←
Nick412 posts
Nick avatar

Nick

@badvalorem

Trade lawyer

◷ Joined May 2013▧ 35 Photos and videos
Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·8h

People often try to argue that we should tariff/reshore "strategic" manufacturing but accept offshoring and cheap imports for the "non-strategic" stuff like consumer goods. The problem is these categories are completely symbiotic. You can't draw a line between strategic and non-strategic manufacturing. Aerospace-grade rayon is a great example. This is a key input into Patriot missiles and the WSJ did a long article (in the quoted thread below) about how we import all of our aerospace rayon from a single company in France. When that little company runs out of supply, we lose the ability to manufacture Patriot missiles. So clearly aerospace rayon is a critical input and we should manufacture it, right? Well, we did. It was made by a company called North American Rayon. NARC made rayon yarn for both consumer textile applications (rayon makes a great suit lining) and more advanced carbonized rayon yarn for defense. The consumer market for things like suit linings kept NARC's business robust enough to make the more complex aerospace-grade stuff. But in the 90s, the US ended trade protections for its textile industry, causing a massive wave of cheap imports that decimated NARC's consumer business. It stopped producing apparel-grade rayon yarn in 1997, and then it stopped producing aerospace-grade rayon in 1998. A fire destroyed the vacant factory in 2000. Loss of seemingly "non-strategic" consumer textile manufacturing directly contributed to the loss of highly strategic manufacturing of a critical defense input. The lesson is that manufacturing is a single ecosystem. Losing the ability to manufacture seemingly non-strategic consumer goods jeopardizes your ability to make strategic goods. You lose know-how, you lose capacity, you lose financial flexibility, and you lose the ability to innovate the next generation of products. We should aim to support manufacturing as a holistic ecosystem instead of solely trying to target isolated products we think are "strategic." Who would guess that being good at making suit linings translates into being good at making missile components? These weird little chokepoints are scattered throughout the global production system. Instead of trying to find each one, we should do what we can to make ourselves generally good at manufacturing a broad range of products, including consumer products that don't seem all that "strategic." Paradoxically, that ends up being the most strategic policy of all.

Rayon was a civil product first. It was cloth. They called it artificial silk. The cloth business left America. One rayon maker was left. That plant made the grade that lines a rocket nozzle. Its civil cloth paid for the plant. Defense orders alone could not. The plant closed in 2000. 26 years later the Pentagon needs Patriot missiles and the rayon comes from France. No civil, no defense. We need civil manufacturing for a sustainable renaissance.

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 17

Lmao at thinking China will be a “big customer” for Canada that can replace US demand. China has a $1.2 trillion trade surplus, their domestic market is completely saturated and they depend on selling outside China. They don’t have demand slack. To the extent China does have demand, it’s for ag and mineral commodities with low value-add. In exchange, they send EVs and other advanced manufactured goods. Free trade with China deindustrializes its trade partners. In the meantime, the market access Canada is providing China makes it less likely USMCA will be renewed. That’s on a bipartisan basis - pretty much everyone on the US side agrees that USMCA privileges should be contingent on alignment on China policy to prevent China from getting the benefit of the agreement by setting up shop in Canada or Mexico. This sets up a zero-sum dynamic where the closer Canada gets to China the less market access it will have in the US. Canada thinks it’s making itself stronger by reducing its dependence on the US, but it’s actually sacrificing its biggest strategic advantage (access to the massive US market) for the opportunity to get deindustrialized by China. Good luck guys

Say what you want about Carney but this is a win. Over 90% of the trade that got hit with Chinese tariffs is flowing again. That's almost $7.5 billion in Canadian exports back on the table. That means farmers, fishermen and manufacturers getting paid. With the US jerking us around on trade, we need more than one big customer, and this is what that looks like.

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 15

I can’t believe this needs spelling out, but we didn’t have any tariffs during manufacturing’s multi-decade decline. Tariffs - indeed taxes in general - are not what make American manufacturing uncompetitive. That would be the statist command economy with $400B of annual industrial subsidies and global pricing power. If you think tax cuts are all we need to compete with China on price, you’re not living in reality. So, if tariffs are off the table, what’s the plan?

If tariffs are delivering a manufacturing renaissance, the jobs data should show it. BLS: manufacturing employment was 12.68 million in October (preliminary), about where it was in January 2025 at 12.67 million. Tariffs are taxes on the inputs our factories buy. Cut them, cut spending, and let real growth follow. vanceginn.com/letpeopleprosp… Let people prosper. x.com/RapidResponse47/status…

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 14

Tariffing bananas is often cited as the height of stupidity. They get swept up in our flat 10% global tariff and there's essentially no industrial policy or reshoring justification for tariffing bananas. But the virtue of a flat tariff is that you don't have to pick winners and losers - you can let the market decide what gets reshored without the government having to plan or predict. It's easy to administer. If you like markets, the flat tariff is actually the most market-friendly option. It's so-called "strategic" or "targeted" tariffs that deviate substantially from market logic. The downside of a flat tariff is that you end up tariffing things that can't or won't get reshored, like bananas. That cost is graphed below: banana prices are elevated by approximately 2.5 cents a pound over their pre-2025 level. I'm not going to object if we exempt bananas. But when you begin poking holes in the flat tariff, it makes administrability more challenging, reduces revenue, and invites corruption. Maybe that's worth the 2.5 cents/pound. But we should be clear about the terms of the debate.

Post attachment

DEAN: What's the tariff on bananas? LUTNICK: Generally 10% DEAN: Walmart has already increased the cost of bananas by 8% LUTNICK: If you build in America, there is no tariff DEAN: We cannot build bananas in America

1:25
Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 14

People absolutely love this talking point. It’s a complete misrepresentation of reality. Manufacturing construction spend is strongly *up* from its pre-COVID level. The recent drop is an artifact of the CHIPS Act and the IRA pulling forward spend and those projects wrapping up. Anyone that looks at a graph can immediately see that we’re in a period of elevated manufacturing construction spending. In fact, it’s been rising for the last two months, possibly indicating a new equilibrium at more than twice the 2019 level.

Post attachment

Trump claims that because of his tariffs, thousands of manufacturing plants are under construction. Not true. Manufacturing construction spending fell 21.7% in the first nine months of 2026, and spending on computer, electronic, and electrical manufacturing construction fell 45%.

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 14

This didn't get enough attention. @carney found that the Fed's main economic model, FRB/US, shows that a flat 10% tariff on non-oil goods results in both higher growth and investment over a ten year period if foreign exporters absorb just 4% of the tariff cost. The mechanism is that higher domestic selling prices act as a spur to investment, and that investment ends up outweighing the cost of the tariff. The model likely underestimates these effects, for two reasons. First, it doesn't factor in any reshoring effect - it's purely an effect on existing economic relationships. Second, we have seen that foreign exporters have absorbed far more than 4% of the 2025 tariffs - the real number is likely over 40% (source in replies). One interesting implication: there is now something close to a consensus that tariffs are necessary for certain strategic reasons relating to China or defense, but this is still understood as sacrificing growth to achieve other goals. That's not necessarily the case. Tariffs can actually be pro-growth. Ladies, we can have it all. There is still a sacrifice in the form of the short-term price increase, but that price signal pulls in investment which results in growth - exactly as protectionists have argued and matching the historical experience of Britain, the US, Germany, the East Asian Tigers, and China, *all* of whom experienced massive growth and industrialization behind high tariff walls. @carney's result shows that, as some have long suspected, this may not have been a coincidence.

A clever piece, literally running FRB/US on tariffs does result in higher investment--as John correctly notes. I believe that says something about limitations in FRB/US which is why I made the modeling choices I did in simulating the tariffs. But props to @carney for doing this.

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 13

Somehow, people who think tariffs are bad economic policy always additionally find that they’re unlawful - even under protectionist statutes passed in the 30s. The economic effectiveness of tariffs and their lawfulness are two separate and unrelated questions, but they always magically end up aligning for the textualists at AAF and Cato. Fortuitous!

Trump’s Section 338 tariffs on Canada fail to pass legal muster: The conduct, the procedure, the taxing power and the timing are all outside what the 1930 statute allows. @DrewHaleDC @AmericanFreedom @realclearpolicy realclearpolicy.com/2026/11/…

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 12

The media will almost never cover stories about tariffs onshoring manufacturing to the United States. Trump’s association with the policy makes it impossible for them to think straight and they don’t want to give him a win. They will, however, cover the damage tariffs are doing to Canada - in the form of Canadian businesses relocating to the US as a result of Trump’s tariffs. If you want to see how tariffs can attract manufacturing to the American market, look for stories that report on them through the lens of “harm to Canada.”

Post attachment

Canadian textile maker battered by tariffs eyes production in the U.S. bnnbloomberg.ca/tariffs/2026…

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 12

Jonah criticizes Oren Cass and the New Right's supposed deviation from "the ideals of limited government" which are exemplified by "the lives of Lincoln, Coolidge, and Taft." This is curious because Lincoln, Coolidge, and Taft were passionate protectionists and confirmed tariff enjoyers. Had these men been alive today, Jonah would denounce their policies just as he denounces Cass.

Post attachment

A G-File on the latest, but not the last, attempt by Oren Cass and the “respectable” New Right to run away from Trump, and the actual New Right. thedispatch.com/newsletter/g…

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 11

It’s funny to warn Republicans against “parroting the GOP’s 1880 platform.” When Republicans were the pro-tariff party, roughly between 1860 and 1932, Republicans won 14 of 19 presidential elections and controlled both houses of Congress during 64% of that span. Whatever you think about the current administration’s policies, the voting public absolutely supported tariffs in the late 19th and early 20th centuries and the Republicans accordingly built a 40% tariff wall. Republican presidents attributed America’s unbelievable prosperity to those tariffs. Here’s Calvin Coolidge, who I’m told libertarians admire:

Post attachment

💯 from @davidharsanyi "Republican 'elites,' says the president of the Heritage Foundation, 'still lash out any time a conservative refuses to parrot the party’s 1980 or 2000 platform.' Well, it beats parroting the GOP’s 1880 platform. It is certainly better than parroting the three failed presidential runs of Roberts’s hero and the paleo patron saint of paleoconservatism, Pat Buchanan."

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 11

Ancient Rome was like mid-period Dead Can Dance

Ancient Roman music is the most unsettling shit I’ve ever heard in my life

5:53
Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 9

One problem with this view is that defense and aerospace eventually fall apart without a robust industrial commons that disperses know-how, drives innovation, and creates lots of human capital in the world of atoms. And you can't defend yourself with software and tourism.

The "we don't make things anymore" crowd starts with the premise that the things the US is really good at doing – software, oil and gas, finance, venture capital, higher ed, logistics, retail, pharma, media, defense, food, tourism, aerospace – don't count. It's unfalsifiable.

Nick avatar
Nick@badvalorem·Nov 9

I frequently see this objection to tariffs: "yes, they help the steel industry, but at the expense of everyone else who uses steel." The idea is that tariffs harm manufacturing by making input prices go up. It's an intuitive argument, but ultimately not a persuasive one. As Charlie acknowledges, tariffs have returned the steel industry to profitability, attracted new investment, and allowed the industry to expand capacity. With this new investment and capacity, supply will increase and prices will decline. That's how tariffs work and have always worked. It takes some time, but anyone who follows the steel industry knows it's happening. There is a hangover period where prices have increased in response to the tariffs but the new investment attracted by the price signal hasn't yet added new capacity. That's a tough period politically, and we're in it now with most industries. This gives teeth to the argument that input prices have gone up, because there isn't yet anything concrete to show for it. But consider this: almost every product is an input for something else. Steel is an input to machined parts that are an input to combustion engines that are an input to cars, which themselves have hundreds of discrete inputs. If we want to reindustrialize, we want what's happening to steel to happen to each stage of this supply chain. If the principle is "don't tariff inputs," you cannot drive the investment and capacity expansion mechanism in the manufacturing sector as a whole. You will onshore only the low-value assembly of finished goods using imported parts, which China's massively subsidized industrial champions will supply because they don't need to earn a market return to stay in business. If China can drown a given sector in cheap imports whenever it wants, that sector becomes un-investable and the market will not deliver new capacity. If our goal is to broadly reindustrialize, you simply can't get there by only tariffing finished goods. You need to tariff industrial inputs. Doing so allows the cycle of price increase -> profitability -> investment and capacity expansion -> price decrease to work across the entire supply chain. The same expansionary cycle benefitting the steel industry can then benefit the machine tooling, engine manufacturing, and auto industries in turn. That's when you find yourself with a robust and profitable manufacturing sector instead of a small slice of finished goods assembly. Finally, just to put the cost increases in perspective, the Boston Fed estimated that 2025 tariffs increased input prices for domestic producers by an average of 1.1%. The figure was higher - specifically between 3 and 5% - for steel-using industries like motor vehicles, electrical equipment, and machinery. This matters, but it's far from a tariff-induced death blow to industry, which is the impression many seem to have. bostonfed.org/publications/c…

You've made the case against tariffs. Do tariffs help the steel industry? Absolutely. Higher profits, investment, and jobs. But you're ignoring industries that are harmed by steel tariffs: any industry that uses steel—automakers, construction, aerospace, defense, energy, medical, appliances, etc. ALL downstream industries are harmed by higher costs (passed on to consumers), less investment, and fewer jobs. It’s like putting brakes on the economy.