EUCALYPTUS TREE, Jan 3, 2022 (Newswire) 7:00 AM:
The koala is an unrestricted free agent
There is no pre-contract or handshake on a max deal to be signed on a certain date
What will come in '22, let's see, but until then no compliance regime
Let the mayhem begin...
NARRATOR VOICE: It turns out, Sigma Lithium $SGML never issued fourth quarter guidance
In fact, with 2 hours left in the fourth quarter, the only news release since third quarter earnings on November 14th was mentioning the CEO was at COP30
A 2026 prediction: no one will give management the fresh capital to restart Grota do Cirilo & Sigma Lithium equity makes new 52 week lows even with spodumene prices where they are today
As a mentor reminded the Koala this morning “it’s not over until it’s actually closed”
But if you’ll allow the marsupial this indulgence today as the largest shareholder of TNR Gold $TNR.V$TRRXF and we enter the closing end game for “Project Messi”
Expect anything different?
Look, the critical minerals thematic has completely deflated in public markets
See MP Materials trading below levels where it opened post DoW announcement in July 2025
So it's not an everything works vibe and energy anymore, you need to separate the wheat from the chaff but there are some absolute bargains right now
Inbox:
@USTradeRep Jamieson Greer's call with Chinese Vice Premier: "During the call, Ambassador Greer emphasized the critical importance of China taking concrete actions to fully implement its past commitments, particularly as they relate to agricultural purchases, rare earths, and other critical minerals."
When markets are melting down, everyone is sad, and a material portion of your portfolio is in what has become merger arb / special situation that will resolve favorably one way or another by the end of the calendar year just in time to buy all the tax loss selling destruction
See Teck released a “North America Truth and Reconciliation Action Plan”
The Koala looks at a map of where Teck’s operations are today
Also checks Anglo American’s operations too
Still pretending it is a Canadian champion the marsupial sees:
Blue Moon:
Current market cap: $308M
Current value of 8.85M ACG shares: $208M (up ~20% since transaction, certainly implies Blue Moon left something on the table with Nussir)
Cash minus obligation to pay back drawn amounts for Nussir: $72.5M
Current implied EV of everything else (Springer, Apex, Blue Moon, Turner): $27M
On the one hand, I was sad to see Nussir go at below what I believe is fair value. And I understand the market not valuing the ACG shares at their NAV since there's 12 months before their distribution and it's an illiquid stock anyway. But what I don't understand is the following:
- Nussir permitting concerns now substantially derisked and value realized for the project (looking at you, Viceroy! You got the price action here right despite being wrong on every fundamental point)
-start of operations at Springer & Apex in ~12 months. At spot, Springer could produce more annual FCF than Blue Moon's current market cap. DSO at Apex could mine stuff with an in-situ value of $11,000/tonne at spot germanium prices. Whatever the recovery/payability is on that, you should be making money.
- I think some have viewed the Blue Moon team as doing too many deals in too short a span of time, and get confused by an ever-changing narrative. The company has picked up 3 projects in the last 13 months and divested two. But it's a substantially more rationalized pitch now (hub-and-spoke for critical minerals in the Western US) than it was the last time the share price was here (two small polymetallic projects in tough jurisdictions with no linkage between them).
- The critical minerals rout here hurts as much as anything. Until this Nussir deal, Blue Moon was holding up as well as/better than the sector, possibly because the market viewed it as plurality copper. Now that's gone and the investors who were in it for near-term copper exposure have likely moved on.
I think the value from here is remarkable, but I also said that six months ago. But the market just seems to have given up here. I haven't.
Not a pod monkey anymore but the Koala got to “shallow high grade open pit at Kamoa” and didn’t need to read any further to know the takeaway from the Ivanhoe Mines $IVN.TO report
Just thinking about narrative for tomorrow:
Looking at the Senate: think the bogey for "Blue Wave" narrative is 53 Dems because Texas + North Carolina can be chalked up to hubris by the President
Lose those two & one or both of Kansas and Alaska?
That's "Blue Wave"
52 Dems or less in the Senate, don't think markets freak out, probably actually relief rally
Bittersweet to see this deal to be honest
Nussir showed really well a few weeks ago but where the stock is trading today this shows the massive sum of the parts unlock in the Blue Moon $BMM$MOON.V portfolio and while retaining exposure through ACG shares it simplifies Blue Moon to be an “operating” critical minerals pure play story
Also means don’t have to encumber Nussir with debt or a precious metals stream (which through cycle…smart, it’s a third quartile cost curve asset but will run for decades once producing) to get to first revenue
If Blue Moon was trading where it was this spring / 2q, probably just do another equity raise in lieu of drawing down the Hartree facility but that’s not the tape we are in, so well done by management to play the cards they were dealt and not be in denial
Also, Koala has to give Viceroy some props here. They positioned their short thesis around forcing the company to disprove a negative which is extremely difficult
“Will you lose your permits for any reason” is right up there with “so when did you stop [insert awful thing here]” as a brutal framing of a risk because it plants the seed of doubt where it wasn’t before
But one way you do throw such allegations back in someone’s face is third party DD and validation…which is exactly what an acquiror of Nussir like ACG provides…they clearly have no concerns about the seabed tailings permit after their DD
So while the Viceroy thesis was in the Koala’s opinion bs, it was framed in a way very difficult way to rebut. But this deal does exactly that
For ACG, they obviously want to get bigger quicker given they for some reason are listed in London where if you don’t have scale & float people just don’t care so logical use of paper
Win win transaction all around
So…stock trading at $7/sh Friday close
Would you rather:
A) issue equity at $6/share
B) Do a 5 yr 7% cash coupon unsecured convertible at $6.50/sh that shareholders can put to you end of year 3
So much to say, but the koala suspects to all its friends it doesn’t need to say it