←
Tim Bartik11,025 posts
Tim Bartik avatar

Tim Bartik

@TimBartik

Senior economist at the Upjohn Institute for Employment Research

◷ Joined August 2012▧ 128 Photos and videos
Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Nov 15

Main points: Problems of distressed places are persistent & diverse, require diverse solutions. Most cost-effective solutions rely less on tax incentives, more on customized business services such as customized training. Helping distressed places can boost overall national jobs.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Oct 14

(3) It is plausible that reformed policies -- customized services, targeting distressed places, more housing as population grows -- can over 20 years have fiscal benefits exceeding costs.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Oct 14

(2) Key to making incentives have larger effects on per capita incomes, and lower fiscal costs, are to move from cash to customized business services. Targeting and more elastic housing supply also helps - however, targeting only makes major difference if tightly targeted.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Oct 14

What suprised me: (1) Altho current incentives costly, they clearly are insufficient to have major effects on state per-capita incomes.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Oct 14

My report on reforming state incentives released today. 5-page summary: research.upjohn.org/cgi/view… Conclusions: current incentives have modest returns and large costs. Reforms that use more cost-effective services & target distressed places & reform housing can increase returns 6x

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Sep 15

Why such high benefits? (1) adding training helps increase proportion of jobs for Chattanooga residents; (2) training is more cost-effective per job induced than typical business tax incentives.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Sep 15

My report (with 2 colleagues) on impact of adding training to business tax incentives in Chattanooga is being released today: research.upjohn.org/up_techn… Bottom-line: adding training has benefit/cost ratio > 25 to 1.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Jun 9

Housing policy: B/C for incentives goes up if housing supply grows to accommodate population growth. This avoids effective multipliers being reduced by feedbacks from higher local costs.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Jun 9

Design: B/C goes up if avoid excessive incentives per direct job, put more emphasis on incentives that are customized services, and enforce clawbacks.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Jun 9

Targeting: B/C goes up if target more distressed places and higher multiplier projects.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Jun 9

The devil is in the details. B/C ratio is affected greatly by project targeting, incentive design, & housing policy.

Tim Bartik avatar
Tim Bartik@TimBartik·Jun 9

The report finds that the median project has benefits 47% > incentive cost. But wide variance: 13 projects have B/C ratio > 3 to 1, and 7 projects have B/C ratio less than 0.5.