←
Chief5,699 posts
Chief avatar

Chief

@TX_Chief

Christian · Husband · Father · Grandfather US Army Retired Constitutional analysis | Institutional limits | Original commentary Constitution / Cincinnatus 🚫DMs

◷ Joined January 2023▧ 170 Photos and videos
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 6

Army retired. Now I write as a citizen about the Constitution: who holds power, who is supposed to, and how we the people take it back. Plain language, no spin. Longer essays at Cincinnatus: thecincinnatus.substack.com/…

Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·8h

The Constitution in 5 Sentences: the Qualifications Clauses. A Representative must be 25, a citizen for 7 years, and live in the state; a Senator must be 30 and a citizen for 9. That's the whole list, and the Supreme Court says it's closed: Powell v. McCormack (1969) held the House can't add to it, and U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton (1995) held the states can't either. Not one word in it addresses holding a second citizenship. That's why a plain statute barring dual citizens would likely die in court, and why Rep. Luna filed H.J. Res. 222 as an amendment: two-thirds of both chambers, then 38 states. Whatever you think of the idea, she knocked on the right door. Should the Constitution require members of Congress to hold one citizenship only?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 17

The Constitution in 5 Sentences: the Recess Appointments Clause. Article II lets the President fill vacancies "during the Recess of the Senate," and those commissions expire at the end of the Senate's next session. The Constitution never says how long a recess has to be. In NLRB v. Noel Canning (2014), all nine justices threw out Obama's 2012 NLRB picks made during a three-day gap between pro forma sessions, and the majority said any break under 10 days is presumptively too short. That's why one senator gaveling in for 30 seconds every three days keeps the door shut, a move Harry Reid's Senate started in 2007. George W. Bush made 171 recess appointments and Obama made 32; Trump hasn't made any. Should a 30-second gavel be able to switch off a power the Constitution gives the President?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 17

Most talk about socialism starts with a slogan. "Venezuela." "Denmark." Then everyone talks past each other. I'm starting with their best argument. New series: The Anti-Socialist Papers. State the strongest case, quote it fairly, answer it with the Constitution and evidence. No. 1: Why Hear the Strongest Case? thecincinnatus.substack.com

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 17

Three Supreme Court justices wanted to hear the California doctors' case today. It takes four. In Khatibi v. Yip, Thomas and Alito dissented from the denial and Gorsuch said he would grant. California makes private instructors cover "implicit bias" in continuing medical education, and the Ninth Circuit called that government speech, so the First Amendment never got a look. The Rule of Four isn't in the Constitution or any statute. It's a custom the Court has kept for about a century, and being one vote short means the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands. A denial isn't an endorsement. It just means not yet. Who's the fourth vote next time?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 16

The Constitution in 5 Sentences: Advice and Consent. The blue paper that could stall Trump's Texas judge isn't in the Constitution. Article II, §2 says the President nominates judges and appoints them "by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate," and in practice that means a Senate majority votes yes or no. The "blue slip" is a Judiciary Committee courtesy dating to at least 1917, not a Senate rule or a statute, and since 2017 a withheld slip no longer blocks circuit nominees, only district judges. Any chairman can keep it or drop it, because Art. I, §5 lets each chamber set its own rules, so when one home-state senator "blocks" a judge, the chairman is choosing to let him. Should one senator's slip of paper outrank 51 votes?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 16

The White House says Democrats' oversight threats may "cross the line into blatant criminality." Democrats say Trump has something to hide. The Supreme Court already wrote the rules for this fight. McGrain (1927): the power to investigate comes with the power to legislate. Watkins (1957): there is "no congressional power to expose for the sake of exposure." Eastland (1975): issuing a subpoena is protected by the Speech or Debate Clause, and courts don't judge the motive. Mazars (2020): a subpoena for a President's personal records needs a real legislative purpose and can't reach further than necessary. So January won't be won by whoever sounds angriest. It'll be won by whoever can name the bill. What legislation should a subpoena have to serve?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 15

"It depends." That's the White House Counsel's answer on whether the administration will comply with House subpoenas come January. Congress's power to investigate isn't written in the Constitution. The Court found it implied in McGrain v. Daugherty (1927), and in Trump v. Mazars (2020) it fenced in subpoenas for a President's personal papers: a real legislative purpose, no broader than needed, and weighed against the burden on the President. Here's the part nobody mentions. Criminal contempt of Congress goes to the U.S. Attorney, who works for the President being investigated. The civil route is a lawsuit, and the McGahn subpoena fight that started in 2019 outlasted that Congress. If oversight only works when the executive agrees to be overseen, is it oversight?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 14

Chuck Todd is right about one thing: the 435 cap isn't in the Constitution. It comes from the Permanent Apportionment Act of 1929 (2 U.S.C. 2a), so Congress can change it with an ordinary law. Article I §2 only says no more than one representative per 30,000 people. Today it's about one per 761,000. The Founders even sent the states a fix in 1789, the Congressional Apportionment Amendment. It's technically still pending. But a bigger House won't end popular vote/Electoral College splits. Electors equal House seats plus 2 senators, so 800 seats shrinks the small-state bonus. It doesn't touch winner-take-all, which drives most splits. Win California by millions or by one vote, it's still exactly 54 electors. Uncap the House for representation's sake. Just don't sell it as an Electoral College cure. x.com/chucktodd/status/21210…

We can solve the Electoral College problem by uncapping the House. No Constitutional Amendment needed. Right size the House (should be about 800 members) and we won’t have a popular vote/EC split maybe ever. Oh, and the House will actually be “the people’s House” again.

Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 14

I raised my right hand more than once in uniform. I can still recite the words. I couldn't tell you what my left hand was on. That's by design. Article VI asks for an "Oath or Affirmation" and bans any religious test for office. The book is your business. The promise belongs to the public. Every oath I took ended up in the same place: support and defend the Constitution. Veterans, what do you remember about the day you took yours?

Post attachment
Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 13

Same construction projects. Two different records laws. Rep. Huffman's Nov 9 letters told Interior, the Park Service and 27 companies and groups to save everything, including disappearing messages. Agency files on the arch and the golf course are federal records under the Federal Records Act, and a House committee can subpoena them once the new Congress organizes in January. White House staff emails on the same projects are presidential records under 44 U.S.C. 2201, which expressly excludes agency records. Congress's access clause in the PRA, §2205(2)(C), mostly bites after the records reach the Archives, and a subpoena for a sitting president's papers has to clear Trump v. Mazars (2020) first. So the paper trail Democrats get fastest is the Park Service's, not the West Wing's. Which one do you think actually tells the story?

Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 13

'On the table' is the easy half of that sentence. The House impeaches by simple majority. The Senate convicts only with two-thirds of the senators present (Art. I, §3). Holding the Senate doesn't get you there. Sixty-seven does, if all 100 vote. The House has impeached a Supreme Court justice exactly once, Samuel Chase in 1804. The Senate acquitted him in 1805, and the House hasn't impeached a justice since. So is this a plan to remove anyone, or a plan to put people on record? thegatewaypundit.com/2026/11…

Chief avatar
Chief@TX_Chief·Nov 11

A Texas Supreme Court seat could flip the court, and the calendar matters more than the headcount. If Justice Lehrmann retires, Gov. Hinojosa fills the seat (Tex. Const. art. V §28). An appointment made while the Senate is in session needs two-thirds of senators present (art. IV §12). Leave after the 2027 session ends, and a recess appointee can serve until voters fill the seat in November 2028 without a confirmation vote, unless a special session acts first. "Early summer" isn't a throwaway line. It's the whole ballgame.

Post attachment
DataRepublican (small r) avatar
⟳ Chief retweeted
DataRepublican (small r)@DataRepublican·Nov 10

Thank you. Every one of you freaking out needs to read every word of this article.

Cynical Publius @CynicalPublius Nov 10 Article Some Hard Truths About Election Fraud My friend @DataRepublican has been getting savaged by people who should know better for her data analyses on the midterms. Those analyses suggest that there was no algorithmic voter fraud in the