
Canada's elected politicians have become far too comfortable surrendering their responsibility to govern. In a new essay for @WDiminishment, I argue that our legislatures have increasingly abandoned the field on contentious social questions, leaving courts only too happy to fill the vacuum. The problem is far deeper than judicial activism. It ultimately lies in a conception of rights that treats human beings as free-floating individuals with ever-expanding claims to autonomy, leaving judges to adjudicate an endless contest of broad, open-ended rights claims that necessarily conflict with each other and the general welfare, when they are so ill-conceived. Under this framework, questions about drug addiction, parental authority, public order, and sex-specific spaces are presented as technical legal problems rather than moral and political judgments about what is right and good. Governments have become so fearful of anything their lawyers label a "Charter risk" that they increasingly govern by anticipated judicial permission. This gets the constitutional order backwards. Rights are not limitless abstractions. They exist in relation to concrete goods—family life, public safety, truth-seeking, and the conditions of human flourishing. And it is principally legislatures that must give those rights practical meaning through laws, institutions, and clearly assigned responsibilities to the various agents that must fulfill them. Provincial governments should stop asking judges for permission to govern. They should legislate boldly, defend the legitimate distinctions their laws make, and use the notwithstanding clause if necessary. @BCConservCaucus new government has plenty of opportunity and political capital to do so on drug abuse, homelessness, sexual orientation and gender identity curriculum, pronouns and gender affirming care, among others. @MLInstitute macdonaldlaurier.ca/reassert…
















