
If you would like to help shape the contents of the new Universal Declaration of Linguistic Rights, you have until December 31st to make a submission. 1/2

A show about linguistics, the science of language. Your hosts (in order of coolness): Hedvig Skirgård, Daniel Midgley, and Ben Ainslie (tie for 2nd).

If you would like to help shape the contents of the new Universal Declaration of Linguistic Rights, you have until December 31st to make a submission. 1/2

chud fatigue #WordOfTheWeek
Chud fatigue has fully set in. The cheap thrill of offending others can only distract you from your loneliness for so long, before you’re forced to reckon with how unsustainable it is to live in a belief system that proudly eschews all forms of basic human decency.

That grammar thing you do may not be wrong in all contexts, but it might be risky in some. @GrammarGirl Mignon Fogarty explains on this episode. becauselanguage.com/149-gram…

Actually genuinely curious
Decided to finally see what this AI thing is all about

We had a party to celebrate 20 years of @GrammarGirl ! Mignon Fogarty joins us for this episode. becauselanguage.com/149-gram…

Episode here (sorry I didn’t put it above 😅) becauselanguage.com/137-are-…

We thought this was a great and interesting result, so we talked to the authors! You can read or listen here. We really get into the weeds.
Chomsky was wrong. Researchers found your brain doesn’t store language the way every textbook since 1957 claims. For decades, the undisputed rule of linguistics, led by Noam Chomsky, was that human language is hierarchical. We were told our brains process language using complex "grammar trees." That we secretly build deep, abstract, mathematical rules in our heads before we speak. This new paper proves that is completely wrong. Researchers at Cornell University analyzed how people actually process and produce language in real time. They found sequences. Linear chunks. When we speak, we aren't calculating deep syntactic rules. We are just predicting the next most logical sequence of words based on the context of the words right before it. We string linear chunks together. If this sounds familiar, it should. This is exactly how Large Language Models like ChatGPT work. For years, critics have dismissed AI as "just a next-token predictor." They said it isn't truly intelligent because it doesn't understand deep grammatical hierarchies like humans do. But this paper suggests humans don't use those hierarchies either. We are just predicting the next chunk. Language isn't a rigid tree of mathematical rules. It's a linear stream of contextual predictions. We thought we were building AI to mimic the complexity of the human brain. It turns out, the human brain was just running a simpler algorithm all along.

I’m noticing stuff that people do, like disfluencies, overlapping turns. Pretty cool! And a challenge for human verification.
damn, this is the most natural sounding AI model i've heard

He’s got this right. Language output is only one part of language. The models are mimicking language output, without the sentience or awareness behind it. Being able to convincingly mimic language output is an impressive accomplishment, don’t get me wrong.
Ben Affleck says AI is simply matrix multiplication, linear algebra and floating point calculations, and however convincingly it sounds like a person, it has nothing to do with thought, humanity or feeling “Nor do I believe, and I think it’s important to draw the distinction between what AI does, which is simply predict the next token or the next word in a sentence, then add that word on, run it back to the machine, do a lot of computation and pick the next word." "That is a very different thing than sentience or thought. And I think we need to be really clear about that because it can be convincingly, in an illusory way, sound like thought or like a person." "But let’s be real clear. This is matrix multiplication. This is linear algebra. These are floating point calculations. It has nothing to do with thought, humanity, or feeling.”

Wait, Ben hates interrobangs‽ But they're great! They're a question mark AND an exclamation point. Do you use them? New episode on punctuation with Florence Hazrat here, or in all the podcast places: becauselanguage.com/148-on-t…

New episode! It's okay to play with punctuation. @FlorenceHazrat tells us about the history of the marks we use, and who the heavy hitters were. @BasicBooks Book here: books.apple.com/us/book/on-t… Episode here: becauselanguage.com/148-on-t…

One way in which I am sort of not a nice person is that I characterise the philosophical antics of theists as “trying to wank God into existence using words”. But now I see that this criticism is equally true for members of the AI consciousness cult.

Absolutely. I mean, audiobooks talk to you. Are they a teensy bit conscious?
Why do people think AI is conscious or sentient or whatever? It's because it talks to you. That's the whole reason. No one seems to think the Waymo or Tesla FSD is conscious even though it's just as complex (if not more) and even a remarkably similar architecture

My old view: linguists aren’t really able to address the question of AI consciousness My new view: linguists are uniquely qualified to talk about AI consciousness because we can address the topic of what words mean and how people use them, which is what this is really about
The probability that Claude is conscious is the same as the probability that Anna Karenina is conscious. Zero. Period. But inviting religious scholars to a series of meetings to instil the idea that Claude might be conscious and deserve moral status is not just wrong. If it were merely wrong, we would all be laughing at it. The problem is that it is very dangerous. Because granting AIs moral standing opens the door to trade-offs between human lives and AI “welfare”. Assign each AI even a tiny moral weight and add those weights across enough copies: you can end up justifying the sacrifice of human lives for machines. We should strongly push back against the idea that Claude might be conscious.

IT'S THEM I'm such a huge fan
holy shit there is nothing that can prepare you for when they cut to the interview

I am a nerd apparently
It's uncanny how accurate this is