British Medical Laser consultant & former CQC Independent Hospital🏥 Cumberlege Report found systemic failing + new emerging science proves mesh is toxic #BJUI
Devon MP ( Caroline Voaden ) urges Prime Minister to act on pelvic mesh 'scandal’
She demanded to know when the
government would respond to the Hughes Report, which was published in 2024 and set out options for providing #redress for those harmed by pelvic #mesh and the medicine valproate.
devonlive.com/news/devon-new…
The Patient Safety Commissioner wrote to the Prime Minister on 3 March 2026 about financial redress for mesh-injured women. That letter remains unanswered.
I have submitted detailed documents and letters to the PSC, ministers and Number 10 setting out the evidence of systemic failure, the Cumberlege findings, and the urgent need for non-adversarial redress. Silence is the only response.
Mesh-injured women are still waiting. While the letters sit unanswered, women continue to live with the harm.
Redress now.
#MeshInjured#RedressNow#PatientSafety#Cumberlege#FirstDoNoHarm@10DowningStreet@DHSCgovuk
🔥 JUSTICE FOR ELJAMEL’S PRIVATE PATIENTS!
@AConstance23 is due to meet @MDDUS_News. #Eljamel’s medical indemnity provider.
Private patients remain locked out of a clear route to financial compensation for the devastating harm suffered.
🔹Patients were NOT told they were receiving an open-weave plastic designed to provoke a permanent foreign-body reaction, that full removal was often incomplete, or that there was no accredited UK explant pathway
Mesh was and is a catastrophic failure
2019 IMMDS hearing (27 Feb, Session 2) MHRA
🔹MHRA (Ian Hudson, June Raine, John Wilkinson) acknowledged “very moving” stories of harm, then said mesh “still has a role in appropriate circumstances,” with informed consent, as part of a treatment pathway, and in line with NICE.
🔹They treated it as later-line, not first-line for most women. They said multiple earlier reviews had reached similar conclusions and that New Zealand’s different approach reflected the lack of a NICE-style mechanism to constrain use.
🔹On history they said 1990s device regulation was in its “infancy,” products reached the market on weaker evidence than would be accepted later, and adoption often outpaced training.
🔹That is the official 2019 line: harm recognised, product still framed as usable if “appropriately” selected and consented.
🔹What that line rested on
The original sales and regulatory pitch treated polypropylene as chemically inert, non-degradable, and a durable implant.
🔹Patients were NOT told they were receiving an open-weave plastic designed to provoke a permanent foreign-body reaction, that full removal was often incomplete, or that there was no accredited UK explant pathway.
The first mrsh scandal and the second mrsh scandal requires a #publicinquiry which is long overdue
youtu.be/zrfwwunYcRA?is=5Enh…
🚨within 2 weeks of implantation the plastic would have been fusing to internal structures and already too late to remove easily
Misplacement of these devices did occurr - which meant the permanent plastic became ‘stuck’ to internal structures that it shouldn’t have and they had no skills to remove it promptly
Second Mesh Scandal
🚨we need a public inquiry into why no one was trained to remove mesh devices in preparedness for surgical failure - there was nothing
They knew the plastic mesh material was going to a permanent implant - this was never properly explained in consultation - and being a permanent implant with associated dangers these devices were shoved into the pelvis with a ‘blind’ surgical procedure and no post op scans
🚨within 2 weeks of implantation the plastic would have been fusing to internal structures and already too late to remove easily
Misplacement of these devices did occurr - which meant the permanent plastic became ‘stuck’ to internal structures that it shouldn’t have and they had no skills to remove it promptly
These devices have deteriorated internally now over decades and women are very sick but continue to be gaslighted even after the Cumberlege Review !
This appalling situation is now deserving of a public inquiry
My letter to the PSC sent today 17th September
@BBCPanorama@bbchealth@itvnews@CommonsHealth@APPG_WH@vicderbyshire@ShaunLintern @PHSOmbudsman @andyburnham@YvetteCooperMP@mariacaulfield
“I am writing to raise a second, distinct scandal sitting alongside the question of financial redress, one that cannot wait for a compensation scheme to be resolved, because it concerns whether mesh-injured women can access safe surgical care at all, right now, today.”
#SecondMeshScandal
pelvic mesh removal surgery is an entirely new area of clinical practice, meaning there are still no formal, standard global training programmes or fellowships specifically dedicated to extracting eroded pelvic mesh
🚨Second mesh scandal
No one was trained to remove it - and 6 years after the IMMDS Review still no one is trained!
According to statements from the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG), pelvic mesh removal surgery is an entirely new area of clinical practice, meaning there are still no formal
, standard global training programmes or fellowships specifically dedicated to extracting eroded pelvic mesh
rcog.org.uk/careers-and-trai…
The Urgent Call for Non-Adversarial Redress
“Dr. Hughes, my case is the definitive proof of why your options for a non-adversarial redress scheme must be adopted by the Treasury and Number 10 immediately. The adversarial civil route relies on the assumption that medical records are transparent and honest. They are not.
Clinical concealment ensures that statutory limitation clocks expire silently while the proof of harm is locked behind redaction blocks.”
Part of yet another letter calling for urgent redress….
The Urgent Call for Non-Adversarial Redress
Dr. Hughes, my case is the definitive proof of why your options for a non-adversarial redress scheme must be adopted by the Treasury and Number 10 immediately. The adversarial civil route relies on the assumption that medical records are transparent and honest. They are not.
Clinical concealment ensures that statutory limitation clocks expire silently while the proof of harm is locked behind redaction blocks.
The state has set aside £58.2 billion for clinical negligence liabilities, yet one pound in every five is swallowed by defense solicitors and adversarial legal costs rather than patient care.
I am an older patient, but I was a relatively young snd very fit woman in charge of an independent hospital before the hell that was to ruin my life. Like the thalidomide survivors and the victims of the infected blood scandal, the women of the mesh debacle are rapidly aging and do not have another decade to spend acting as forensic detectives to prove they were harmed by a state institution. No patient should spend 17 years unraveling the systemic lack of transparency currently pervasive in the NHS.
My case is an unarguable demonstration of why the current system is an engine of trauma, and why a tariff-based, no-fault redress scheme—modelled directly on the Armed Forces Compensation Scheme—must be enacted without further delay.
Yours sincerely,
Mrs. Susan Morgan
(Former) CQC Registered Manager & Medical Laser Consultant
#pelvicmesh#redress#patientsafety#EndtheSilence@DHSCgovuk@CommonsHealth
🌸Dear friends,
As you know, our campaign continues to push hard for the genuine action and non-adversarial redress we all deserve.
My MP recently took my policy document directly to 10 Downing Street, and I am now looking to engage the Health and Social Care Select Committee regarding the reality of the care we are receiving due to what I am reading here and on X.
The government often points to official NHS audits to say the specialised mesh centres are working well. We know our lived experiences are often very different.
If you feel well enough, could I ask you all to share again a brief sentence or two only in my DM to answer the following:
Q: Have you been seen by one of the 9 NHS Specialist Mesh Centres, and did you feel they provided you with clear transparency, full removal options, or comprehensive care and follow up?
Your raw, honest feedback will help us show parliamentarians the true picture on the ground and we can press again for a Public Inquiry. Ideally we need 50 - 100 comments:
Please only share what you feel comfortable with and rest assured no names will be shared, this is purely for information purposes and thank you for standing together.
Susan🫂🌸
Second Mesh Scandal
🚨we need a public inquiry into why no one was trained to remove mesh devices in preparedness for surgical failure - there was nothing
Second Mesh Scandal
🚨we need a public inquiry into why no one was trained to remove mesh devices in preparedness for surgical failure - there was nothing
They knew the plastic mesh material was going to a permanent implant - this was never properly explained in consultation - and being a permanent implant with associated dangers these devices were shoved into the pelvis with a ‘blind’ surgical procedure and no post op scans
🚨within 2 weeks of implantation the plastic would have been fusing to internal structures and already too late to remove easily
Misplacement of these devices did occurr - which meant the permanent plastic became ‘stuck’ to internal structures that it shouldn’t have and they had no skills to remove it promptly
These devices have deteriorated internally now over decades and women are very sick but continue to be gaslighted even after the Cumberlege Review !
This appalling situation is now deserving of a public inquiry
My letter to the PSC sent today 17th September
@BBCPanorama@bbchealth@itvnews@CommonsHealth@APPG_WH@vicderbyshire@ShaunLintern @PHSOmbudsman @andyburnham@YvetteCooperMP@mariacaulfield
These poor ladies were vindicated with the verdict against #IanPaterson
Needless operations is evident in many areas - not least #mesh that was touted as ‘gold standard’ and women were fast forwarded to surgery that didn’t even need #mesh implants but resulted in complex painful #vaginal injuries - and that’s just one of the injuries
since the insertion of this hideous device into our complex pelvic structures and soft organs it has now been reclassified as dangerous
so we now have dangerous devices internally - why was it not classified as dangerous BEFORE regulators allowed it’s use @MHRAdevices
There’s no #consent to us having a ‘dangerous device ‘ shoved cruelly into our bodies , which has wreaked havoc on our lives
No audits and no MRI scans - no one knows the full extent of suffering or how many have died
It is time for a PUBLIC INQUIRY
@PSCommissioner@mariacaulfield@SteveBarclay@wesstreeting@APPGFDNH@SharonHodgsonMP@jamesosh@AnthonyMangnal1
Putting permanent plastic m^sh in women was an unstudied risk—and trying to take it out carries even greater danger. These devices were engineered as permanent implants, never designed to be removed. They never tested these devices in women before implanting millions. The risks never outweighed the benefits, and recent science proves there is no such thing as a "full" removal.
•Organ perforations
•Bleeding
•Chronic infections
•Sexual issues
•Recurrent UTIs
•Mobility issues
•Serious nerve damage
•Significant pelvic pain
•Fibromyalgia
•Incontinence
•Mesh extrusion
•Mesh erosion
Solicitors listing the above hideous outcomes on their legal websites is all well & good but the explanations as to how these catastrophic internal injuries actually occurred are missing, & exactly why this ‘blind’ gung-ho procedure went wrong has not been discussed openly and requires a #publicinquiry for #mesh
🚨these injuries are far worse than ‘issues’
I’d like to add to the solicitors list of injuries my thoughts based on 15 years of mesh injury as to why these injuries occur and the severity….👇
🔹Organ perforations
Lackadaisical blind insertion through the vaginal wall - why wasn’t this camera led?
🔹Bleeding
Perforation & laceration of blood vessel - due to blind insertion!!!
🔹Chronic infections
Puncturing through the vaginal wall - that allows bacteria to flood into the pelvic cavity - the mesh is porous and allows a hiding place for bacteria to thrive
🔹Sexual issues
Issues! Vaginal laceration, mesh stuck to internal organs, mesh eroding through organ walls - this is not conducive to a happy love life
🔹Recurrent UTIs
The mesh was placed too tightly often buckling the urethra & causing great difficulty in passing urine, many of us have mesh stuck to our bladder walls
🔹Mobility issues
Blind insertion & no post operative scans to check for misplacement meant that the mesh procedure lacerated pelvic nerves such as obturator affecting the gait
🔹Serious nerve damage
Includes laceration & damage of illiohypogastric, Ilioinguinal, obturator, genitofemoral
🔹Significant pelvic pain
The plastic causes a foreign body reaction with inflammation, pelvic nerves have mesh glued to them , the actual plastic can be felt like cutting glass -AT ALL TIMES
🔹Fibromyalgia
There is an inflammatory response to the plastic device, & thee was a Safety Data Sheet issued to manufacturers NOT TO PUT THIS STUFF PERMANENTLY INTO THE HUMAN BODY - we were not shown this
🔹Incontinence
Meshes inserted too tight & left to rot into the urethra is one reason why incontinence was made worse
🔹Mesh extrusion
These meshes were misplaced & started to poke through organ
🔹Mesh erosion
The plastic erodes through cell walls, there were no trials
🔸we were the trials and this is not ok
Listing these hideous outcomes is all well & good but the explanations are missing & exactly why this went wrong has not been discussed openly #publicinquiry for #mesh must occur
@YvetteCooperMP@MHRAgovuk@DHSCgovuk@andyburnham@JamesFrith@CommonsHealth@APPGFDNH#mesh#publicinquirylimesolicitors.co.uk/media-h……
#plasticmesh
🔸we were the trials and this is not ok
The NHS listed hideous outcomes as a result of ‘blind’, dangerous #medicaldevice implanting techniques
The NHS list is all well & good but the explanations are missing & exactly why this went wrong has not been discussed openly #publicinquiry for #mesh must occur
The NHS listed hideous outcomes but cannot righteously claim consent was given when the doctors gaslighted the patients stating the device was “inert” and “minimally invasive”
It’s obvious the patients trust in these doctors’ untrue explanation down-playing the real truth of the extent of harm led them to believe they were in safe hands -
🚨once these patients woke up screaming in agony they had no idea of the internal carnage that had just occurred and that these injuries would be for life
#EndtheSilence#publicinquiry#redress for mesh injured
@PSCommissioner@YvetteCooperMP@andyburnham@SharonHodgsonMP@APPGFDNH@JuliaCumberlege@AlecShelbrooke@CarolineVoaden@ShabanaMahmood@Nigel_Farage @PHSOmbudsman @AvMAuk@DHSCgovuk
I’d like to add to the below list of injuries my thoughts based on 15 years of mesh injury as to why these injuries occur ….👇
🔹Organ perforations
Lackadaisical blind insertion through the vaginal wall - why wasn’t this camera led?
🔹Bleeding
Perforation & laceration of blood vessel - due to blind insertion!!!
🔹Chronic infections
Puncturing through the vaginal wall - that allows bacteria to flood into the pelvic cavity - the mesh is porous and allows a hiding place for bacteria to thrive
🔹Sexual issues
Issues! Vaginal laceration, mesh stuck to internal organs, mesh eroding through organ walls - this is not conducive to a happy love life
🔹Recurrent UTIs
The mesh was placed too tightly often buckling the urethra & causing great difficulty in passing urine, many of us have mesh stuck to our bladder walls
🔹Mobility issues
Blind insertion & no post operative scans to check for misplacement meant that the mesh procedure lacerated pelvic nerves such as obturator affecting the gait
🔹Serious nerve damage
Includes laceration & damage of illiohypogastric, Ilioinguinal, obturator, genitofemoral
🔹Significant pelvic pain
The plastic causes a foreign body reaction with inflammation, pelvic nerves have mesh glued to them , the actual plastic can be felt like cutting glass -AT ALL TIMES
🔹Fibromyalgia
There is an inflammatory response to the plastic device, & thee was a Safety Data Sheet issued to manufacturers NOT TO PUT THIS STUFF PERMANENTLY INTO THE HUMAN BODY - we were not shown this
🔹Incontinence
Meshes inserted too tight & left to rot into the urethra is one reason why incontinence was made worse
🔹Mesh extrusion
These meshes were misplaced & started to poke through organ
🔹Mesh erosion
The plastic erodes through cell walls, there were no trials
🔸we were the trials and this is not ok
Listing these hideous outcomes is all well & good but the explanations are missing & exactly why this went wrong has not been discussed openly #publicinquiry for #mesh must occur
@PSCommissioner@wesstreeting@SharonHodgsonMP@APPGFDNH@JuliaCumberlege@AlecShelbrooke@CarolineVoaden@ShabanaMahmood@Nigel_Farage @PHSOmbudsman @AvMAuk@DHSCgovuk
🔥 #Eljamel harmed patients from 1995 to 2013.
Yet past and present leadership at @NHSTayside have allowed the same culture of secrecy, failure and lack of accountability to persist.
Different faces. Same culture. Nothing has changed.
#TheyDitherWeDie
Scottish Labour leader @michaeljmarra: "There is a broader culture problem at the top of our health service...there are managers that are not accountable to citizens. They are acting with impunity and are too often concerned with headlines rather than delivering care." #FMQs