
People often try to argue that we should tariff/reshore "strategic" manufacturing but accept offshoring and cheap imports for the "non-strategic" stuff like consumer goods. The problem is these categories are completely symbiotic. You can't draw a line between strategic and non-strategic manufacturing. Aerospace-grade rayon is a great example. This is a key input into Patriot missiles and the WSJ did a long article (in the quoted thread below) about how we import all of our aerospace rayon from a single company in France. When that little company runs out of supply, we lose the ability to manufacture Patriot missiles. So clearly aerospace rayon is a critical input and we should manufacture it, right? Well, we did. It was made by a company called North American Rayon. NARC made rayon yarn for both consumer textile applications (rayon makes a great suit lining) and more advanced carbonized rayon yarn for defense. The consumer market for things like suit linings kept NARC's business robust enough to make the more complex aerospace-grade stuff. But in the 90s, the US ended trade protections for its textile industry, causing a massive wave of cheap imports that decimated NARC's consumer business. It stopped producing apparel-grade rayon yarn in 1997, and then it stopped producing aerospace-grade rayon in 1998. A fire destroyed the vacant factory in 2000. Loss of seemingly "non-strategic" consumer textile manufacturing directly contributed to the loss of highly strategic manufacturing of a critical defense input. The lesson is that manufacturing is a single ecosystem. Losing the ability to manufacture seemingly non-strategic consumer goods jeopardizes your ability to make strategic goods. You lose know-how, you lose capacity, you lose financial flexibility, and you lose the ability to innovate the next generation of products. We should aim to support manufacturing as a holistic ecosystem instead of solely trying to target isolated products we think are "strategic." Who would guess that being good at making suit linings translates into being good at making missile components? These weird little chokepoints are scattered throughout the global production system. Instead of trying to find each one, we should do what we can to make ourselves generally good at manufacturing a broad range of products, including consumer products that don't seem all that "strategic." Paradoxically, that ends up being the most strategic policy of all.
Rayon was a civil product first. It was cloth. They called it artificial silk. The cloth business left America. One rayon maker was left. That plant made the grade that lines a rocket nozzle. Its civil cloth paid for the plant. Defense orders alone could not. The plant closed in 2000. 26 years later the Pentagon needs Patriot missiles and the rayon comes from France. No civil, no defense. We need civil manufacturing for a sustainable renaissance.





















