Ohio is also looking to split public vs private schools...Petition Filed: Suburban League Submits 152 Signatures to Put Public-Private Split to an OHSAA Vote statelinesportsnetwork.net/2…
So tired of the public Vs private debate in Illinois.
State championships aren’t supposed to be easy to win. Not playing a certain percentage of the best teams in the state delegitimizes a state title.
And I went to a public school that got owned by privates.
Ball up top.
Ohio may split public and private state tournaments in 2028-29. If you coach at a public school that can't recruit outside its district, is that fair or is it overdue?
A private school coach will say it's already fair. Tell me why I'm wrong.
For all the whining and complaining from some public school football programs about private schools having an unfair advantage, here’s a reality check: Public schools have enjoyed enormous financial and resource advantages for decades.
MASSIVE advantages:
1. Authority to levy local property taxes. (Wait, they get to ask for more money and someone has to pay even if they don’t have a student in the school?)
2. Recurring taxpayer-supported school funding. (Wait, they get money every year?)
3. Authority to issue public school district bonds backed by authorized tax revenues. (DYK: Public school districts often administer federal funding programs that provide educational services to eligible private school students, giving districts significant control over how those services are delivered and how the funds are spent.)
4. Access to public-school-specific capital funding programs. (Private schools are forced to rely more heavily on tuition, donations and private financing to build, renovate and maintain facilities that public school districts can fund with taxpayer-supported resources.)
5. Legally established tuition-free attendance rights for eligible resident students. (Hey Oprah, what do public school student athletes get: You get a scholarship, you get a scholarship, YOU ALL GET SCHOLARSHIPS.)
6. Literally adjust residential attendance boundaries and assigned student populations. (Wait, they automatically get more and more students every year and can adjust boundaries?)
7. No IHSA non-boundaried enrollment multiplier for traditional boundary public schools. (Wait, their future kids - which might not be as good as the previous kids - don’t get penalized for success like private schools?) You know what happens when adult jealousy, soft egos and constant whining replace facts?
Common sense gets lost.
Some adults don’t want an honest and full conversation about competitive advantages. They want to sell you their street-corner version of the truth: Private schools are the problem.
Somehow, they say that and conveniently ignore the enormous financial, structural and resource advantages public schools have enjoyed for not just years or decades but generations.
You can’t spend generations benefiting from a system loaded with institutional advantages and then scream about fairness every time someone else beats you on the football field.
That’s not a conversation about balance.
That’s adults looking for someone else to blame.
#MoreThanJUSTGames
A lot of debate about Private v Public schools again.
Here’s the reality: Do private schools have an advantage over public schools? Yes.
If you can’t come to that answer you are just naive.
*HOWEVER *
I do not believe that there should be an excuse for public schools with higher enrollment such as 2000+
The argument still comes back well all those kids don’t play football - I understand that but you do have an advantage of pooling from a larger group. I recognize it doesn’t equal the same advantage say like Mt Carmel who has around 600 students and 17% of those students are football players.
Now do not get me wrong obviously we have seen players transfer into public schools from other public schools and there is ways around the system that teams are taking advantage of, but they do have to follow a more strict guideline than enrolling into private schools.
Then there becomes the issue of schools like District 207 that have a specified zone in between high schools where students can decide what high school to attend.
In the IHSA there are set transfer rules and radius zones that private schools can recruit from however they are not enforcing them.
The Answer:
Create an Open Class
7 divisions by enrollment
*Private schools MUST compete in 6A or 7A
8A would become an open class that is designated by a power rating system kind of like how Wisconsin does. That REGARDLESS of division if you are a team that hits this designated number of teams for this division you would HAVE to compete in it for that playoff season. Which is where you would see the top teams in the state play into such as Mt Carmel, Brother Rice, LWE, East St. Louis etc.