←
Tyler Koteskey2,268 posts
Tyler Koteskey avatar

Tyler Koteskey

@TKoteskey

Policy Director at @ConcernedVets | @GeorgetownCSS '26 | @UCLA '15 | Opinions are my own.

◷ Joined January 2012▧ 136 Photos and videos
Tyler Koteskey avatar
Tyler Koteskey@TKoteskey·6h

I would add, on the underlying policy debate, that if your desired strategy is this politically unsustainable, it is not a viable one.

Doesn’t matter how you personally feel about the Iran War. The fact is that it’s wildly politically unpopular and was one of the main reasons why Republicans just got wiped out. No credible person debates either of those points. The logical conclusion is that no Republican who was a key promoter or architect of the war can be considered a viable candidate in 2028. The voters have already spoken on the issue, loud and clear. Run an Iran War candidate and get catastrophically annihilated. Again. The very first question we must ask of any Republican contender is whether they can be credibly distanced from this war that an overwhelming majority of Americans oppose. If the answer is no then it would be suicide to have them as your nominee.

Rep. Warren Davidson avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Rep. Warren Davidson@Rep_Davidson·13h

“I’m not an isolationist. I’m a former Army Ranger. But we’re not made stronger by getting into all the wars we’re invited to, and we certainly don’t need to seek out extra ones.” nationalreview.com/news/warr…

Oren Cass avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Oren Cass@oren_cass·13h

6/ Here's what happened to the GOP: It was corruption and Iran. The immigration bar is also fascinating. It absolutely drove votes, but equally in both directions, with no net effect. People blaming tariffs or tax cuts are just talking their book. americancompass.org/post-mid…

Post attachment
Concerned Veterans for America avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Concerned Veterans for America@ConcernedVets·13h

Here’s the bottom line up front: Americans voted for lower gas prices and affordability in 2024; two years later, they didn’t get it. @TKoteskey explains what went wrong in the 2026 midterm election. Hint: It has to do with the war in Iran. 🔗 bit.ly/48mPR9l

0:55
John Vick avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
John Vick@JohnVickFL·13h

This and moreover, if things clearly haven't gone according to plan, the onus to justify continuation of a war is not just political, but moral

Tyler Koteskey avatar
Tyler Koteskey@TKoteskey·13h

I'm curious, @RepDonBacon, what your acceptable end-state to the Iran war is? "Once Iran is no longer a threat" is not sufficient. At what point would you be satisfied that U.S. troops could come home? If you are running in 2028, this is a key question to have an answer to.

The real problem is we have enemies in the Middle East who aren’t done waging war against the U.S.

John Daniel Davidson avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
John Daniel Davidson@johnddavidson·Nov 17

Again, the neocon analysis of the Iran war is just slogans divorced from reality. What exactly does “go fast, go hard, and finish it” mean in the context of a country like Iran? If Shapiro means, “arms the Kurds,” well, that’s not going to “go fast” or “finish it.” It’s going to unleash a very long and bloody civil war (that would likely spill over into neighboring countries). If he means, “send in US ground troops,” again, nothing fast about that—and guarantee it would “finish” anything. You don’t hear actual arguments from these neocons, you hear platitudes meant to sound like strategies. The reason they don’t want to spell out their argument in any detail because they know most people, who possess a bit of common sense, would rightly oppose it.

“I think it was a mistake to pause the Iran war. I was advocating very early on for ‘Go fast, go hard, and finish it.’" @BenShapiro tells @ColdXMan why he believes the U.S. stopped short in Iran, arguing that Washington failed to finish the job. Watch the full episode: bit.ly/4zPYlSw

2:17
Michael Brendan Dougherty avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Michael Brendan Dougherty@michaelbd·Nov 18

Weird, between this and the New York Magazine piece I haven’t seen one of these voters mention the MOU as their reason for turning against Republicans.

The most revealing line in this WSJ autopsy of Texas, imo, is the one at the very end from a Republican in Starr County, the 97-percent Hispanic border county that voted Trump in 2024 and promptly swung 76 points left to back Talarico. "'The betrayal was everything—the war and the gas and the fajitas,' Saenz said about rising costs. 'I still voted red, but in my heart I knew other people would vote blue.'" That word, "betrayal," gets at the hardest part of turning things around for 2028. People who swung Republican in 2024 were excited because they believed they were backing a GOP that had firmly and permanently rejected the elective wars of the Bush era and was ready to be focused only on America. To these people, the Iran war is not simply a mistake. It was, truly, a betrayal: The complete opposite of what they had been promised, and done with minimal justification. (And yes, I know that Donald Trump has always vowed Iran wouldn't get a nuclear weapon -- I'm simply describing how these voters saw things) From there, it was inevitable that those voters would see higher gas prices and other economic difficulties not as temporary difficulties necessary for the Administration to fulfill its promises, but as the immediate harms caused by a lie they fell for. Unsurprisingly, millions of people who felt this way stayed home, or switched their votes. It will be very difficult to win these people back. wsj.com/politics/elections/r…

Post attachmentPost attachment
Alex JER-dun avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Alex JER-dun@alexjordanATL·Nov 17

the idea that Trump (or any president!) is putting "adversaries over allies" by talking to Xi and Putin is stupid the implication here, if we're not allowed to solve our problems with Russia & China by talking to them is...we should just be feverishly preparing for WWIII !!

CSPAN@cspanNov 17

.@SenSchumer on President Trump's trip to Asia: "There is real progress to be made on this trip, if only Trump would take our partners and allies as seriously as he takes his photo ops."

2:12
Michael Brendan Dougherty avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Michael Brendan Dougherty@michaelbd·Nov 17

The idea that Iran went from the edge of defeat to completely rearmed and rallied during the short MOU period while we admit it will take maybe half a decade to rearm from our side is so risible I can’t believe anyone is saying it.

.@TomCottonAR on ending the Iran war by winning or surrendering. Democrats are poised to pressure Trump to do the latter.

2:07
Greg R. Lawson avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Greg R. Lawson@ConservaWonk·Nov 17

The #iran hawks need to answer these questions. If they cannot, then they are fundamentally u serious notwithstanding their hawkish rhetoric. 👇

Tell us what "finish the job" means then: Regime change? An open strait? Crippled nuclear/ballistic missile infrastructure? By what methods: Blockade? Renewed strikes? Ground troops? If you can't explain why victory is feasible and what it requires, why believe you?

Tyler Koteskey avatar
Tyler Koteskey@TKoteskey·Nov 17

In my latest for @ConcernedVets, I discuss why Iran mattered in the midterms, the lessons policymakers should learn from Nov. 3rd, and what the new Congress can do. What the American people actually want is central to any discussion of what the President does next on Iran.

Scalito avatar
⟳ Tyler Koteskey retweeted
Scalito@Legally_Italian·Nov 17

Barack Obama became President because George W. Bush killed his own coalition in Iraq. How many times must the voters vote against war before they learn?

Post attachment