←
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |11,704 posts
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar

The Sietch of Sci-Fi |

@TSoS_

Celebrating the beauty of the sci-fi genre and the art that moves us.

◷ Joined November 2020▧ 4,573 Photos and videos
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·2h

Sunrise on the Reaping stuns with incredible scale, colourful sets and great camerawork. Newcomer Joseph Zada poured his heart and soul into an incredible performance as young Haymitch Abernathy. Unfortunately, it is also this franchise's worst movie by a LARGE margin. With a bad script that has nothing new to say and overexplains what little thematic relevance it has, it feels like the least thought out movie in a franchise that had always managed to frame its politics in a rather interesting manner. What scarce action we get is never innovative or gripping enough to create a lasting sense of tension. Endless high-profile actors fill the shoes of every minor character the franchise had to offer. Introductions appear shot with audience reactions in mind; constant references and easter eggs make this feel like a late-stage MCU movie. There is a mid-credit scene so awful and detrimental to the movie's dramatic impact that people in my screening started laughing. In an attempt to create an interwoven story that ties directly into the plot of the original Saga, Sunrise falls into every single trap a prequel movie could fall into. Characters alluding to events the audience has seen in later films that have yet to happen within this fictional world, President Snow explaining the entire plot of the last movie to our main character despite rarely revealing any personal details about himself and having no reason to do so and a forced sense of linearity: Many of the side characters work to bring forth a a revolution by prematurely enacting the same narrative steps 'Catching Fire' and 'Mockingjay' took. The uprising of the other films is no longer a case of finding the perfect opening; it is a rebellion they have tried to establish again and again in the same redundant manner. Worst of all, the movie consistently frames Katniss Everdeen as an almost prophesized chosen one figure, a person connected to so many rebels, poets and freedom fighters that her path almost feels preordained at this point. Joseph Zada and Jesse Plemons carry this entire film on their shoulders; many other performances are oddly stilted. I had looked forward to seeing Ralph Fiennes, but the script barely gives him anything to work with and he neither captures Tom Blyth's nor Donald Sutherland's version of President Snow, feeling strangely dissonant with the other films. Most unfortunately, Sunrise on the Repaing feels subdued in its portrayal of capitalist, authoritarian systems. The interesting concept of an upper class ruling with an iron fist over those they consider beneath them, sending 24 (48) children / teenagers to fight a bloody battle to the death in an arena they control with equally bloody measures, feels involuntarily secondary here. Where the other films quite cleverly contrasted endless televised brutality and the deaths of children with the fancy dresses, the swell parties, the luxurious cities and the obscure Capitol characters who laugh at everything that happens, this movie gives this angle far too little weight. Having become such an insane global phenomenon once again, the studio released a movie so PG-13, so marketable to the masses that all its horror is lost. There's barely any blood, most of the tributes get little to no characterisation and almost all of them die off-screen. Any thematic richness the franchise had feels gone for good; there is a potentially interesting narrative thread that aims to dissect how propaganda works, but it never fully commits to it. The final 25 minutes REALLY want you to cry, but it never worked for me. None of the side characters feel well developed; there is no reason to ever feel emotionally invested. At the end, I was left with but one question: If a Hunger Games movie no longer makes you feel horrified by what you're seeing, have we not become the voyeurs these movies originally warned us about, the sensationalist Capitol citizens who but consume a palatable version of events without thought?

Post attachment

Now Watching: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·2h

I understand people were skeptical how Villeneuve could carry this story forward after Part Two without sacrificing the narrative integrity of Dune: Messiah, but he only seems to have emphasized the utter tragedy of Paul and Chani's love. This movie will break me.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·2h

You know I talk about it constantly, but Andor is such a brilliant prequel in comparison. The first real victory of the Rebel Alliance is the destruction of the Death Star. The real beginning of Revolution is the Battle of Scarif. Everything Andor does helps shape that eventual revolution, but it never takes the same steps twice. Every success, every conflict, every failure feels unique. Nothing it ever does feels redundant. With Sunrise on the Reaping, the games themselves feel timid, boring and redundant, while the revolutionary plot shows Haymitch taking the exact same steps Katniss later took. Its even the exact same characters he does it with! It's like Cassian trying to steal the Death Star plans twice! At the end of the movie, Haymitch appears determined to bring the Capitol down one day, but that is not who he is when we first meet him in the original movies. The spirit of revolution may have slumbered in him, but it needed awakening, it needed an opening that only Katniss could provide. Sunrise on the Reaping creates a sort of linearity of story, an idea that Haymitch would be there for the Revolution because he always knew he would be there, not because he was inspired to join it.

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·4h

Paul in the gardens of the Arrakeen palace talking to Hayt about everything that has transpired on Arrakis after the death of Duncan Idaho. (Shot edited by @CalderDune)

Post attachment
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·4h

CalderDune was one of the earliest voices that really stood out to me in this community. Great posts, deep dives and analyses. So glad all his hard work is paying off and he gets to share exclusive clips from the movie of the decade. Y'all made the right person famous!

Please enjoy watching this brand new exclusive scene from Dune: Part Three with me. (Exclusive to TikTok) tiktok.com/t/ZPNd7h7jN/

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·9h

Now Watching: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·11h

We are 29 days away from the release of #DunePartThree. One of my favorite Dune: Messiah quotes: Empires do not suffer emptiness of purpose at the time of their creation. It is when they have become established that aims are lost and replaced by vague ritual. - Words of Muad'dib by Princess Irulan.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
⟳ The Sietch of Sci-Fi | retweeted
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 17

When do y'all consider it alright to post Dune: Part Three spoilers? I really want to get into the discussion of the movie quickly, but I also don't want to ruin it for anyone who might not see it until the next day.

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 18

Denis Villeneuve on Dune: Part Three, art and the idiocy of AI in filmmaking. "AI is about the past [...] The AI can only create from things that existed. Us, we can step into the unknown and go deeper into the dream and that is the strength of the human being."

0:53
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 17

Why does this app have the audacity to constantly show me movie posts from people who only watch 3 movies a year?

does hollywood realize there are more than 5 actors in the industry why am i being forced to watch the same people in literally everything

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 17

We are but thirty days from the release of #DunePartThree. In celebration of these final weeks of unbearable anticipation, I will be posting my favourite #Dune quotes over the next thirty days, starting of course with the famous to Litany Against Fear, beautifully recited by the great Rebecca Ferguson in Dune: Part One: I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past, I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.

The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 17

Considering I have yet to see La Bola Negra, You Can See Everything, Werwulf and Dune: Part Three, I'm not sure any of these will still be here by the end of the year. All fantastic, though.

Post attachment

what are your four favorite films of 2026 so far, and what film do you think may replace one of them before the year is over?

Post attachment
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
⟳ The Sietch of Sci-Fi | retweeted
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 15

One final question I personally find interesting as a huge fan of both Dune and the series: Have you seen Star Wars: Andor? Did you like it? I want to prove my gut feeling that the fanbases of both these projects - highly political & profound sci-fi epics - frequently overlap.

Post attachment
The Sietch of Sci-Fi | avatar
⟳ The Sietch of Sci-Fi | retweeted
The Sietch of Sci-Fi |@TSoS_·Nov 15

Should we ever get a 'God Emperor of Dune' movie, who would you want to direct it? This is just a small selection of directors I find interesting. If your favourite pick isn't here, feel free to comment or quote this post with your preferred choice.

Post attachment