
European leaders gathering in Dublin to discuss breaking free from US tech dependence, on the very day a Microsoft outage locks them out of their own email The irony is deafening.

We help nonprofits, activists, progressive businesses and philanthropies to gain a voice in the policy process. Founded by @alemannoEU 🇪🇺

European leaders gathering in Dublin to discuss breaking free from US tech dependence, on the very day a Microsoft outage locks them out of their own email The irony is deafening.

Extraordinary times or the new normal? After the 21-hour Microsoft glitch, now it’s the airspace: ALL flights have been grounded across the US since. ft.com/content/c9b119ff-d1da…

The more I see polls suggesting that the French presidential election is already crystallising into a Le Pen–Mélenchon contest, the more I expect a surprise candidate to emerge. And if I had to bet on one name, it would be… Christine @Lagarde

Delighted to debunk your debut 1. EU primacy is in Declaration 17 to Lisbon, and in the acquis when the Polish Parliament ratified EU accession in 2004. Primacy stems also from Art. 91(3) of Poland's own Constitution. 2. The German Constitutional Court defied the CJEU in 2020 and no one called it a rule-of-law breach, because Karlsruhe is lawfully composed. Warsaw's Tribunal isn't, per Strasbourg (2021) and Luxembourg (2025) judgments. The coup was 2015. The rest is conspiracy #Poland
Delighted to debut in @Weltwoche with this piece about Donald Tusk’s EU-backed constitutional coup. In it, I explain that even though, at face value, this might seem like little more than a showdown between the government and opposition over control of the country’s highest court, it is actually part of a much larger power struggle within the EU establishment. At its core, this is a battle over sovereignty in its most fundamental form: which legal order should prevail, the Polish constitution or EU law, when the two collide? In the past, the Tribunal has argued that the final word lies with the Polish constitution, not EU law — something Brussels has never forgiven it for. The supremacy of EU law over national law does not exist in any treaties; rather, it was created by the EU judiciary through a ruling made by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) known as Costa v ENEL in 1964. Since then, it has become the engine of EU “integration by law”: by constantly creating “laws” through its rulings, almost always in favor of “more Europe”, the ECJ has effectively become the bloc’s most important legislative and, indeed, constitution-writing body, thus hollowing out from above of national constitutional and legal systems. Alec Stone Sweet, an international-law expert, has termed this a “juridical coup d’état”. A national constitutional court that rejects this principle represents an existential threat to Brussels. This is the real reason the EU was so adamantly opposed to Poland under the previous national-conservative government (and to Orbán’s Hungary for the same reason). This is ultimately what Brussels and Tusk refer to when they accuse the previous government, and the Tribunal itself, of having violated the rule of law. What they mean is that they dared to challenge the rule of Brussels’s law. This is the law Tusk wants to restore.

Who captured the Polish Constitutional Tribunal? PiS, not Tusk Who led legal Polexit? PiS, not Tusk The rest is history in the making
It was the outgoing party of Tusk (PO) that first attempted to illegally pack the court in 2015. PIS then responded with an overcorrection of their own. But the first provocative move was by PO. On the primacy issue the constitutional court defended Polish primacy in 2005 in many areas. It’s not at all clear cut.

Part of Poland's elite keeps treating PiS and Tusk as two sides of the same coin. They are not. PiS captured the courts and public media. Tusk set out to restore their independence. How he is doing it is open to fair criticism. Methods matter, and some of his have been rough. But the aim is not up for debate. Independent courts and free media are not one party's agenda. They are the precondition for democratic life to work again, and EU law requires them. Treating the arsonist and the firefighter alike because the firefighter broke a window serves only those who lit the 🔥 #Poland
Since 2023: 📌 Tusk (not PiS) has unlawfully (and by force) taken over the state TV, radio and Polish Press Agency 📌 Tusk (not PiS) froze state funding for the main opposition party. Especially important since public funding is the only legal means of financing political activity in Poland 📌 Tusk (not PiS) has unlawfully appointed the Office of the National Prosecutor 📌 Tusk (not PiS) has illegally overriden the President's veto. 📌 Tusk (not PiS) is persecuting opposition MPs virtually making it impossible for them to serve their democratic mandate As you can see, the Constitutional Court is not the first - and surely will not be the last - violation of the constitution, rule of law and the spirit of democracy that Tusk has commited. The question is whether Mr Alemanno does not know all of this. If so, he should not be really taking part in the seriuos discussion about Poland because is is obviously lacking the expertise. But maybe he knows all of that, and decides not to mention. In that case he seems extremely biased in favour of Tusk. And I believe the reader has right to know that..

Let me get this straight: The Tusk government should continue restoring the Constitutional Tribunal. It should do so through transparent, publicly defensible procedures anchored in European judgments; better communicate the rationale of its actions; and invite independent scrutiny of its methods rather than resist it. The test is not whether Poland can free its Tribunal from those who captured it. It is whether it can build one that is also independent of the government now committed to repairing it. Redemocratisation means restoring the rule of law, not swapping one form of political control for another. READ my latest for EUobserver lnkd.in/etA3bxbf

Is the solution to the Polish Tribunal Stand-off as simple as @donaldtusk argues? He got the law on his side, but the Friday’s actions and identity of some the newly elected judges may have complicated things. #Poland
Rozwiązanie konfliktu jest proste i możliwe bez zmian w Konstytucji. Prezydent uznaje legalnie wybranych przez Sejm sędziów, bo tak stanowi Konstytucja, a oni podejmują swoje obowiązki w Trybunale. Póki co, @NawrockiKn wybiera siłową konfrontację, która może bardzo wiele Polskę kosztować. Demokratyczne państwo prawa nie może ustąpić przed przemocą, niezależnie od tego, jak potężne zewnętrzne siły wspierać będą atak PiS, Konfederacji, Brauna i Nawrockiego. I nie ustąpi.

Let me get this straight: Poland is legally obliged to have an independent constitutional court, and anyone blocking the new legally appointed judges is not defending the law, but going against it. We can question the methods used by the Tusk-led government but not its mission, which is required by the law (Polish and EU)? albertoalemanno.substack.com…

Poland's Constitutional Tribunal stand-off raises a question that reaches well beyond Poland: How can a constitutional democracy restore institutions dismantled from within, using the very procedures and authorities meant to protect them? My latest on European Question Time 👇 albertoalemanno.substack.com… #Poland #RuleOfLaw #EUlaw #EuropeanDemocracy

The losers are also corrupt (that's why they lost big to @magyarpeterMP): 💰Three of Viktor Orbán’s former ministers are already in custody over alleged corruption. Sums involved: Seszták €30m; Hankó €47m; the wider Matolcsy/Hungarian National Bank scandal €1.37bn. Seszták allegedly kept HUF 9bn (€24m) in cash in safes at home and hid it before his arrest. @panyiszabolcs reports
The “losers” (as you call them) are going to win and roll back your liberal superstate project. It has nothing to do with outsiders. The only way you can try to prevent this is by turning to outright tyranny. But then you will have destroyed everything you claimed to be fighting for. The alternative is to acknowledge your mistakes, help make this change happen, and save what can still be saved. The time is coming when you will have to choose.

After some hesitation, the EU Commission clarifies that the Polish government and Parliament are entitled to appoint new judges
The statement comes after a confrontation outside the Constitutional Tribunal building on Friday night, broadcast live on television, that has pushed a decade-old dispute into the wider European political debate. ➡️ l.euronews.com/8x2k

When you decided to join the EU, you accepted to abide by commonly-agreed rules: - judicial independence - media fredom If you depart from them, you affect all other member states and therefore must back up. Btw if you can always leave the EU, any time - instead of weakening it from within #EUCO @eucopresident
Ko smo se odločali za vstop v EU, si ni nihče predstavljal, da bo v kaki njeni članici in uniji nasploh mogoče brez posledic: 1. Razveljaviti predsedniške volitve (Romunija); 2. Ukiniti informativni program na nacionalni RTV (Madžarska); 3. Poslati policijo na Ustavno sodišče (Poljska); 4. Tri tedne pred volitvami poslati v zapor predsednika stranke, ki vodi v anketah (Slovenija); 5. Zasesti nacionalno RTV s policijo in zamenjati vodstvo (Poljska); 6. Prekiniti mandate vodstvu nacionalne RTV in izvesti čistko zaposlenih (Slovenija); 7. Poslati v zapor člane prejšnje vlade brez možnosti obrambe (Madžarska); 8. Podeliti skoraj milijon državljanstev ilegalnim migrantom po hitrem postopku (Španija); 9. Zapreti novo Nuklearno elektrarno in zgraditi plinovod do Rusije (Nemčija); 10. Obdavčiti ogljične energetske vire ob hkratnem zapiranju NE ter preseliti industrijo v države z nizkimi ekološkimi standardi pod pretvezo, da tako rešujemo planet. Nastala je EU, ki se mora reševati sama pred sabo.

The losers prefer to team up with Europe's enemies rather than defend the continent. No matter, this is self-destructive.
This is the most childish argument imaginable at a time when courts are clearly persecuting politicians from only one side of the political spectrum, obviously for political reasons, and when media freedom in practice means that only federalist media outlets are allowed to survive and receive funding. The hypocrisy is so obvious that it is outrageous for every normal person. And it is precisely the anger provoked by such cynical arguments that will ultimately destroy the very political project you supposedly want to preserve. So if you genuinely care about the future of the European Union, stop trying to defend it with such empty arguments. Instead, start putting pressure on those who are abusing their power.

The ultimate test is whether Poland can regain a constitutional court independent of both the government that captured it and the government now seeking to fix it. The methods chosen to restore the rule of law in Poland must be judged on their legality. But the duty to restore judicial independence is - and should not be - up for debate. Read my latest @Substack substack.com/home/post/p-223…

There’s a lot of confusion around Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal crisis. Here’s what you must know: 1. The Polish Constitutional Tribunal is not a lawful court The CJEU has ruled that it is not a tribunal previously established by law, owing to serious irregularities in the appointment of three judges and its President (C-448/23, 18 Dec 2025). The ECtHR (Xero Flor v Poland, 2021) and the Venice Commission reached the same conclusion. 2. Restoring judicial independence is a legal obligation, not Tusk's caprice Articles 2 and 19(1) TEU require every Member State to guarantee independent courts, because: (i) National courts are part of the EU’s system of judicial protection, (ii) their decisions affect all Europeans. The President’s refusal to receive the oaths of four of the six judges elected by the Sejm in March 2026, and the Tribunal leadership’s refusal to let them sit, prompted an ECtHR interim measure in May requiring that nothing hinder them from taking up and exercising their functions. 3. EU law offers no blueprint, but the Commission and the EU courts can check the chosen methods Appointing Maciej Berek, a minister until weeks earlier and Tusk’s “right-hand man”, to the bench contradicts the government’s pledge to depoliticise the Tribunal. The Friday suspension of the Tribunal’s president and vice-president, ordered by one judge and accompanied by a police presence outside the building, is not in itself a “coup”: the stated aim is to restore a lawfully functioning court. But restoring the rule of law must itself be done lawfully. 4. The EU has weakened its own leverage. In February 2024, it released up to €137bn in suspended funds on the strength of promises, before durable change was secured. What the EU could do is to reopen an Article 7 TEU procedure against Poland. 5. No: this is not a two-sided, symmetrical dispute If the Polish government is trying to repair an institution captured under PiS, its opposition is striving to retain some control through illegal means. Bottom line: restoring judicial independence is a legal duty, and the methods chosen by the Polish government deserve scrutiny. Equating the two sides, or reading that scrutiny as opposition to restoring the Tribunal, is, therefore, deeply misleading.