
New paper at @GEC_Journal. Can climate engineering research slowball to deployment? My take: Maybe…we should beware the Slippery Slopes! authors.elsevier.com/a/1gx~A…

:^) Honorary Lecturer, Climate Policy @ANUFennerSchool My greatest hits: scholar.google.com/citations……

New paper at @GEC_Journal. Can climate engineering research slowball to deployment? My take: Maybe…we should beware the Slippery Slopes! authors.elsevier.com/a/1gx~A…

Just noticed an article I wrote with for the conversation with @ANU_ICEDS and @aawktang was translated into Portuguese a few months ago... Kind of cool... theconversation.com/clima-e-….

"Researchers do not passively create a bank of knowledge for the world to draw from. They shape ideas and the way that issues are discussed.” @aawktang for @BulletinAtomic thebulletin.org/2023/06/when…

When looking is dangerous: How solar radiation management research can harm. Read the new article by @aawktang: bit.ly/44aJDFJ

New article @BulletinAtomic Researching global sunlight reflection to cool the Earth may be necessary, but research itself can create risks. Thanks to my amazing editor @Saragoud! bit.ly/44aJDFJ

Meanwhile, countries like the US treat science, innovation, and industry as central to grand strategy: washingtonpost.com/business/… If Australia doesn’t invest in research and innovation, Australia risks being left behind.
The Government’s Science, Research and Innovation Budget tables reveal that Gov't investment in R&D is at the lowest on record at 0.49% (as a percentage of GDP). In February, Australia’s leading scientists urged the government to commit to a ‘bold & ambitious’ structural reform agenda for science, including formally adopting a target of 3% of GDP invested in R&D. To learn more, please read our pre-budget submission: science.org.au/supporting-sc… Note: The tables do not account for new and off-budget expenditures such as the National Reconstruction Fund, or initiatives such as the Australian Economic Accelerator program. #Budget2023


@ANU_ICEDS @CSERCambridge @ANUFennerSchool

This is hopefully useful to those engaged in debates on climate engineering research governance @JesseLReynolds @FHBBiermann @InaMoller @HoneggerM @mclaren_erc @GFuterman @AartiGupta17 @hollyjeanbuck @sktalati @DrRobBellamy @peteirvine

Importantly, these dynamics could overlap. Feedback loops can be powerful. Underdogs can become frontrunners. We can only know if we are at risk of slipping by understanding the lay of the land. The slopes exist, and we should beware the Slippery Slopes of research.

But this could very much happen for smaller scale aerosol injection uses (eg. cyclone intervention) or other technologies!

Lastly, there are concerns that research (eg. field tests like SCoPEx) could slowly progress to at scale deployments, avoiding political attention. But I’m sceptical because SAI field tests have not avoided attention, and researchers say we need more public engagement, not less.

Research can spark hype. The Theranoses and Juiceros of the world show you don’t need fundamental technological substance to get millions or billions of funding. And SAI does have underlying substance – a hype train could happen.

A related power driven concern is deployment lobbying by scientists, potentially motivated by patent interests. I’m sceptical because if scientists were good at climate policy lobbying, we would have reduced emissions in the first place.

Research can lead to power interests and arms races for strategically important technology. Established issues of mitigation deterrence, arms races, and politicisation fit in here. Again, this is a could happen (not will happen).

Research can normalise and legitimise. Things which are initially controversial can, over time and with public exposure, become normalised (eg. marijuana). Whether this will happen with climate engineering is up in the air.