←
William Fitzpatrick3,654 posts
William Fitzpatrick avatar

William Fitzpatrick

@WriterScience

Day job: English professor, Nonfiction writing coach; Building: Writer Science—Studying the art and science of expert writing, sharing what I learn

◷ Joined March 2021▧ 745 Photos and videos
William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Aug 3

A good essay is like a set of instructions: it gives readers the info they need in the places and order they expect to find it. Here are the five structural locations that readers use to interpret your essay—the places where they expect to find the answers to certain questions. These reader expectations are unconscious. But if you anticipate consciously what your readers expect intuitively, then you make your essay much more readable and valuable.

20:28
William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 17

One question that fixes unclear sentences: Who does what? This question roots out the characters and actions buried in unclear writing. Then you can put them back where they belong: characters in the subject position, and actions in the verb.

1:43

To improve your writing: audit the verbs. Reserve the verb ‘to be’ (and its analogues: seems, appears, means) for describing (the weather is sunny) and defining (the weather is the climate and atmosphere). Aside from these use cases, if you notice a buildup of ‘to be’, odds are the actions are hiding in nouns. Put important actions in the verb.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 17

I have this formula posted to my computer screen: Work = output Output = volume * leverage It’s not just about how hard you paddle (volume); it matters which boat you’re in (leverage).

Kevin O’Leary gets CHALLENGED by a security guard who works 80 HOURS A WEEK after arguing that ANYONE can become WEALTHY through hard work, only for the guard to reveal that 55% of his income goes to RENT and he’s applied to HUNDREDS of jobs without success, questioning how much HARDER he’s supposed to work 😲👀

4:55
William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 16

The usage wars are alive and well. Grammar is like physics: it tells writers what is permitted, but not which permissible option to choose. So how do you know whether a given language choice is better or worse? Oliver Kamm says, within the constraints of grammar, anything goes: if you can find an example of a given language choice used by a good writer, then it's ipso facto an exemple of good writing. I think a more sensible ruling on whether a given language choice is better or worse can be made by appealing not to some arbitrary rule nor to the authority of writers who used it in the past, but by the reader's experience. For example, here we debate the question of whether personal pronouns (I, we) should be used in academic registers. Kamm says yes, because a famous philosopher used them 120 years ago. I say rarely, if ever: the personal pronoun should be used only when a claim needs its author in order to be considered valid by the reader; otherwise the pronoun pulls the reader’s attention from the evidence to the writer. Maybe appropriate in more personal genres, but not in academic registers. The only rules of writing are grammar; everything else is a recommendation. The question is, on what basis can we make those recommendations—authority and popularity, as Kamm insists; or the reader's experience?

Done addressing every red herring you threw in the way of the point—that descriptivism fails because it conflates grammar (an innate capacity, as Pinker rightly points out) with language usage, a set of conventions which are learned and taught. To offer an analogy you'll no doubt dismiss as silly without establishing why, in the UK you drive on the left side of the road. Any American who argues that you drive on the 'wrong' side of the road is obviously an idiot. We agree about that much. But it's equally stupid to argue, as you do, that one can drive on either side of the road or straight down the middle on the basis that doing so isn't forbidden by the laws of physics or that certain historical figures drove on the opposite side of the road to perfect utility. Driving and language are each constrained by certain immutable laws—i.e., physics and grammar. But within their degrees of freedom, they're also governed by shared conventions that everyone has to agree upon in order for each to work as a public resource. (If you doubt that language is a public resource, see Wittgenstein's discussion on private language.) Are these conventions arbitrary? Yes. But that doesn't mean they're dispensable. We can drive on either the left side or the right; we can use personal pronouns in an academic register, or not. What matters is that everyone agrees on the rules of the road. Conventions are part of what makes communication possible. They're not snobbish extras passed from on high; they're the community-ratified codes that help us all navigate the shared roadway of language. So the question isn't whether we should have conventions for usage—without them, language doesn't work. The question is by which criteria should those conventions be established. Your criteria is authority and popularity: so long as the laws of grammar don't forbid it and you can find some Nobel laureate who said it before, anything goes. My position is more democratic: I say those conventions in writing should be observed strictly but debated openly, with respect for the reader. But anytime I wade into the debate, you ignore my position and make these silly obfuscations before asserting that the debate is over—which goes a long way to clarifying the validity of your ideas, for anyone with eyes to see.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 16

Many such cases

Descriptivists like Kamm are just pollsters: they think the only measure of a language choice is whether it’s made by native speakers. But the relevant question for writers is neither the descriptivist one (is it popular?) nor the prescriptivist one (is it correct?), but the functional one: does it work? An objective basis for answering that third question is found in psycholinguistics. If we understand the reader’s experience—the ways in which certain language choices tax or exploit cognitive faculties—e.g.: working memory (how many details a sentence forces you to hold); mental imagery (how readily a phrase can be pictured, versus abstractions in nominalizations); and negation (the extra work required of flipping a negative statement to its positive form)—then we can make the case that certain constructions are not right or wrong but better or worse, regardless of who wrote it.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 16

That writers can use the first person doesn't mean that they should do. Academic writing is argument writing, and an argument is a world unto itself: evidence, claims, causes and effects. These are the stars of the show. In this world the author is not a character but an omnipotent creator: they belong outside the rhetorical space of the text, on the byline. Compare: "This idea changes X" with "This idea, I argue, changes X." With the personal pronoun, the author steps onto the stage, standing between the cause and its effect, and the link between them runs through the author instead of the evidence. The reader stops weighing the changes and starts weighing your opinion. So of course, as descriptivists never tire of repeating, you 'can' use the personal pronoun in academic discourse. But the question of whether you 'should' comes down to this test: does the claim need you, the author, in order to be true? If it doesn’t, cut the 'I' and get out of its way.

There’s nothing wrong with using 1st person. The same goes for passives (prototypically, auxiliary verb ‘be’ plus past participle). Both constructions are widely (and oddly) condemned in different types of prose. Both are appropriate to any form of writing and any register.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 16

To improve your writing: audit the verbs. Reserve the verb ‘to be’ (and its analogues: seems, appears, means) for describing (the weather is sunny) and defining (the weather is the climate and atmosphere). Aside from these use cases, if you notice a buildup of ‘to be’, odds are the actions are hiding in nouns. Put important actions in the verb.

True in life as in writing

Post attachment
County Highway avatar
⟳ William Fitzpatrick retweeted
County Highway@countyhwy·Nov 9

Gary Fisketjon, on editing Cormac McCarthy: Editing’s just a more relentless and specific form of reading in which you read a book more closely than any sane person would ever think of doing. And an editor’s responsibility to the author is to note page by page everything that crosses one’s mind, pro or con, large or small, that might prove useful. Only the writers can make those calls, or come up with the best solutions to anything that also seems troublesome to them. Having made my various points, I never look back to see if any changes were made because I’m just an enthusiastic bystander.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Nov 4

The second letter exemplifies the first stage of the writing process, the Writer’s Draft, when the writer uses the text to work out their own ideas. Great to see a stylist like DFW reveal what his early thinking drafts look like.

A couple David Foster Wallace letters published in Harper’s, November 2008

Post attachmentPost attachment
William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Oct 18

The reader isn’t an output of your writing; they’re an input. You don’t find your readers. You produce them in the text.

William Fitzpatrick avatar
William Fitzpatrick@WriterScience·Oct 4

Writing advice almost always comes as a list of rules. But Paul Millerd would never presume to tell you how to write. Instead, he'll tell you not to copy him, to do it your own way. So we flipped the genre on its head. Here are the 6 rules of writing that @p_millerd broke in order to keep his writing free.

did this cut with claude code new convo with @WriterScience to youtube asap

0:44
Paul Millerd avatar
⟳ William Fitzpatrick retweeted
Paul Millerd@p_millerd·Oct 3

did this cut with claude code new convo with @WriterScience to youtube asap

0:44