←
Tom Stringham2,165 posts
Tom Stringham avatar

Tom Stringham

@TomStringham
◷ Joined December 2012▧ 118 Photos and videos
Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

Either way, polygamy probably hangs on longer in this scenario, though I would guess not forever. BC ends up bigger and the island much more developed, and Canada a richer, more interesting country, while Utah remains a desert wasteland. 9/9

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

Possibly Canada would have agreed to let the Saints keep polygamy in exchange for joining. Or maybe not, leaving LDS BC to go on its own, maybe declaring independence from Britain at some point or maybe eventually getting swallowed into the US after all. 8/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

But then what would have happened in 1871, when Canada begged BC to join Confederation? An LDS BC would’ve been considerably more populous and powerful than the small frontier colony that was won over with the promise of a railroad in 1871, giving them a lot of leverage. 7/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

A big sticking point would’ve been polygamy. That may well have been why the British didn’t grant the petition in the first place. But as the HBC recognized, if the Saints had decided to settle on the largely uninhabited island, no one would have been able to stop them. 6/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

that the Saints had “no rights of occupation whatever”. For all we know this could have been the plan; BY was willing to burn everything down if needed, and if the church hadn’t been able to strike a deal using their contacts with the US who knows what would’ve happened. 5/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

HBC was nervous when the Saints arrived in the valley and started trading with their posts in now-Idaho. During the Utah War they feared the Saints would abandon Utah and make the trek to Vancouver Island. So did the imperial government: the island’s governor was instructed 4/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

permission to settle Vancouver Island and help doing it. The British were looking for settlers so it wasn’t a crazy idea. At least one MP wrote back asking for more details. But the Hudson’s Bay Company was very against the idea; they ended up getting control in 1849. 3/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

the reach of the US government. They looked seriously at Texas but it was headed toward annexation, and California wasn’t isolated enough. They liked the idea of being under British rule. They went as far as sending a petition with 13,000 signatures to Parliament, requesting 2/

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 17

There’s a fun alternate reality where the Saints settled Vancouver Island instead of the Salt Lake valley and Canada is 15% LDS instead of the US being 1-2% LDS. Even before JS died, the church was looking for places for the Saints to settle that were beyond 1/

Dr. Mike P. Moffatt 🇨🇦🏅🏅 avatar
⟳ Tom Stringham retweeted
Dr. Mike P. Moffatt 🇨🇦🏅🏅@MikePMoffatt·Nov 11

New piece at the Globe! Property tax deferral and exemption programs get more generous every year, and a growing movement is pushing for a full exemption for seniors. But... If homeowning seniors pay less property tax, who will pick up the bill? theglobeandmail.com/investin…

Alison Somin avatar
⟳ Tom Stringham retweeted
Alison Somin@AlisonSomin·Nov 6

1. Forgive me for screenshotting a paywalled newsletter, but can’t resist sharing Matt Yglesias’s take on Democrats, affirmative action, and the Moderation that Dare Not Speak Its Name.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 6

States all having state-level elections on the same day keeps things simple, but it leads to people always voting based on national vibes. Last month BC had an election and it was a whole thing with its own, strange story. The parties aren’t even the same as the federal ones.

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 4

Proud of church members who closed ranks in Idaho to defeat a popular but extreme abortion ballot measure.

Post attachment
Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 3

Maybe you're not convinced, but imo do take Elder Cook's devo seriously, go ruminate on it. Maybe there is some deep wisdom in your decision to be anon online, but on the other hand, maybe not and this devo from EQLC is your sign to let it go and it'll be OK. 8/8

Tom Stringham avatar
Tom Stringham@TomStringham·Nov 3

Elder Cook notes that the mob that tarred and feathered Joseph Smith covered their faces with soot, but also that JS still recognized some of them the next day. Often anonymity leads someone to do something regrettable but then doesn't even protect them in the end. 7/