A small announcement: my next book, Everything is Predictable, about how Bayes' theorem is the most important little equation in the world, is out in April and will look like this! If you'd like to pre-order, you can do so here geni.us/EIPBook and I will be very grateful
It's very depressing that Bender and Gebru are still able to make this move where they can glue a bunch of poorly thought out philosophical claims together, describe it as a "technical explainer," and use this to bully people in a lot of circles out of using a clearly amazing pro-social tool like Pangram. The idea that using Pangram is racist is so obviously ridiculous but will still fly in a lot of places.
Of course this is Gebru and Bender. The link isn't "technical" + now many serious papers on whether frontier detectors empirically have or theoretically could have ~0 false positives. They can & do. So frustrating Dror & I had to write an op-ed countering this misinformation. 1/3
Incredibly important role here - 'Pacing the Frontier' lead at Anthropic.
Would benefit from someone very sharp and strong willed.
Please please apply if you could do a great job at this: job-boards.greenhouse.io/ant…
A perfect synedoche for the problem of political communication in democracy: the wrong view that panders to preexisting prejudices can be expressed in 280 characters to express and gets 1M views. The right view is a whole ass essay that takes +120 IQ to grok. It nets 690 likes.
The FAA literally grounded every flight in the US over a nationwide communications outage, and Uber’s immediate response is to charge stranded passengers $100–$200 just to go a few miles from the airport. Profiteering off a national travel crisis isn't "dynamic pricing." It's predatory.
Flying back from London to US and just as I was going through security at Heathrow, they announced a minute of silence for Armistice Day. Bugle, everything stops, total silence, then bugle again. Incredibly moving and truly a national thing.
We could use something like that.
The Caine Prize, which awarded its top prize this year to a story Pangram classifies as almost entirely AI-generated, conducted an investigation and found "no evidence" of AI use.
Strangely, their official statement on Instagram seems to also be blatantly AI-generated.
Couple thoughts:
1) After several people pointed out that Lyman couldn't substitute all-cause mortality for malaria-specific mortality like he had done, he fixed it. His initial estimate for $/lives saved was $19000; revised it’s about $8,200.
2) I think, though I could be wrong about this, that his calculation to get $8200 still has a problem: he calculates the costs of the distribution based on the whole population but the benefits based on 75% of the population (since he argues the other 25% is already sleeping under nets). But as he himself identifies, the nice thing about an intention-to-treat analysis is that you don't need to do this and shouldn't: you just ask how much to expect mortality to fall in a village after handing out the nets, and the answer is 17%. (You only care about the fact some people are already sleeping under nets if that makes your village unlike the one where the 17% was measured; more on that below.) If he changed this one factor this would make his numbers quite close to GiveWell's.
3) He then applies an adjustment for the long-term: "If bednets reduced short-run all-cause mortality by 18% in the 1990s and maybe reduce it by (who knows?) 14% today, they probably reduce actual child mortality (i.e. across 5 years of early childhood) by 7-11%."
But GiveWell actually accounts for that even more stringently by just excluding all benefits past the first two years, one of several places where they are intentionally conservative.
4) He accuses GiveWell of misrepresenting Cochrane's statistics but they actually just report a bunch of different numbers and I think he mixed them up. He complains "GiveWell cites that review to support a “45% reduction in malaria incidence.” That’s an error, that review did not find a 45% reduction in malaria incidence." But the review absolutely does report almost exactly that: "Insecticide-treated nets also reduce the incidence of uncomplicated episodes of Plasmodium falciparum malaria by almost a half (rate ratio 0.55, 95% CI 0.48 to 0.64; 5 trials, 35,551 participants, high-certainty evidence". Rate ratio 0.55 means a 45% reduction.
5) He expresses concern that a lot of the Cochrane studies are old and describe a different environment (Africa in the late 1990s/early 2000s). However, GiveWell's most recent grant to nets in the DRC - which I believe that my donations helped to fund - is based on data from a 2023-2024 large scale demographic survey in the DRC, so the nets are being distributed in an environment very close to the one studied. It found about a 14% all-cause mortality reduction in the first year after a distribution, close to the 17% in Cochrane.
He also expresses concern that Cochrane's mortality estimate here is low-powered but I don't think it is (the analysis says "rate ratio 0.83, 95% CI 0.77 to 0.89; 5 trials, 200,833 participants, high-certainty evidence") so it's between 11% and 23% with a 95% CI!
6) He also raises questions about whether there are more people trying to hand out nets than nets to be handed out. GiveWell looked into that and determined that in the DRC, there was not enough funding to do all the distributions that were indicated, in part because the Global Fund caps how much it'll spend in any one country.
7) Finally, he argues we should instead - from an altruistic perspective - spend our money however maximizes GDP. But I think there's a serious case that health interventions like combatting malaria are necessary for GDP growth to take off in DRC, just like the American South was kind of a backwater until we eradicated malaria there. Being constantly sick is horrible for productivity. Being only able to hire employees who are constantly sick is horrible for a business environment. GiveWell estimates that a $1,000,000 donation increases adult income for 80,000 children by 0.6%, which means that much of their modelled benefit of malaria nets *is* their GDP effects.
My best guess is that if you were a hard-nosed GDP maxxer you'd invest a lot in reducing the disease burden in poor countries. Or maybe you'd go all in on making AI happen as fast as possible, something I rarely see EAs criticized for failing to do. I would probably donate more money to making AI go well if I had more of an idea of how to do that and it wouldn't create a bunch of conflicts of interest with my reporting work.
I agree it would be cool if there were an organization focused on effective institutional capacity building in poor countries, but the reason I and man others don't donate to this is not that everyone fails to realize how important institutions are, it's that even though many people have worked very hard on the problem for a long time they do not have a way better than the nets to turn my money into GDP growth in poor countries.
There was a bit of a Our World In Data article I read this fall that has stuck with me:
"I’ve never had malaria, but I know several people who have. They describe it as one of the worst experiences of their life.
What starts out feeling like the flu — which is bad enough — can quickly progress into something far worse. The body swings from intense fever and sweats to chills deep enough to make you shake uncontrollably. Everything aches, from your muscles and joints to the pounding headache that makes it impossible to think clearly. Your body is so fatigued that it’s a battle to make it to the bathroom when the nausea and vomiting arrive.
That’s what a pretty standard infection feels like. For some, it goes much further. Here is how one account describes it:
“I awoke to what felt like lightning going through my legs, and then spreading through my body and in my head. Probably the worst headache, body aches, and chills you could possibly imagine. It felt like I was being stung repeatedly by an electric shock gun and could barely control my movements. The pain was so intense; I actually believed I was dying, literally crying out in pain so bad that I was taken to a 24-hour clinic that night at 3am.”
In Senegal, the median child experienced 43 attacks of malaria over the course of their childhood. My hard-nosed productivity obsessed persona says "I bet that's rough on their human capital development, and it's quite cheap to prevent." But mostly I don't, actually, say that to myself. I just buy some nets. If something even better comes along I'll do that, but I haven't seen it yet.
Britain has so much good in it, it’s just weighed down by years of this sort of built-up crud which hasn’t been cleaned out. Every piece of this mess made someone feel nice when they implemented it but the cumulative effect is stagnation
Right now, British electricity pricing is bonkers. Prices are disconnected the from the underlying reality in several very important ways.
1. The costs of keeping the grid going, like transmission and balancing, are spread over every unit of electricity sold. This means the price of an extra unit of electricity is vastly higher than the social cost of providing that unit. The cost of having a grid connection at all is, conversely, much lower than it actually costs society to provide you one.
Economically, this amounts to a crippling price cap on grid connections, which is part of why we can't expand infrastructure to plug people in: they don't pay for it. It also amounts to an enormous tax, over 2/3 of the price of electricity, on using an extra unit of it.
Which is presumably why electricity use has cratered since 2003, when we started driving up the cost of our grid like this.
Note how perverse the incentive is here. We are heading into a situation where electricity is extremely expensive because the ratio of grid costs to the amount of electricity put through that grid. Our high prices incentivise everyone to have a connection, but then to use it as little as possible, the EXACT opposite of what we need. We charge the most tax on people use their connection most intensively (i.e., efficiently) and the least on those who use it the least intensively!
2. We impose carbon taxes on electricity produced through gas that we don't impose on gas used directly. This is part of why electricity is so expensive, and means people electrify less than we would like, which leads to less decarbonisation overall. A child, with a basic understanding of supply and demand, would see how perverse this is.
3. We charge the same price for electricity nationwide, and pay the same amount, in a single market, even though electricity is worth more and less at different places. This is part of why people are building solar farms in Scotland, where it is not only less sunny, but which is on the other side of massive grid congestion that we are paying BILLIONS of pounds to relieve. Yet we keep paying people to make the problem worse.
4. We keep buying Contracts for Difference off electricity generators. CfDs say 'we will pay you X for every unit of electricity you produce, whenever you produce it'. (Recent iterations have cut off these payments when prices go negative, but they will still pay them £90 per megawatt hour when the megawatts they are producing are worth 1p each!)
Renewables Obligations Certificates were a lot more honest. They just paid producers a top up on what they got on the open market: a straightforward subsidy. CfDs are a totally hidden subsidy. The amount of subsidy is set by the market trajectory after today. So, for example, every time we sign a new wind CfD we increase the subsidy for past tranches.
The really messed up thing is that CfD recipients do not cover for when they don't provide any power. If the CfD was set on quantity as well, so generators had to pay back money when they didn't produce, to cover the cost of running the grid to accommodate them, and for the gas needed to keep the lights on, then we would get a good sense of how much we were actually paying. Buying a CfD would be buying new electricity at its going rate. Instead, practically all the important pricing functions are hidden.
The result of all these broken pricing systems is poor coordination. Everyone is working exactly as the price system tells them to: plug in but only use your grid connection when the grid is having trouble, use less electricity, don't electrify, add generation far away from where it is consumed, and produce the most electricity possible whenever and wherever you like, not when or where it's rare and expensive. The ultimate result is expensive electricity, industrial decline, and economic stagnation.
A small theory of mine is that Rishi Sunak’s decision to set up the AISI might be one of the most important prime ministerial decisions of this century.
Is the UK Government literally #1 in the world in terms of how well it's preparing for AGI, given the resources it has available?
After last week's budget, I think so.
Puts some other countries to shame really.