🚨 “I’m going to shoot all of you!” Canada Must Treat a Death Threat on a Toronto Sidewalk as a Crime
A free country is judged by what it allows on an ordinary street. Circulating video from Toronto shows a man wearing a People’s Republic of China flag patch confronting Falun Gong practitioners at a public display, grabbing banners that read “Stop Persecution of Falun Gong” and “Stop CCP Transnational Repression,” and leaving poles and signs on the ground. On the original audio, he can be heard saying: “The Ethnic Unity Law is now in effect. I’m going to shoot all of you.”
That is not political argument. It is an alleged death threat, delivered in Canada, against people exercising a Charter right to worship and to protest. A Chinese statute has no force on a Toronto sidewalk. A man invoking Beijing’s law as a license to execute believers in Truthfulness, Compassion, and Forbearance is importing a police-state slogan onto Canadian soil.
Toronto Police Service should preserve every second of the original audio, identify the speaker, and determine whether the words meet the Criminal Code test for uttering threats, alongside possible assault and mischief. The Ontario Attorney General and federal public-safety officials should not treat this as a noisy quarrel between “community groups.” If the speaker is linked to United Front work or consular direction, that belongs in an RCMP and CSIS file.
Canada already knows the pattern: harassment of Falun Gong practitioners, pressure on families, and hoax bomb threats that disrupted Shen Yun in Toronto this year. A filmed threat to have people shot is the moment when “awareness” must become enforcement.
Investigate the video. Transcribe the audio. Charge whoever broke the law. Give the targeted practitioners a public accounting. A democracy does not prove its values by lecturing Beijing. It proves them by making clear that “I’m going to shoot all of you” is a crime in Canada, not a talking point from another country’s statute book.
Putin refused to shake hands with Xi Jinping and walked straight up to President Trump to shake his hand! Xi Jinping was left in an extremely awkward situation!
During today’s group photo session at the APEC Summit, Trump, Putin, and Party Leader Xi appeared together for the first time, but a dramatic scene unfolded.
In the video, Putin walked directly toward Trump with enthusiasm, raising his right hand early on in preparation for a handshake. As Putin passed Party Leader Xi, Xi looked at Putin and raised his hand as if to shake his hand. However, Putin ignored Xi’s gesture, walked right past Xi and Peng Liyuan, and shook Trump’s hand, leaving Xi and his wife extremely embarrassed.
During the subsequent photo session, Putin attempted to stand next to Trump. At that moment, General Secretary Xi suddenly raised his hand, gesturing for Putin to step aside to make room for Peng Liyuan. In the footage, Putin looked displeased and could only stand awkwardly to the side.
This dramatic scene quickly went viral on social media, sparking widespread discussion.
Xi Met President Trump on the Tarmac. Japan's Prime Minister Got a Protocol Officer.
A year after Sanae Takaichi said a war over Taiwan could threaten Japan's survival, Beijing used her first trip to China to show the region what plain speech costs. Japan and Japan's Iron Lady made no concession and came to China upright and unbowed, knowing the cold reception that awaited her there, and she has not taken back a word.
On Wednesday evening, the Tokyo broadcaster TBS split its screen in two. On the left, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi came down the stairs of her government jet in Shenzhen. On the right, South Korean President Lee Jae Myung and first lady Kim Hea Kyung descended from theirs. The anchor of the evening program N Sta asked viewers to look at the foreground. Beside the Koreans, crowds waved pompoms. Beside Ms. Takaichi, no one did.
China, the anchor told viewers, was sorting countries into those it chooses to welcome and those it does not, and doing it plainly enough for anyone watching to see.
Ms. Takaichi landed Wednesday for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, the first visit to China by a Japanese prime minister since Shinzo Abe in 2019, according to the Sankei Shimbun. Japan's Foreign Ministry said she was met by Zhang Qiyue, a protocol ambassador at China's Foreign Ministry. U.S. President Donald Trump was met by Chinese leader Xi Jinping himself. Russian President Vladimir Putin was greeted by Cai Qi, the fifth-ranking member of the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) Politburo Standing Committee, the Nikkei and the Chunichi Shimbun reported.
The gap was the message.
Two screens
Footage from China Central Television (CCTV), the state broadcaster, showed most arriving leaders received by an honor guard and young people jumping and dancing, the Nikkei reported. Ms. Takaichi received the honor guard alone. There was no bouquet, the Chunichi Shimbun noted. Ms. Zhang, the paper added, is the daughter of Zhang Shu, a former Chinese ambassador to Japan.
Tokyo had seen it coming. On Nov. 9, Bloomberg reported that Japan had asked Beijing to guarantee Ms. Takaichi the same protocol treatment as other leaders, and that Japanese officials expected at least a customary handshake from Mr. Xi. Two days later, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said China was actively fulfilling its obligations as host, and that its position on relations with Japan had been stated many times.
On the tarmac, Beijing kept the form of that promise and withheld its substance.
A year of pressure
The dispute dates to Nov. 7, 2025, 376 days before Ms. Takaichi's plane touched down. Answering an opposition lawmaker in the lower house budget committee, she said a Chinese use of force against Taiwan could constitute a "survival-threatening situation" for Japan, the legal threshold at which Tokyo may exercise collective self-defense.
Beijing demanded a retraction. She did not give one. China then aimed a year of economic pressure at a democracy over a statement about that democracy's own defense law.
Within days of the remarks, China told its citizens not to travel to Japan and urged students to reconsider studying there. On Nov. 19, 2025, it notified Tokyo that it would halt imports of Japanese seafood. On Jan. 6, China's Commerce Ministry banned exports of dual-use goods to Japanese military users, from a catalog that includes rare earths. Japan still sources about 60% of its rare-earth imports from China, Reuters reported. On Feb. 24, Beijing restricted exports to 40 Japanese companies and entities.
The pressure was not only economic. In December, J-15 fighters from the Chinese carrier Liaoning twice locked their radar on Japanese aircraft in international waters near Okinawa, according to Japan's government.
Japanese voters gave their own answer on Feb. 8. Ms. Takaichi's Liberal Democratic Party won 316 of the 465 seats in the lower house, the first time in Japan's postwar history that a single party has held a two-thirds majority in the chamber, Jiji Press reported.
The handshake
Before Wednesday's welcome dinner, Mr. Xi, as APEC's chair, greeted the leaders in turn. Ms. Takaichi shook his hand and spoke to him. Mr. Xi did not reply, the Sankei reported. A person traveling with the prime minister told the paper that no formal meeting with Mr. Xi was expected.
Kyodo News, citing Chinese sources, reported that she would be the only leader of a major economy not to get a sit-down with Mr. Xi in Shenzhen. Mr. Lee held his third summit with Mr. Xi on Wednesday, South Korea's presidential office said.
Some Japanese officials believe Mr. Xi personally demanded that the Taiwan remarks be withdrawn, Bloomberg reported. Bonnie Glaser, managing director of the Indo-Pacific program at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, said ahead of the summit that talks were highly unlikely unless Tokyo signaled that Ms. Takaichi was willing to say something close to an apology.
That is the price Beijing has set for a meeting: a Japanese leader unsaying an assessment of Japan's own security.
What Tokyo holds
The timing sharpens the snub. On Thursday, Mr. Xi hosts Mr. Trump and Mr. Putin in Shenzhen for the first formal three-way summit among the U.S., China and Russia, with nuclear arms control and Ukraine expected on the agenda. Japan's government is wary that big-power bargaining could redraw existing spheres of influence, the Sankei reported. The cold welcome lands in the week Tokyo most fears being left out of the room.
A year of trade curbs and travel warnings has not moved Ms. Takaichi's position. The airport footage now shows the region something else: what China does to a neighbor that describes a Taiwan war as a threat to its own survival, and how little that treatment has changed the neighbor's mind. Every capital weighing how plainly to speak about Taiwan is watching which of those two lessons holds.
Before leaving Tokyo, Ms. Takaichi said she would use the trip to promote "a free and open international order based on the rule of law," Kyodo News reported.
On Thursday morning, APEC's leaders sit down for the main session. Ms. Takaichi will be in the room with the man who did not answer her. She has not withdrawn a word.
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
Xi Met President Trump on the Tarmac. Japan's Prime Minister Got a Protocol Officer.
A year after Sanae Takaichi said a war over Taiwan could threaten Japan's survival, Beijing used her first trip to China to show the region what plain speech costs. Japan and Japan's Iron Lady made no concession and came to China upright and unbowed, knowing the cold reception that awaited her there, and she has not taken back a word.
On Wednesday evening, the Tokyo broadcaster TBS split its screen in two. On the left, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi came down the stairs of her government jet in Shenzhen. On the right, South Korean President Lee Jae Myung and first lady Kim Hea Kyung descended from theirs. The anchor of the evening program N Sta asked viewers to look at the foreground. Beside the Koreans, crowds waved pompoms. Beside Ms. Takaichi, no one did.
China, the anchor told viewers, was sorting countries into those it chooses to welcome and those it does not, and doing it plainly enough for anyone watching to see.
Ms. Takaichi landed Wednesday for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, the first visit to China by a Japanese prime minister since Shinzo Abe in 2019, according to the Sankei Shimbun. Japan's Foreign Ministry said she was met by Zhang Qiyue, a protocol ambassador at China's Foreign Ministry. U.S. President Donald Trump was met by Chinese leader Xi Jinping himself. Russian President Vladimir Putin was greeted by Cai Qi, the fifth-ranking member of the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) Politburo Standing Committee, the Nikkei and the Chunichi Shimbun reported.
The gap was the message.
Two screens
Footage from China Central Television (CCTV), the state broadcaster, showed most arriving leaders received by an honor guard and young people jumping and dancing, the Nikkei reported. Ms. Takaichi received the honor guard alone. There was no bouquet, the Chunichi Shimbun noted. Ms. Zhang, the paper added, is the daughter of Zhang Shu, a former Chinese ambassador to Japan.
Tokyo had seen it coming. On Nov. 9, Bloomberg reported that Japan had asked Beijing to guarantee Ms. Takaichi the same protocol treatment as other leaders, and that Japanese officials expected at least a customary handshake from Mr. Xi. Two days later, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said China was actively fulfilling its obligations as host, and that its position on relations with Japan had been stated many times.
On the tarmac, Beijing kept the form of that promise and withheld its substance.
A year of pressure
The dispute dates to Nov. 7, 2025, 376 days before Ms. Takaichi's plane touched down. Answering an opposition lawmaker in the lower house budget committee, she said a Chinese use of force against Taiwan could constitute a "survival-threatening situation" for Japan, the legal threshold at which Tokyo may exercise collective self-defense.
Beijing demanded a retraction. She did not give one. China then aimed a year of economic pressure at a democracy over a statement about that democracy's own defense law.
Within days of the remarks, China told its citizens not to travel to Japan and urged students to reconsider studying there. On Nov. 19, 2025, it notified Tokyo that it would halt imports of Japanese seafood. On Jan. 6, China's Commerce Ministry banned exports of dual-use goods to Japanese military users, from a catalog that includes rare earths. Japan still sources about 60% of its rare-earth imports from China, Reuters reported. On Feb. 24, Beijing restricted exports to 40 Japanese companies and entities.
The pressure was not only economic. In December, J-15 fighters from the Chinese carrier Liaoning twice locked their radar on Japanese aircraft in international waters near Okinawa, according to Japan's government.
Japanese voters gave their own answer on Feb. 8. Ms. Takaichi's Liberal Democratic Party won 316 of the 465 seats in the lower house, the first time in Japan's postwar history that a single party has held a two-thirds majority in the chamber, Jiji Press reported.
The handshake
Before Wednesday's welcome dinner, Mr. Xi, as APEC's chair, greeted the leaders in turn. Ms. Takaichi shook his hand and spoke to him. Mr. Xi did not reply, the Sankei reported. A person traveling with the prime minister told the paper that no formal meeting with Mr. Xi was expected.
Kyodo News, citing Chinese sources, reported that she would be the only leader of a major economy not to get a sit-down with Mr. Xi in Shenzhen. Mr. Lee held his third summit with Mr. Xi on Wednesday, South Korea's presidential office said.
Some Japanese officials believe Mr. Xi personally demanded that the Taiwan remarks be withdrawn, Bloomberg reported. Bonnie Glaser, managing director of the Indo-Pacific program at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, said ahead of the summit that talks were highly unlikely unless Tokyo signaled that Ms. Takaichi was willing to say something close to an apology.
That is the price Beijing has set for a meeting: a Japanese leader unsaying an assessment of Japan's own security.
What Tokyo holds
The timing sharpens the snub. On Thursday, Mr. Xi hosts Mr. Trump and Mr. Putin in Shenzhen for the first formal three-way summit among the U.S., China and Russia, with nuclear arms control and Ukraine expected on the agenda. Japan's government is wary that big-power bargaining could redraw existing spheres of influence, the Sankei reported. The cold welcome lands in the week Tokyo most fears being left out of the room.
A year of trade curbs and travel warnings has not moved Ms. Takaichi's position. The airport footage now shows the region something else: what China does to a neighbor that describes a Taiwan war as a threat to its own survival, and how little that treatment has changed the neighbor's mind. Every capital weighing how plainly to speak about Taiwan is watching which of those two lessons holds.
Before leaving Tokyo, Ms. Takaichi said she would use the trip to promote "a free and open international order based on the rule of law," Kyodo News reported.
On Thursday morning, APEC's leaders sit down for the main session. Ms. Takaichi will be in the room with the man who did not answer her. She has not withdrawn a word.
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
Just in: "I can shoot you dead." The man who said that to a Falun Gong demonstrator outside China's consulate in Toronto on Sept. 22 is now wanted on a Canadian arrest warrant, the Falun Dafa Association of Canada says. He's back in China.
The association's Joel Chipkar says Toronto police told him the suspect is a Chinese national who was visiting the city, that he's been notified of the warrant, and that he'll be arrested if he comes back. Chipkar told CTV News how he was found: witnesses took down the plate of the Uber he left in, and Canada's border agency then established he'd returned to China. Police aren't releasing his name, and their only public confirmation so far is that the investigation is open.
The video runs four minutes and CTV verified the subtitles. A man in a jacket with a People's Republic of China (PRC) flag tears down banners about the persecution of Falun Gong, shoves one woman and goes after a second who is filming. He calls a Toronto sidewalk "Chinese territory" and cites Beijing's Anti-Secession Law as his authority.
So this was a claim of jurisdiction. A PRC statute, enforced by hand on a Canadian street, against a woman who says she fled China to get away from it.
Safeguard Defenders lists the Toronto attack among dozens of cases in a report out this month, A Formula for Repression. It alleges at least 18 overseas Chinese associations in Canada are working as police monitoring stations, part of a network of nearly 1,250 in 91 countries, run by party operatives under the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Department. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand has written that her officials understand the RCMP is investigating the consulate incident alongside Toronto police.
Mark Carney signed a police co-operation agreement with Xi Jinping less than a year ago. He's due to meet Xi at the APEC summit in Shenzhen this week and has said he'll raise foreign interference.
The man Toronto police want is in China.
Her Husband Died in Chinese Police Custody Before One Olympics. Beijing Jailed Her Before the Next.
Painter and poet Xu Na has been sentenced to a combined 16 years for her faith. Her current crime was photographing her own city during the pandemic.
On Sunday afternoon, outside the Chinese consulate in Los Angeles, a small group of protesters unrolled a banner with a name most Americans have never heard: Xu Na.
More than 6,000 miles away, the woman on that banner is serving an eight-year sentence in Beijing Women's Prison. It is her third prison term. Taken together, Chinese courts have sentenced her to 16 years for practicing Falun Gong, a meditative spiritual discipline the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) outlawed in 1999. The latest sentence came down in January 2022, three weeks before Beijing opened the Winter Olympics. Her offense, according to U.S. government records, was sharing photographs of Beijing street scenes during the Covid-19 pandemic with a publication outside China.
Fourteen years earlier, in the run-up to the Summer Olympics, her husband went into police custody alive and came out dead.
Ms. Xu's case has drawn the attention of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), the federal body that tracks religious persecution abroad, which lists her among its religious prisoners of conscience. Her story is worth telling in full, because it shows with unusual clarity how the Party treats a citizen who will not stop believing, and how it times its blows to the calendar of its own prestige.
A painter's life, interrupted
Ms. Xu was born in 1968 into what The Epoch Times describes as a family of painters. She studied at the Beijing Broadcasting Institute, now the Communication University of China, and at the Central Academy of Fine Arts. As a student in 1989 she joined the protests in Tiananmen Square. After the army cleared the square that June, she chose to make her living as an independent painter and poet.
She married Yu Zhou, a Peking University graduate and musician who played in Xiaojuan & the Residents of the Valley, a Beijing folk band with a devoted following. In the mid-1990s the couple took up Falun Gong, whose teachings center on truthfulness, compassion and tolerance. At the time, practitioners still gathered openly in parks across China.
Then the Party decided the movement was too large to tolerate. In July 1999 it banned Falun Gong and branded it a "cult," the label it still uses to prosecute practitioners. Within weeks, in August 1999, Ms. Xu and Mr. Yu were detained for more than 40 days after attending a gathering.
In July 2001 police arrested her again, this time for giving practitioners from outside the capital a place to stay. A court sentenced her to five years. USCIRF's case record says she was tortured and mistreated during that imprisonment. Falun Gong advocates say she was held in solitary confinement and deprived of sleep. She came home in 2006.
The night of the checkpoint
On the night of Jan. 26, 2008, Ms. Xu and Mr. Yu were driving home from one of his concerts when police stopped them at a checkpoint in Beijing's Tongzhou District. Officers searched the car and found Falun Gong literature and a CD. Both were taken into custody. Beijing was then six months from hosting the Olympics, and security forces were sweeping the city for anyone the Party considered a risk to its debut on the world stage.
On Feb. 6, Lunar New Year's Eve, the family was told to go to an emergency medical center in Beijing's Qinghe area. When they arrived, Mr. Yu was already dead. He was 42 and had been in custody for 11 days.
Authorities offered two explanations: a hunger strike, and complications from diabetes. His sister, Yu Qun, who does not practice Falun Gong, told reporters he did not have diabetes and had been healthy when he was arrested. Ms. Xu requested an independent autopsy and investigation. According to The Epoch Times, authorities refused and pressed her to drop the matter, and she declined to sign the consent form for his cremation. No independent inquiry into his death has ever been made public.
The Sunday Times of London reported his death in April 2008. Amnesty International took up the case. The Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC), which monitors human rights for Congress, wrote it up as an example of Beijing's use of criminal law against religious belief.
None of it moved the outcome. Later that year, a Beijing court sentenced the widow to three more years in prison. She was released in 2011.
The photographs
In early 2020, as Covid-19 spread from Wuhan, Beijing's message to the world was one of control. Between February and June that year, Ms. Xu and a group of fellow practitioners photographed the capital's streets and sent the pictures to a publication overseas.
On July 19, 2020, one day before the 21st anniversary of the 1999 crackdown, police took her into custody along with other members of the group. Prosecutors later named her its leader.
On Jan. 14, 2022, the Dongcheng District People's Court sentenced her to eight years and fined her 20,000 yuan, about $3,150 at the time. The charge was "organizing or using a cult to undermine implementation of the law," the offense under Article 300 of China's Criminal Law that the Party routinely applies to Falun Gong. Ten others were sentenced in the same case to shorter terms. Hers was the longest. According to Bitter Winter, a religious-liberty magazine that has followed the case, an appeals court upheld the sentence in 2023.
The sequence is hard to read as coincidence. Her husband died in the security sweep ahead of the 2008 Summer Games. She received the heaviest sentence in her case three weeks before the 2022 Winter Games. In both years, Beijing was asking the world to come and admire it.
Out of sight
Ms. Xu has been denied family visits for long stretches of her current imprisonment, according to U.S. government records and press accounts. The Epoch Times reports that her elderly father now lives alone without anyone to care for him. If she serves the full term, she will not be released until 2028.
Washington has taken notice. Ms. Xu appears in USCIRF's database of religious prisoners. The Senate passed the Falun Gong and Victims of Forced Organ Harvesting Protection Act (S. 4009) by unanimous consent on Sept. 28. The bill, introduced by Sens. Ted Cruz (R., Texas) and Jeff Merkley (D., Ore.), would authorize sanctions on people found to have taken part in forced organ harvesting in China. The House passed an earlier version in May 2025, but because the Senate passed an amended text, the House must vote again. The bill has sat at the House desk since Oct. 5, and the current Congress ends in January.
That was the demand outside the consulate on Sunday: free Xu Na, and pass the bill. Liu Yinquan, a former history professor who chairs the Chinese Social Democratic Party, called her "a representative of the conscience of China's intellectuals."
Ms. Xu turned 58 this month in a prison cell. If Beijing holds her to the full term, she will walk out at 59, two decades after the night her husband drove home from his last concert.
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
Her Husband Died in Chinese Police Custody Before One Olympics. Beijing Jailed Her Before the Next.
Painter and poet Xu Na has been sentenced to a combined 16 years for her faith. Her current crime was photographing her own city during the pandemic.
On Sunday afternoon, outside the Chinese consulate in Los Angeles, a small group of protesters unrolled a banner with a name most Americans have never heard: Xu Na.
More than 6,000 miles away, the woman on that banner is serving an eight-year sentence in Beijing Women's Prison. It is her third prison term. Taken together, Chinese courts have sentenced her to 16 years for practicing Falun Gong, a meditative spiritual discipline the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) outlawed in 1999. The latest sentence came down in January 2022, three weeks before Beijing opened the Winter Olympics. Her offense, according to U.S. government records, was sharing photographs of Beijing street scenes during the Covid-19 pandemic with a publication outside China.
Fourteen years earlier, in the run-up to the Summer Olympics, her husband went into police custody alive and came out dead.
Ms. Xu's case has drawn the attention of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), the federal body that tracks religious persecution abroad, which lists her among its religious prisoners of conscience. Her story is worth telling in full, because it shows with unusual clarity how the Party treats a citizen who will not stop believing, and how it times its blows to the calendar of its own prestige.
A painter's life, interrupted
Ms. Xu was born in 1968 into what The Epoch Times describes as a family of painters. She studied at the Beijing Broadcasting Institute, now the Communication University of China, and at the Central Academy of Fine Arts. As a student in 1989 she joined the protests in Tiananmen Square. After the army cleared the square that June, she chose to make her living as an independent painter and poet.
She married Yu Zhou, a Peking University graduate and musician who played in Xiaojuan & the Residents of the Valley, a Beijing folk band with a devoted following. In the mid-1990s the couple took up Falun Gong, whose teachings center on truthfulness, compassion and tolerance. At the time, practitioners still gathered openly in parks across China.
Then the Party decided the movement was too large to tolerate. In July 1999 it banned Falun Gong and branded it a "cult," the label it still uses to prosecute practitioners. Within weeks, in August 1999, Ms. Xu and Mr. Yu were detained for more than 40 days after attending a gathering.
In July 2001 police arrested her again, this time for giving practitioners from outside the capital a place to stay. A court sentenced her to five years. USCIRF's case record says she was tortured and mistreated during that imprisonment. Falun Gong advocates say she was held in solitary confinement and deprived of sleep. She came home in 2006.
The night of the checkpoint
On the night of Jan. 26, 2008, Ms. Xu and Mr. Yu were driving home from one of his concerts when police stopped them at a checkpoint in Beijing's Tongzhou District. Officers searched the car and found Falun Gong literature and a CD. Both were taken into custody. Beijing was then six months from hosting the Olympics, and security forces were sweeping the city for anyone the Party considered a risk to its debut on the world stage.
On Feb. 6, Lunar New Year's Eve, the family was told to go to an emergency medical center in Beijing's Qinghe area. When they arrived, Mr. Yu was already dead. He was 42 and had been in custody for 11 days.
Authorities offered two explanations: a hunger strike, and complications from diabetes. His sister, Yu Qun, who does not practice Falun Gong, told reporters he did not have diabetes and had been healthy when he was arrested. Ms. Xu requested an independent autopsy and investigation. According to The Epoch Times, authorities refused and pressed her to drop the matter, and she declined to sign the consent form for his cremation. No independent inquiry into his death has ever been made public.
The Sunday Times of London reported his death in April 2008. Amnesty International took up the case. The Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC), which monitors human rights for Congress, wrote it up as an example of Beijing's use of criminal law against religious belief.
None of it moved the outcome. Later that year, a Beijing court sentenced the widow to three more years in prison. She was released in 2011.
The photographs
In early 2020, as Covid-19 spread from Wuhan, Beijing's message to the world was one of control. Between February and June that year, Ms. Xu and a group of fellow practitioners photographed the capital's streets and sent the pictures to a publication overseas.
On July 19, 2020, one day before the 21st anniversary of the 1999 crackdown, police took her into custody along with other members of the group. Prosecutors later named her its leader.
On Jan. 14, 2022, the Dongcheng District People's Court sentenced her to eight years and fined her 20,000 yuan, about $3,150 at the time. The charge was "organizing or using a cult to undermine implementation of the law," the offense under Article 300 of China's Criminal Law that the Party routinely applies to Falun Gong. Ten others were sentenced in the same case to shorter terms. Hers was the longest. According to Bitter Winter, a religious-liberty magazine that has followed the case, an appeals court upheld the sentence in 2023.
The sequence is hard to read as coincidence. Her husband died in the security sweep ahead of the 2008 Summer Games. She received the heaviest sentence in her case three weeks before the 2022 Winter Games. In both years, Beijing was asking the world to come and admire it.
Out of sight
Ms. Xu has been denied family visits for long stretches of her current imprisonment, according to U.S. government records and press accounts. The Epoch Times reports that her elderly father now lives alone without anyone to care for him. If she serves the full term, she will not be released until 2028.
Washington has taken notice. Ms. Xu appears in USCIRF's database of religious prisoners. The Senate passed the Falun Gong and Victims of Forced Organ Harvesting Protection Act (S. 4009) by unanimous consent on Sept. 28. The bill, introduced by Sens. Ted Cruz (R., Texas) and Jeff Merkley (D., Ore.), would authorize sanctions on people found to have taken part in forced organ harvesting in China. The House passed an earlier version in May 2025, but because the Senate passed an amended text, the House must vote again. The bill has sat at the House desk since Oct. 5, and the current Congress ends in January.
That was the demand outside the consulate on Sunday: free Xu Na, and pass the bill. Liu Yinquan, a former history professor who chairs the Chinese Social Democratic Party, called her "a representative of the conscience of China's intellectuals."
Ms. Xu turned 58 this month in a prison cell. If Beijing holds her to the full term, she will walk out at 59, two decades after the night her husband drove home from his last concert.
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
Falun Dafa (also known as Falun Gong) is an ancient mind-body cultivation practice rooted in the universal principles of Truthfulness, Compassion, and Forbearance (真善忍). It includes five gentle exercises: four standing movements to stretch, strengthen, and circulate energy, plus a serene seated meditation.
Practitioners improve their health, elevate their character, and live with greater peace and virtue.
While freely practiced worldwide—including in cherry blossom parks across Japan—the Chinese Communist Party has brutally persecuted Falun Dafa since 1999, subjecting millions to arrest, torture, and worse simply for following these peaceful teachings.
Falun Dafa is good! Truthfulness-Compassion-Forbearance is good! 💛
#FalunDafa#FalunGong#法輪大法#法輪功#真善忍
Jensen Huang will appear before the committees on December 1st, and NVIDIA General Counsel will appear on December 2nd, both for transcribed interviews.
Jensen Huang will appear before the committees on December 1st, and NVIDIA General Counsel will appear on December 2nd, both for transcribed interviews.
Seventeen defendants, six separate investigations, billions of dollars' worth of chips. That's Washington's tally of people charged in semiconductor smuggling cases under this administration, from a joint Commerce and Justice statement dated Nov 16.
Six cases don't happen by accident. Somebody keeps placing the orders.
The same day, Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) went after the quieter route, which is renting. Advanced chips headed to Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil will need a license. So do chips bound for any data center supplying more than 12 million units of total processing performance, roughly 750 Nvidia H100s, to companies headquartered in China or Macau. Putting a shell in between doesn't help, because the rule looks through to the ultimate parent.
On Megaspeed, the Singaporean firm in the headlines, the statement lays out a timeline. Commerce opened its investigation in 2024. In June 2025 Nvidia put the company on its no-sell list, and BIS agents went on-site with Singaporean law enforcement and interviewed the CEO. Justice now leads the criminal investigation. Megaspeed hasn't been charged and denies wrongdoing.
Beijing's foreign ministry calls the spy allegations a pretext for tech restrictions. The rule names its target in writing: companies headquartered in China. If they weren't the customers, who was renting all that compute?
Does this statement answer every question you had? For me, the one still open is for Beijing: who was the end user?
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
“We've had five reviews of the PRC and its interference in Canada. We've had the Hogue Commission, David Johnston's Special Rapporteur assessment, the NSICOP special report, the NSIRA review in 2024, and critical election incident public protocols through two elections. We have had now 18 associations that have been revealed inside Canada as operating with impunity.”
“We have a senator, Senator @YuenPauWoo, in our Senate who embarrasses himself and his office habitually.”
At the committee, I questioned @LukedePulford on Beijing's escalating human rights abuses, transnational repression, and Canada's reluctance to act.
His warning was clear: “We are losing ground.” Beijing's repression is intensifying while democratic governments are growing softer in their response.
Seventeen defendants, six separate investigations, billions of dollars' worth of chips. That's Washington's tally of people charged in semiconductor smuggling cases under this administration, from a joint Commerce and Justice statement dated Nov 16.
Six cases don't happen by accident. Somebody keeps placing the orders.
The same day, Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) went after the quieter route, which is renting. Advanced chips headed to Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil will need a license. So do chips bound for any data center supplying more than 12 million units of total processing performance, roughly 750 Nvidia H100s, to companies headquartered in China or Macau. Putting a shell in between doesn't help, because the rule looks through to the ultimate parent.
On Megaspeed, the Singaporean firm in the headlines, the statement lays out a timeline. Commerce opened its investigation in 2024. In June 2025 Nvidia put the company on its no-sell list, and BIS agents went on-site with Singaporean law enforcement and interviewed the CEO. Justice now leads the criminal investigation. Megaspeed hasn't been charged and denies wrongdoing.
Beijing's foreign ministry calls the spy allegations a pretext for tech restrictions. The rule names its target in writing: companies headquartered in China. If they weren't the customers, who was renting all that compute?
Does this statement answer every question you had? For me, the one still open is for Beijing: who was the end user?
ACI — Aric Chen | Insights
Just in: "I can shoot you dead." The man who said that to a Falun Gong demonstrator outside China's consulate in Toronto on Sept. 22 is now wanted on a Canadian arrest warrant, the Falun Dafa Association of Canada says. He's back in China.
The association's Joel Chipkar says Toronto police told him the suspect is a Chinese national who was visiting the city, that he's been notified of the warrant, and that he'll be arrested if he comes back. Chipkar told CTV News how he was found: witnesses took down the plate of the Uber he left in, and Canada's border agency then established he'd returned to China. Police aren't releasing his name, and their only public confirmation so far is that the investigation is open.
The video runs four minutes and CTV verified the subtitles. A man in a jacket with a People's Republic of China (PRC) flag tears down banners about the persecution of Falun Gong, shoves one woman and goes after a second who is filming. He calls a Toronto sidewalk "Chinese territory" and cites Beijing's Anti-Secession Law as his authority.
So this was a claim of jurisdiction. A PRC statute, enforced by hand on a Canadian street, against a woman who says she fled China to get away from it.
Safeguard Defenders lists the Toronto attack among dozens of cases in a report out this month, A Formula for Repression. It alleges at least 18 overseas Chinese associations in Canada are working as police monitoring stations, part of a network of nearly 1,250 in 91 countries, run by party operatives under the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Department. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand has written that her officials understand the RCMP is investigating the consulate incident alongside Toronto police.
Mark Carney signed a police co-operation agreement with Xi Jinping less than a year ago. He's due to meet Xi at the APEC summit in Shenzhen this week and has said he'll raise foreign interference.
The man Toronto police want is in China.
Of 348 doctors who authored papers linked to organ transplant abuses in China, more than 100 are still practicing, according to @Sarah_G_Cook of the UnderReported China newsletter:
“I was shocked because top heart and lung transplant doctors, people now who are leading major transplant centers in China, are among the people that authored those papers.”
Chinese doctors are taking organs from living people for organ "donation" but the surgery leaves the "donor" dead. How do you process this type of crime?
And one of the doctors is an active member of the American surgical association.
@capitolreport@infil_watch@NTDNews
Just in: "I can shoot you dead." The man who said that to a Falun Gong demonstrator outside China's consulate in Toronto on Sept. 22 is now wanted on a Canadian arrest warrant, the Falun Dafa Association of Canada says. He's back in China.
The association's Joel Chipkar says Toronto police told him the suspect is a Chinese national who was visiting the city, that he's been notified of the warrant, and that he'll be arrested if he comes back. Chipkar told CTV News how he was found: witnesses took down the plate of the Uber he left in, and Canada's border agency then established he'd returned to China. Police aren't releasing his name, and their only public confirmation so far is that the investigation is open.
The video runs four minutes and CTV verified the subtitles. A man in a jacket with a People's Republic of China (PRC) flag tears down banners about the persecution of Falun Gong, shoves one woman and goes after a second who is filming. He calls a Toronto sidewalk "Chinese territory" and cites Beijing's Anti-Secession Law as his authority.
So this was a claim of jurisdiction. A PRC statute, enforced by hand on a Canadian street, against a woman who says she fled China to get away from it.
Safeguard Defenders lists the Toronto attack among dozens of cases in a report out this month, A Formula for Repression. It alleges at least 18 overseas Chinese associations in Canada are working as police monitoring stations, part of a network of nearly 1,250 in 91 countries, run by party operatives under the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Department. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand has written that her officials understand the RCMP is investigating the consulate incident alongside Toronto police.
Mark Carney signed a police co-operation agreement with Xi Jinping less than a year ago. He's due to meet Xi at the APEC summit in Shenzhen this week and has said he'll raise foreign interference.
The man Toronto police want is in China.
🚨 “I’m going to shoot all of you!” Canada Must Treat a Death Threat on a Toronto Sidewalk as a Crime
A free country is judged by what it allows on an ordinary street. Circulating video from Toronto shows a man wearing a People’s Republic of China flag patch confronting Falun Gong practitioners at a public display, grabbing banners that read “Stop Persecution of Falun Gong” and “Stop CCP Transnational Repression,” and leaving poles and signs on the ground. On the original audio, he can be heard saying: “The Ethnic Unity Law is now in effect. I’m going to shoot all of you.”
That is not political argument. It is an alleged death threat, delivered in Canada, against people exercising a Charter right to worship and to protest. A Chinese statute has no force on a Toronto sidewalk. A man invoking Beijing’s law as a license to execute believers in Truthfulness, Compassion, and Forbearance is importing a police-state slogan onto Canadian soil.
Toronto Police Service should preserve every second of the original audio, identify the speaker, and determine whether the words meet the Criminal Code test for uttering threats, alongside possible assault and mischief. The Ontario Attorney General and federal public-safety officials should not treat this as a noisy quarrel between “community groups.” If the speaker is linked to United Front work or consular direction, that belongs in an RCMP and CSIS file.
Canada already knows the pattern: harassment of Falun Gong practitioners, pressure on families, and hoax bomb threats that disrupted Shen Yun in Toronto this year. A filmed threat to have people shot is the moment when “awareness” must become enforcement.
Investigate the video. Transcribe the audio. Charge whoever broke the law. Give the targeted practitioners a public accounting. A democracy does not prove its values by lecturing Beijing. It proves them by making clear that “I’m going to shoot all of you” is a crime in Canada, not a talking point from another country’s statute book.