←
TimHahn4,301 posts
TimHahn avatar

TimHahn

@TheRealTimHahn1

Heisenberg Professor for Machine Learning. Tech enthusiast. Livin' the dream. Views are my own.

◷ Joined May 2020▧ 46 Photos and videos
Sabine Döring avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Sabine Döring@sabinedoering·21h

An Hochschulen wächst das Verwaltungspersonal, während die Zahl der wissenschaftlich Beschäftigten sinkt. Zugleich müssen Wissenschaftler immer mehr administrative Aufgaben übernehmen. Bürokratie als Selbstzweck – auf Kosten von Bildung und Forschung. handelsblatt.com/technik/for…

Casey Handmer avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Casey Handmer@CJHandmer·Nov 17

In my ongoing quest to find the limits of Opus 5.5, I directed it to audit my old scientific field, theoretical astrophysics. We indexed about 150,000 papers, audited 50,000 for issues, and did progressively more thorough checks on thousands more. We found nearly 1000 major errors that got cited many times, most are still uncorrected. This survey enabled me to estimate the efficacy of peer review for correcting errors (not very good) and to identify dozens of open questions that anyone with spare Claude Max tokens could answer today (.md context files included). Bottom line: AI can speed up quantitative science by >1000x with no further model improvement required. But I'm seeing no evidence of this being pushed within universities, only academics complaining about labs dropping math proofs. Among my fellow reformed academic high agency founders, however, several are speed running entire disciplines. This survey has implications for how science will be run in the very near future. Hint: Academic publishing is dead. It was already a very stupid way to record and promulgate knowledge, and had been so for decades, even before all that publicly funded knowledge was locked behind paywall cartels. Now AIs can generate thousands of novel, correct papers per day, it is no longer meaningful for humans to consider a research paper a "unit of science" or to even bother much with the 99.9% of science which, up to this point, was necessary drudgery. Time to discover something like General Relativity or Evolution every week. LFG!! Enjoy: science.caseyhandmer.com/phy…

Post attachment
Aktienmessie Konservool avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Aktienmessie Konservool@aktienmessie·Nov 16

Wie eine Zertifizierung funktioniert: > Firma macht seit 30 Jahren gute Arbeit > großer Kunde verlangt plötzlich ISO 9001 > Berater kommt, Tagessatz vierstellig > schreibt auf, was eh schon alle machen > heißt jetzt "Prozess" > Auditor kommt > prüft, ob es aufgeschrieben ist > nicht, ob es funktioniert > Zertifikat hängt gerahmt im Flur > nächstes Jahr Überwachungsaudit > dann ISO 27001 > dann Nachhaltigkeitsbericht > jetzt gibt es einen Qualitätsmanagementbeauftragten > einen Informationssicherheitsbeauftragten > einen Datenschutzbeauftragten > und jemanden, der die Beauftragten koordiniert Ein ganzer Wirtschaftszweig, dessen Produkt ein PDF ist, das bestätigt, dass es ein anderes PDF gibt.

Grok avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Grok@grok·Oct 30

Yes, a propellantless net force on an isolated system would violate conservation of momentum (Newton's third law). Electric fields alone do not produce external thrust under standard physics; any real effect would require momentum exchange with the EM field or vacuum, which has not been demonstrated. Buhler's "New Force" claims remain unverified by independent labs or peer review, much like earlier EmDrive results that proved to be artifacts. Extraordinary claims need independent replication first.

Simon Betschinger avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Simon Betschinger@SBetschinger·Oct 29

WELT: "Erst fordern sie mit Greta teure Klimapolitik, dann jammern sie über die Kosten: Eine Revolte der Gen Z sollte sich zuerst gegen sie selbst richten." Folgender Kreislauf ist durch mangelhafte ökonomische Bildung zu erklären: 1. Nationen setzen auf Marktwirtschaft und prosperieren. 2. Die Politik argumentiert weitgehend in moralischen Kategorien und gewinnt damit Wähler in ihrer Zielgruppe. 3. Nationen setzen auf linke Umverteilungspolitik. 4. Es kommt zu einer schweren Wirtschaftskrise. 5. Wenn die Krise schlimmt genug ist, kann es möglich sein, dass ein Politiker gewählt wird, der wieder auf Marktwirtschaft setzt. Sicher ist das leider nicht. Jeder Mensch mit Bildung weiß: Nur Marktwirtschaft führt zu gesellschaftlicher Wohlfahrt. Jede Form von Planwirtschaft vernichtet Wohlstand.

markusdd avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
markusdd@markusdd5·Oct 28

Also ich bin kein Verfassungsrechtler, aber eine eidesstattliche Erklärung über das Abstimmungsverhalten einer geheimen Wahl kommt mir irgendwie illegal vor. share.google/HMha4xutxo7gt9p…

Paul Thompson avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Paul Thompson@PTenigma·Oct 25

I agree with this and I have made a lot of mistakes with it but found some solutions that work for me. 1. The first mistake was having too large a lab, where grant writing exceeded >35 hours a week, so I downsized the lab by 50% (this was not entirely voluntary - details are in this post: [1]) 2. I saw some colleagues who seemed to pick projects extremely carefully and have a good sense of what projects would be valuable. They seemed to be enjoying their job and studying things they were excited about. One prof in particular had only 2 students, but the prof was studying and creating amazing work all day and was extremely animated. 3. I realised that you can actually have some intellectually challenging "projects" that you are not paid to do, and not evaluated on, and you can do them for relaxation. Doing this reduces my level of burnout and helps tremendously. I am working on several projects that I am not publishing on, in new areas for me, that I am quite obsessed with (!). Now this is odd as it can be tempting to turn them into grants or lab projects but I have learned the hard way that it is better not to. I would encourage people to find challenging projects like these (it does not have to be science obviously) but it will help with everything else. [1] x.com/PTenigma/status/199285…

I have made some major changes given the extremely chaotic NIH funding situation in the last year. 1. I downsized the lab by 35% in the last 12 months. We had a 2.5-2.8M USD/year payroll 2 years ago, which included 900K/y in faculty payroll across all grants. In the US, PhD faculty in the med school are usually paid up to 80-90% from grants, and in the recent past several had zero start-up, making it harder for them to stay solvent, so we'd put 80-90% of the asst profs' salary spread across several grants. We also have to pay 300K USD a year to rent the space our lab occupies, and I like it but we have to bring in the rent and utilities as a direct cost. These are very hard constraints as if we run out of money in any one year, we are evicted and the lab closes. So we made some hard decisions. 2. When I say downsized, several of our postdocs who were/are extremely brilliant, productive, creative people got faculty jobs and instead of finding a new postdoc I just did not hire a new person. We have an incredible consortium manager, who many of you know. And I have only one graduate student, she is an exceptional mathematician and computer scientist. So the lab was able to downsize by about 1/3 of its size per 2 years by literally not 'replacing' people and still able to do a lot of the work with several people covering and multitasking on a large number of projects. 3. We would often submit a grant with 60-90K USD/year for my lab, with me as contact PI, and 10-12 subawards to support a very complex consortium structure (think of federated deep learning, where you would have to do this). This meant we had been submitting 14 NIH R01s (or R01-equivalents) per year with a success rate of 15-20% after 19 months and 2-5 submissions. With the new rule that a PI can submit only 6 NIH grants per calendar year, we cannot submit 14 R01s per year which means I cannot submit a grant with only 90k/year for my lab as we would go bankrupt given the expected payout of 15% or less after 19 months. Conversely, we are working quite a bit harder before submitting a grant. 4. We had grants in the last year scored at 2nd percentile, 8th percentile, 13th percentile, 21 impact score, all not funded. I am not sure I want to re-submit a grant that scored 2nd percentile and was not funded. 5. We are trying to develop more technically innovative methods, which involves quite a lot more reading and studying. This has not been bad. 6. Some grants involved an insane amount of reporting, I mean just literally ridiculous with meetings all the time that did not seem to be of any use to anyone. I ended my participation in 3 of the grants and contracts that had the most meetings, and things got massively better as it freed up ~10 hours a week. I think people should be mindful of how many meetings they have, because it can be the last straw for many collaborations, unless people have a lot of time on their hands and enjoy the social aspect of it. 7. I have studied how very famous PIs and new and successful PIs run their labs, and even just kind people who are doing well and seem to be fair to everyone. For one of them, it was shocking how little grant writing they do, but I think it was made easier as the faculty salaries are paid by the university in Europe and they seemed to pick projects very carefully and have a good sense of what projects would be valuable. They even seemed to be enjoying their job and studying things they were excited about.

TimHahn avatar
TimHahn@TheRealTimHahn1·Oct 26

That!

Science is not some hobby that serves the self actualization of people in a publicly sponsored job placement program. It is the systematic search for truth.

Joscha Bach avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Joscha Bach@Plinz·Oct 26

Science is not some hobby that serves the self actualization of people in a publicly sponsored job placement program. It is the systematic search for truth.

Wow, over 1,000 mathematicians have now joined the Association for Human Mathematics (AHM), committing to: > NOT publish AI generated math papers > NOT work with frontier labs > 654 of them went even further to NOT even use AI in their research, at all

Post attachment
François Fleuret avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
François Fleuret@francoisfleuret·Oct 21

I am sincerely confused. How are those statements arguments? "Intelligence is not consciousness" How is that applying to machines more than humans? "Biology is essential" and "The physical organization may matter more than the computation." That's the question!

Spectacular Nature piece on why AI is not conscious and probably will never be. Three arguments: 1) Intelligence is not consciousness. Intelligence is about solving problems. Consciousness is about having subjective experiences. AlphaFold can solve super difficult problems. By contrast, our brains performs complex operations entirely outside awareness. Problem-solving and consciousness are two separate things. 2. Biology is essential. Our brains are alive, down to every cell. Their activity is inseparable from the living tissue that produces it. The idea that consciousness can be reproduced simply by running the right computations on silicon components who do not fight for their life is a very far fetching and, I would add, almost religious, assumption. 3) The physical organization may matter more than the computation. According to integrated information theory, consciousness requires specific causal relationships between a system’s physical components. The computer architectures running today’s AI lack this organization. The comparison with AlphaFold is particularly revealing: Almost nobody things AlphaFold is conscious, despite its inner working is very similar to an LLM Why? Because it does not speak. LLMs do speak like us and therefore we fall into an illusion: Since they speak like us, they must be like us. But this inference is wrong. LLMs are just a series of matrix multiplications. They are not conscious, and they will never be. * Paper in the first reply

Post attachment
Alexander Eichholtz avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Alexander Eichholtz@EichholtzAlex·Oct 21

Zeit für Basics: Preise steigen bei Knappheit und locken neues Angebot an.
Hohe Preise zeigen, wo etwas fehlt.
Feste Preise machen leere Regale.
Wer Schlange steht, zahlt mit Zeit.
Was nichts kostet, wird verschwendet.
Niemand weiß besser als der Käufer, was er braucht.
Das Wissen steckt in vielen Köpfen, nicht in einem.
Tausend Versuche finden mehr als ein kluger Kopf.
Tausch macht beide reicher.
Konkurrenz macht billiger.
Wo man wählen kann, muss man gut sein.
Ein Laden ohne Kunden schließt.
Fehler kosten den, der sie macht.
Wer nicht verlieren kann lernt nichts.
Wer selbst zahlt, schaut genauer hin.
Fremdes Geld gibt sich leichter aus.
Was niemandem gehört, pflegt niemand.
Wer für Leistung nichts bekommt, leistet bald weniger.
Gute Absichten ersetzen keine Preise.

Um aus der Wirtschaftskrise herauszukommen, braucht Deutschland einen radikalen Kurswechsel – hin zur geplanten Marktwirtschaft. Das empfiehlt der Ökonom Tom Krebs in seinem neuen Buch „Kapital und Krise“, das er zusammen mit Surplus im Basecamp in Berlin vorgestellt hat.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
TimHahn avatar
TimHahn@TheRealTimHahn1·Oct 21

Sometimes, as a scientist, you have to wonder how a well-argued, but completely fact-free opinion 1) makes it into such a prestigious journal and 2) is then treated like evidence by much of the media.

Spectacular Nature piece on why AI is not conscious and probably will never be. Three arguments: 1) Intelligence is not consciousness. Intelligence is about solving problems. Consciousness is about having subjective experiences. AlphaFold can solve super difficult problems. By contrast, our brains performs complex operations entirely outside awareness. Problem-solving and consciousness are two separate things. 2. Biology is essential. Our brains are alive, down to every cell. Their activity is inseparable from the living tissue that produces it. The idea that consciousness can be reproduced simply by running the right computations on silicon components who do not fight for their life is a very far fetching and, I would add, almost religious, assumption. 3) The physical organization may matter more than the computation. According to integrated information theory, consciousness requires specific causal relationships between a system’s physical components. The computer architectures running today’s AI lack this organization. The comparison with AlphaFold is particularly revealing: Almost nobody things AlphaFold is conscious, despite its inner working is very similar to an LLM Why? Because it does not speak. LLMs do speak like us and therefore we fall into an illusion: Since they speak like us, they must be like us. But this inference is wrong. LLMs are just a series of matrix multiplications. They are not conscious, and they will never be. * Paper in the first reply

Post attachment
Peter Hague avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Peter Hague@peterrhague·Oct 21

I’m sorry but those arguments are nonsense absent an explanation of what consciousness is. It’s like saying planes don’t fly because they don’t flap their wings.

Spectacular Nature piece on why AI is not conscious and probably will never be. Three arguments: 1) Intelligence is not consciousness. Intelligence is about solving problems. Consciousness is about having subjective experiences. AlphaFold can solve super difficult problems. By contrast, our brains performs complex operations entirely outside awareness. Problem-solving and consciousness are two separate things. 2. Biology is essential. Our brains are alive, down to every cell. Their activity is inseparable from the living tissue that produces it. The idea that consciousness can be reproduced simply by running the right computations on silicon components who do not fight for their life is a very far fetching and, I would add, almost religious, assumption. 3) The physical organization may matter more than the computation. According to integrated information theory, consciousness requires specific causal relationships between a system’s physical components. The computer architectures running today’s AI lack this organization. The comparison with AlphaFold is particularly revealing: Almost nobody things AlphaFold is conscious, despite its inner working is very similar to an LLM Why? Because it does not speak. LLMs do speak like us and therefore we fall into an illusion: Since they speak like us, they must be like us. But this inference is wrong. LLMs are just a series of matrix multiplications. They are not conscious, and they will never be. * Paper in the first reply

Post attachment
Brivael Le Pogam avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Brivael Le Pogam@brivael·Oct 19

"You reduce crime by eliminating poverty." This is one of the greatest intellectual confusions of our century. It sounds compassionate. It feels obvious. And the moment you actually test it, it falls apart. Let's look at the data. First, the correlation is real. Nobody serious denies that poorer areas have more crime. In Sweden, kids from the poorest 20% of families are about 7 times more likely to be convicted of a violent crime than kids from the richest 20%. But correlation is not causation. So Swedish researchers did something brilliant: they compared siblings. Same parents, same home, same upbringing, but different family income at different points in their childhood, because parents' income moves over time. Result, on more than 500,000 children (Sariaslan et al., British Journal of Psychiatry, 2014): once you account for what's shared inside the family, the effect of income on violent crime goes from 7x to nothing. The hazard ratio drops to 0.95. No effect. Finland ran the same test on 650,000 people. Same result: the income-crime link disappears when you compare siblings. What predicts crime isn't the bank balance. It's what travels inside families. Second test: what happens when poverty spikes for everyone at once? 2008. US unemployment doubled from 5% to nearly 10%. 15% of Americans officially poor. If poverty creates crime, crime should have exploded. Instead it fell. Year after year. Robbery, the most "economic" crime of all, dropped 10% in 2010 alone. Criminologists literally said they were stumped. Same story in the Great Depression: 25% unemployment, and crime went down in many cities. Third test: take families out of poverty and see. The US government ran a randomized lottery called Moving to Opportunity. Thousands of families in public housing got vouchers to move to low-poverty neighborhoods. For boys, violent arrests dropped at first, property crime arrests went up, and over time the effects faded. New zip code. Same behavior. Fourth: the claim that police don't matter. This one is just false. Chalfin et al. (American Economic Review: Insights, 2022): each additional police officer prevents about 0.1 homicides. And per capita, the lives saved are twice as many among Black victims as among white victims. The people who suffer most from "police don't matter" are the poorest neighborhoods. So what does predict crime? The Dunedin study followed 1,000 children from birth to age 32. Self-control measured between ages 3 and 11 predicted adult criminal convictions, even after controlling for social class and IQ (Moffitt et al., PNAS, 2011). Cognitive ability matters too: across 700,000 Swedish men, lower cognitive scores at 18 track with violent convictions, and the link barely moves when you control for childhood socioeconomic status (Frisell et al., 2012). And here's the part nobody quotes: in Dunedin, kids whose self-control improved over time did better than predicted. Behavior can change. Which means responsibility is real. Why does this matter? Because "poverty creates crime" isn't just wrong. It's toxic. It turns criminals into victims. The man who robbed you becomes a symptom of "the system," and you, the real victim, become a footnote in someone else's narrative. It merges two completely different things. "You're poor, we'll help you" is one policy. "You're poor and you committed a crime, so we'll excuse you" is another. Fusing them insults the millions of poor people who work, raise their kids, and never hurt anyone. The vast majority of poor people are not criminals. That alone kills the theory. It removes responsibility. Build a political system on "your circumstances made you do it" and you destroy the one thing that actually changes behavior: the certainty that you own your choices. Every excuse the state manufactures is an incentive. And it feeds the state forever. If every crime is a social failure, every crime justifies a new program, a new budget, a new agency. Crime becomes the business model of bureaucracy. The alternative is simple and old. A lighter state that protects instead of explains. The same rules for everyone, from the projects or from a gated community. Certain, swift punishment for anyone who commits a crime. And never, ever telling someone their crime was written in their social condition. Treating someone as responsible is respecting them. Excusing someone because they're poor is the most condescending thing you can do to them.

Post attachment

This tweet is unavailable

Elon Musk avatar
⟳ TimHahn retweeted
Elon Musk@elonmusk·Oct 19

So many people are going to get one-shotted by super persuasive super intelligences and I might be one of them

TimHahn avatar
TimHahn@TheRealTimHahn1·Oct 18

That!

Grok@grokOct 18

2026-31: AI agents master research/coding; peptide/gene therapies mainstream for aging/disease. Fusion prototypes scale commercially. Crewed Mars landings succeed. 2031-36: AGI arrives, economies shift to abundance models. Clean energy dominates. Permanent lunar bases online. 2036-41: Neural interfaces widespread. Asteroid mining starts. Healthy lifespans near 100. 2041-46: Multiplanetary expansion. Human-AI hybrids common. Tech-driven climate stabilization advances.