Works in Progress is a magazine of new and underrated ideas to improve the world. Subscribe to our new print edition now. We are proud to be part of @Stripe.
Works in Progress is now available to buy in 570 Barnes & Nobles across America, as well as Hudson News branches in most major airports.
Post a photo of yourself with your copy outside any brand on social media, and share your post with us, and we'll send you a free Works in Progress tote.
worksinprogress.co/barnes-no…
Another generation of European politicians is about to waste billions of euros and years in court trying to processing asylum claims overseas. The obsession with this idea comes fom a total myth, namely that it worked in Australia.
Australia did briefly process asylum seekers offshore. But as Amelia Wood showed in a piece for WIP, this almost certainly wasn’t what made the difference:
- When Australia relied on offshore processing alone in 2012, arrivals didn’t drop.
- A tougher version introduced in 2013 didn’t reduce them either.
- Offshore transfers ended altogether in 2014, yet arrivals stayed at zero for the following decade.
Instead, what did all the work in Australia was turnbacks: consistently towing boats back to Indonesia. It's cheaper, more humane, and far more effective than offshore processing.
JUST IN:
“Taking back control” of borders by sending failed asylum-seekers/migrants to Rwanda.
Danish PM Mette Frederiksen hopes the pilot project her country, Austria, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands will launch next year will deter people from coming to the EU. 1/
My first column for Works in Progress!
Science isn’t a series of lucky accidents.
I’ve been investigating stories of scientific discoveries for a while and it’s surprising how much the popular retellings flatten the real stories; some are entirely made up.
Alexander Fleming’s discovery of penicillin most likely didn’t come from an open window.
His colleagues testified the window was seldom, if ever, opened. The sequence hasn’t been replicated as he described, because penicillin would have needed to be present on the plate before the bacteria grew, as it blocks bacteria from building their cell walls, rather than killing them once they’ve grown.
Louis Pasteur’s discovery of the chicken cholera vaccine – the second-ever vaccine – is often said to be accidental too.
But historians have found the key experiments were done deliberately by Émile Roux, his assistant at the time, while Pasteur was away for his daughter’s wedding.
Wilhelm Röntgen’s accidental discovery of X-rays? The story was just a hypothesis by others later on.
Röntgen had his notes burned after his death, so it’s unclear what really happened. He had also long been in a dispute with Philipp Lenard over credit for the discovery, so there are reasons to be suspicious.
**
But what really happened? How did Fleming actually discover penicillin? Why burn or hide your notebooks? And most of all, why credit chance events instead of hard work?
For the first time, I’ve decided to come up with some half-cooked theories. Read them here and tell me what you think:
worksinprogress.co/issue/acc…
Famously, very few books accurately predict how the next war will go. Guderian's Achtung! Panzer was one. The Arms of the Future by @Jack_Watling is, in my view, another.
worksinprogress.co/issue/the…
Simplifying a bit, only three things fundamentally determine how armies fight: how far they can see, how far they can shoot, and how deadly each shot is.
Over the last few decades, all three have increased relentlessly. Everyone has seen the videos of drones from Ukraine. But sensors of all kinds are getting better: ground-based radars can spot tanks tens of kilometers away, and acoustic sensors can pick up the heartbeats of individual soldiers. Once the enemy is spotted, it is much easier to kill them: a WW2 artillery shell landed within 50 meters half of the time at 20 kilometers; a modern one lands within 2 meters half of the time at 70 kilometers.
In this new world, there are only three ways to fight: by hiding in a hole in a field, by hiding in a city, or by attacking the sensors.
Read my review in Works in Progress
Famously, very few books accurately predict how the next war will go. Guderian's Achtung! Panzer was one. The Arms of the Future by @Jack_Watling is, in my view, another.
worksinprogress.co/issue/the…
Simplifying a bit, only three things fundamentally determine how armies fight: how far they can see, how far they can shoot, and how deadly each shot is.
Over the last few decades, all three have increased relentlessly. Everyone has seen the videos of drones from Ukraine. But sensors of all kinds are getting better: ground-based radars can spot tanks tens of kilometers away, and acoustic sensors can pick up the heartbeats of individual soldiers. Once the enemy is spotted, it is much easier to kill them: a WW2 artillery shell landed within 50 meters half of the time at 20 kilometers; a modern one lands within 2 meters half of the time at 70 kilometers.
In this new world, there are only three ways to fight: by hiding in a hole in a field, by hiding in a city, or by attacking the sensors.
Read my review in Works in Progress
We're looking for business writers!
Works in Progress is expanding into coverage of business and finance, and we're looking for freelance authors for extended feature-length pieces of 2,000-6,000 words. We will eventually be hiring full-time employees on this beat.
Find the most interesting company in the world, a brilliant financial model, or a telling and relevant piece of business history. Tell us why we should be fascinated by it too.
It could be the geography of an industry, like how Morocco grew to become an massive exporter of cars, or why Bangladesh can do in electronics what it has done with its massive textiles industry. It might be a piece on a new kind of business, like the firms trying to perfect proof of personhood in a world of super-powerful AI. You could write about unsung but vital pieces of hardware, like compressed air and industrial gas, which keep the most advanced manufacturing sites in the world going.
The subject can be lighthearted or momentous, but the piece should cover something you haven't seen everywhere else, which advances an argument and marshals strong evidence. It should be relevant to a broad group of intelligent readers, and enduring rather than short-lived. And we're absolutely definitely not looking for traditional PR pitches. A sense that you've read and understand something about WIP's output goes a long way.
If this sounds like your kind of thing, please send us 1-3 short paragraphs summing up your idea. If we're intrigued by your idea we may ask you for an outline over a page or two. We pay competitive rates to authors.
Email us at wip-pitches@stripe.com and mike@worksinprogress.co.
Stephen Kotkin is one of the great historians of Eurasia. In a new series for Works in Progress, he tackles the biggest question of them all: what went wrong between America and China? In the first part, he explains why we shouldn’t expect China to go the way of the Soviet Union. Beijing’s leaders have internalized the obvious lesson from Moscow: No Gorbachev. But they have also done something subtler: fix the incentives that made Soviet elites think that they had something to gain from ending communism.
worksinprogress.co/issue/sov…
If you’re not reading @WorksInProgMag or @stripepress in general, you’re missing out.
I recommend @tylercowen’s “Stubborn Attachments”, Richard Hamming’s “The Art of Doing Science and Engineering”, and M. Mitchell Waldrop’s “The Dream Machine”
Love all the shared knowledge 🫶
Big thanks to @lennysan for featuring WIP in this year’s holiday gift guide, which remains (objectively and without any bias whatsoever) the best in the business.
Today is a huge day for Works in Progress, but it could be a huge day for you too. As of this morning, WIP is now available for sale in *570* Barnes & Noble stores across the United States, including four in Manhattan and two in Brooklyn, for my local pals.
Go to your local B&N store and send a picture of yourself with a copy, send me a picture, and receive a free tote bag!
From today, Works in Progress is now in stock at Barnes & Nobles nationwide across America.
We're in 570 stores in 49 states*, including the flagship stores at Union Square & Fifth Avenue in NYC; Georgetown, DC; State Street, Chicago; and The Grove, Los Angeles.
We're also now in Hudson News outlets across most major US airports, and the B&Ns at San Francisco Airport.
If you tweet (or LinkedIn/Insta post) a photo of a copy of Works in Progress outside any of these stores, share the post with me or @WorksInProgMag via DM and we'll send you a free tote bag as a thank you. If you're a subscriber already, feel free to do it with own copy!
You can see a full map of Barnes & Noble stockists here, and enter your Zip code to find your nearest store.
*Sorry, Wyoming, we'll get to you!
worksinprogress.co/barnes-no…
We’re delighted to announce that @danwwang is making his debut as a contributor, with a column for this issue of @WorksInProgress.
worksinprogress.co/issue/sic…
Few people understand the China–US contrast as well as Dan Wang, and fewer still write about it with so much talent. His book Breackneck has introduced the now famous meme of China as a “country of engineers” and United States as a “country of lawyers,” to explain the differences in building capacity and physical world stagnation we are seeing between the two polities.
In his new column for us, he takes up one specific thread in the long-running debate over how China and the US compare and argues that both owe part of their power to being polycentric.
One observation is that both the American and US capitals are not their biggest cities. Vienna, London, Seoul and Paris dwarf their countries’ second cities, by four to seven times. By contrast, Beijing isn’t China’s largest city, and DC isn’t even in the top five in the US. Does this make US and China lame, for having smol capitals? No! On the contrary, Dan thinks that this friction between political and economic centers is important and at least partially explains why both countries can combine dynamism with strong states.
But the two countries are polycentric in very different ways. China’s regions are culturally distinct and are shaped heavily by geography. While coastal provinces tend to look outward, mountain areas like Sichuan and Chongqing are characterized by evading the center’s edicts. Dan also points out some misconceptions: yes, China has central control, but it is weaker than it look. Local officials often ignore or quietly subvert senseless directives from Beijing, with enforcement thinning out quickly beyond the big cities.
The characteristic feature of American polycentrism is how well it sorts people into domains and “sends” them to specific cities: this is reminiscent of the point @patio11 has made around “The Sort.” In America, the smartest and most driven tend to cluster in a handful of cities, above all New York and San Francisco, with Washington and Boston are slightly behind them. More than this: each field has an obvious center: AI has its capital in SF, for policy and politics you have DC, for finance New York and for biotech Boston and more recently, SF.
Different cities in America also prize different things: Miami values looking good, Boston being intelligent and bookish, LA how famous you are and New York how rich you are. There is so much variety in terms of who you can choose to become in America. And the city you decide to live in might end up shaping who you are, moreso than in any other country!
Works in Progress has deep British roots. We think our origins explain much about our character and the specific ways in which we care about ideas. A less British WiP would not be WiP. A unique culture and intellectual environment that it gan gift to the world is just one of the reasons why we want the British civilization to prosper.
But civilizations need multiple elements to preserve themselves, and one of those elements is material prosperity and economic growth: these are the basis of everything else. Without them, it's hard to achieve higher-order human flourishing.
We are excited to organize this event with @LSEnews, on how Britain can maximally take advantage of the AI revolution. It's late, but hopefully not too late!
Join Works in Progress at Building Abundance: How Britain can flourish in the age of AI, a day of ideas for rebuilding Britain’s economy and state so it can adapt to and embrace artificial intelligence and other opportunities for growth.
luma.com/ria1khmw
Sessions include:
- @Dominic2306 and Morgan McSweeney in conversation on the decline and fall of British state capacity,
- @JohnFingleton1 on the Nuclear Taskforce and its implementation by the government, one year on from its pledge to implement it in full.
- @bswud, @SCP_Hughes and me on why nearly every attempt to get Britain building has failed;
- @rachelwolf on what the public really thinks about economic growth and AI;
- @lugaricano on messy jobs and Britain’s labour market;
- @jujulemons on why Britain needs gigawatt-scale compute, and how to get it built here;
- @salonium on why fixing clinical trials is the best industrial policy Britain could have;
- @MichaelDnes1 on building the first new tunnel under the Pennines since 1954;
- @RobertBoswall on how to finance and power the data centre buildout; and
- @daisychristo on why VAR matters for state capacity.
It will be held on Thursday 3rd December at the LSE, from 1pm to 7:30pm (doors open 1pm for a 1:20pm start). We're hosting it in association with the LSE Law School and School of Public Policy. Tickets are free.
See you there!
luma.com/ria1khmw