←
#Think3215,390 posts
#Think32 avatar

#Think32

@Think32_

Cross community, non-party political movement to promote & encourage debate on reunification of Ireland #Think32. We've 1 rule, please be respectful.

◷ Joined July 2015▧ 829 Photos and videos
John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

If the UK reneges on pensions, including employment based pensions, there is no real world in which Ireland volunteers to take on debt and no way for the UK to force the issue. A united Ireland cannot end up with both debt and pensions - in the worst case scenario its either /or.

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

There is no basis in national, contract or international law for UK debt to be passed on to a united Ireland, it could only be done voluntarily by an Irish govt.  If something else was on the table it might be negotiated.

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

High cost reports all assume that a united Ireland will be responsible for 100% of pension payments to people resident in NI (including 100% of all public sector employment based pensions - c. €5b) and also will take a proportion of the UK state debt (around €4b).

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

Reports with high cost figures have not allowed for tax, prsi, USC and pension contributions on a pay rise. As public sector workers know, they will overwhelmingly return over 50% of any pay rise to the state in such contributions. (reducing the actual costs by €2.9b in year 1)

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

(iii) there will be issues to negotiate with trade unions, as in addition to wages, terms and conditions also differ north and south in complex ways.

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

(i) Cost of living will not incr. by 48% immediately, it will converge slowly. (ii) increasing pay, for 29% of the workforce by 48% in 1 year, would cause local inflation, & disruption to the private sector, who need time to build profitability to ROI levels & to adjust wages

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

The reports that get anywhere close to €24b make assumptions which are not credible, e.g. a. Granting public sector workers (29% of the workforce) an average pay increase of 48% in year one of a united Ireland. The report makes clear that this is not credible.

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

The report does not say that we cannot narrow the range between €3b and €24b - it summarises what has been published by others, and then looks at some of the calculations. It is possible to narrow down - see my Book Before the Vote. In brief , below dcupress.dcu.ie/book/before-…

John Doyle avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
John Doyle@JohnDoyleDCU·Nov 12

I have had a lot of questions over the past few days regarding media coverage of the Fine Gael proposals on preparing for a united Ireland, and in particular the detailed report on the economics of unity by Prof Stephen Kinsella. finegael.ie/unifiedisland/ A few thoughts:

Suzanne Breen avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
Suzanne Breen@SuzyJourno·Nov 9

Unionism’s worst fears are edging closer: it’s just 4 points away from the unthinkable. Staying in the UK leads Irish unity only among the over-55s in @LucidTalk poll. A border poll is a matter of when, not if. And marching backwards definitely won't work. belfasttelegraph.co.uk/comme…

Leo Varadkar avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
Leo Varadkar@LeoVaradkar·Nov 9

Just 4% in it now. Still too soon for ''unity poll'' as there is no stable majority for unification in the North just yet. But it is coming. Time to prepare - north and south. The FG blueprint published at the weekend sets out some of the next steps that should be now be taken. It is timely and welcome 🇨🇮☘️😀

More results from the LucidTalk Autumn26 NI 'Tracker' poll (3,989 sample, NI rep. sample) as reported in the @BelTel today (9/11) - Q6: If there were a referendum (i.e. a ‘Border poll’) on the constitutional position of Northern Ireland today, - How would you vote?

Post attachment
Ireland's Future - Todhchaí na hÉireann avatar
⟳ #Think32 retweeted
Ireland's Future - Todhchaí na hÉireann@IrelandsFuture·Nov 6

🚨Protestant voices north and south are a very important part of the unity process 🚨Monday night in UCD we welcome four people who are from Protestant backgrounds to our event 🚨This is our first panel discussion of the evening 🚨Make sure to Register

Post attachment