←
Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social1,336 posts
Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social avatar

Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social

@YomSean

Prof. @TUpolisci, Fellow @DAWNme. I write on Mideast politics, authoritarianism, & US foreign policy. More: seanyom.com

◷ Joined February 2021▧ 10 Photos and videos
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde@JesusFerna7026·Nov 17

I am sharing a new paper today with Dario Caldara: “Can Peer Review Survive AI-Generated Text?” sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/Peer_… Dario and I, as editors, are increasingly getting papers submitted to our journals that are 99 percent AI-generated. Even worse, we are also receiving many AI-generated referee reports, both as editors and, more frustratingly, as authors. And we cannot emphasize this enough: the real problem is not that the papers and reports were AI-generated; it is that no one had done the thinking behind them, and you can so easily tell. The papers were eminently forgettable, and the referee reports were disappointingly uninsightful. We have seen too many reports of the form: “The paper is well-written and addresses an important problem. However, the authors should consider additional baselines.” This deluge of AI-generated text puts peer review in jeopardy: journals will be flooded with low-quality submissions, economists will decline requests to referee papers or routinely use AI to referee them, and which papers get published will become less and less linked to their quality. We do not want to defend the status quo entirely. Peer review is slow, many reports are poor, and editors (including us!) make bad calls all the time. Still, well-executed peer review remains the best system we have for assessing each other’s work and advancing the profession. AI could improve peer review if used deliberately for that purpose, for instance, to check proofs and code. That is not what we are seeing. The difficulty is that readers, including editors and referees, cannot see how AI was used. As a result, in practice, the burden of verification shifts from the author to the reader. Since we reject this shift, Dario and I did what economists always do when something bothers us: we wrote a paper. So, what do we do in it? First, we check whether AI detectors such as Pangram get this right: is a referee report flagged as AI-generated indeed AI-generated? Or is Pangram just flagging proofreading and editing? No. We run an experiment with 25 referee reports from the pre-AI era. Proofreading and editing do not trigger AI-generated flags. Only when we ask the LLMs to substantially rewrite the referee report or to generate a new report do we get the AI-generated flags. Pretty compelling evidence, if I may say so. Second, we build a theoretical model to explore who should bear the burden of verification: the author or the reader? (Yours truly always enjoyed the courses on the rules of evidence in law school; yes, as Billy Wilder would say, nobody is perfect.) The answer is that it is much more efficient for the author to do it, because the author can verify at a much lower cost and only needs to do it once (rather than each reader repeatedly). Before AI, the authors more or less had to verify the results, even if only because they had to type them in. This was not perfect (and all papers ever published in economics probably have at least one mistake). But the problem is that, with AI, the author does not even need to read the text. Or can just skim it. Writing is thinking, and without writing there is usually not much thinking. So, a paper flagged as AI-generated is prima facie evidence that the author has not verified it. Should this lead to an automatic rejection? No. But there should be a zero-tolerance policy for serious mistakes. The first serious mistake we find in the paper, and it is out! In comparison, for a non-flagged paper, a serious mistake is something that the editor might determine it can be fixed in a revision. We are stricter with referee reports. There is absolutely no point in the referee generating a report using an LLM. As an editor, I can do that directly and save myself the trouble of asking you for it. Now, of course, you can use the LLM to help you with the report (if the journal allows it! Many journals do not allow you to upload the paper to an LLM, and you need to follow the rules). For example, you can use the LLM to search for existing results in the literature. But peer review is not about finding one sentence that is not entirely precise or a slightly sloppy mathematical proof. Referees are asked: “Is this idea important despite its flaws?” And, relatedly: “Is the paper a good fit for the journal in terms of quality and focus?” That judgment is the task for which you are selected as a subject expert. We also propose that journals require that, before a paper is submitted, the author submit it to an LLM using an approved prompt and include the LLM report and a discussion of what was and was not fixed. That way, the referee would not need to check (or at least not check so carefully) every technical detail, and they could focus on the big picture: Is this a good paper? Is this a good fit for this journal? What is fundamental for this paper to become publishable at this journal? Anyway. The paper has many other arguments, and we try to be nuanced. So, before ferociously typing the first complaint that crosses your mind, would you consider reading it? Chances are that we have already discussed your objection. We have been thinking about this for a long time. But by all means, leave good comments!

Post attachment
derek guy avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
derek guy@dieworkwear·Nov 4

me seeing bo french lose his race

Post attachment
Mina Kimes avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Mina Kimes@minakimes·Nov 4

Been a rough 24 hours huh

You're a left wing hack and this is an admission You're not an NFL expert and men know that

Karl Sharro avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Karl Sharro@KarlreMarks·Nov 4

I love that in the American psyche the worst thing that could happen is to learn another language

I hope everyone is learning Arabic.

Omar Jimenez avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Omar Jimenez@OmarJimenez·Nov 4

I’m waking up struck by the amount of firsts with these midterm elections: -First black female governor in US history -First Muslim Senator -First openly gay Senator -First female Native American Governor -First female Native American Senator -First Latina Governor in Texas history -First female Governor in Ohio history -First elected female Senator in South Carolina history -First Black Governor in Florida history -First elected Latino governor in California history -First Kansas Democratic Senator this century/in 94 years -First Congress set up for Black Speaker of the House

🍂 la exploradora avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
🍂 la exploradora@Missy_dee811·Nov 4

Bro that World Cup changed Kansas forever. These people spent weeks partying with Algerians

Bruno Maçães avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Bruno Maçães@MacaesBruno·Nov 4

Netanyahu says Texas is two weeks away from developing a nuclear weapon

Conor Rogers avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Conor Rogers@conorjrogers·Nov 4

Austin Texas sounds like an Eastern European city that just overthrew a dictator

0:14
Geiger Capital avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Geiger Capital@Geiger_Capital·Nov 4

Now official… Democrats just won every single statewide office in Texas: Senate Governor Lt. Governor Attorney General Land Commissioner Comptroller of Public Accounts Agriculture Commissioner Railroad Commissioner All 4 Supreme Court Justices

James Talarico avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
James Talarico@jamestalarico·Nov 4

We just took back Texas.

2:17
Rana Sweis avatar
⟳ Sean Yom seanyom.bsky.social retweeted
Rana Sweis@ranasweis·Oct 23

Today's terrorist attack in the southern Jordanian town of #Karak comes nearly 10 years after #ISIS claimed responsibility for killing 10 people there. In 2016, seven Jordanian security officers, a Canadian tourist and two Jordanian civilians were killed. 🧵