power and the Canadian Constitution,” tentatively scheduled for February 4, 2027, at Hart House, University of Toronto. We hope to bring together scholars, experts, and practitioners from across Canada, and potentially the wider Commonwealth, to reinvigorate interest in the development, scope, and exercise of judicial power in Canada. @CopelanPeter @SunKerry @GeoffSigalet

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Ryan Alford avatar
⟳ Kerry Sun retweeted
Ryan Alford@ryan_p_alford·Nov 3

If you want to read one book that will guide you through the arguments that will be made in the very near future about the proper roles of courts and legislatures, this is it! Get @Mark_S_Harding's "Judicializing Everything?" today --in paperback!

Very excited to see that my book, Judicializing Everything?, is now available in paperback! Especially gratifying to see such generous endorsements from colleagues whose work I greatly admire and respect. @GeoffSigalet @gerardjkennedy @utpress

Post attachmentPost attachment