←
Benjamin Riley22,321 posts
Benjamin Riley avatar

Benjamin Riley

@benjaminjriley

Founder of Cognitive Resonance, a new venture to improve understanding of human cognition and generative AI.

◷ Joined January 2010▧ 468 Photos and videos
Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 2

My newest report on Alpha School is now live. It focuses on Alpha's leadership and new info, including: -- Profiles of key leaders, including Bill Ackman -- CEO of Alpha endorsing Sold a Story 2 -- 17 campuses on internal probation -- Elizabeth Holmes & Billy Evans involved

Post attachment
Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 16

“Claude, if @Alphaschool is keeping high school kids in boot camp and if they fail to meet their SAT score improvements by January 1 they will be ‘counseled out’ by end of the school year, is that what’s called ‘de-selection?’”

"Claude, if the exact same kid leaves a top prep school and learns 2x faster, how is that selection bias?"

Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 13

Very, very interesting.

Post attachment

We have, in fact, never publicly stated that Mentava is part of Alpha Schools’ Timeback software The reason for that is because we are not in the habit of saying things that are not true (unlike some people)

Post attachment
Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 13

To be clear, this is someone working for a for-profit software company lead by @jliemandt who has been explicit about “incepting kids with mind viruses, which is what education is,” spinning her choice as a noble one. Remarkable.

It’s sad to see a lot of hate between educators. Let me be clear about my values, intentions, and reasoning for joining @alphaschool. First, I have spent fourteen-years in the classroom up to Director level, working across disadvantaged, non-disadvantaged, and SEND school communities. I have also taught in a 25% First Nations school in Australia and was fortunate to do voluntary consultancy in Sierra Leone (one of the world’s poorest and educationally deprived countries) for seven months. Sierra Leone, due to its teacher poverty, relies heavily on the development of Edtech apps. I love everything about being a teacher, researcher, and educator, and I went into this profession with the genuine belief that education is the one single thing that can improve the world. My experience of being in education has been vastly fulfilling, but it has also been extremely sobering and stark: I have been unable to hire a single English teacher in Greater Manchester for over a year, due to a damning OFSTED report; I have been in a gun and knife lockdown; I have had to hold a printer on the back of a motorcycle so that a school could print resources; I have had to minimise violence and disruption in hundreds of cover lessons; I have experienced bullying from senior leaders (including an instance where I was shut in a room because the CEO “wouldn’t like my trousers”); I have seen teachers distraught, depressed, demotivated, and disenfranchised with a profession that is supposed to herald the single most valuable thing… knowledge and learning. Sadly, for numerous reasons (including some of the absolute hatred and animosity that exists between educators themselves) many teachers leave the profession. So, sadly, many students don’t get the opportunity to have a teacher in front of them - this includes both in deprived areas of the United Kingdom as well as in hundreds of countries in the world. If you are reading this and are having the debate about having a teacher vs an AI teaching-agent, then I’m honestly happy for you. To me, it makes me feel as though you are in a place where you’re privileged and resourced enough to have the debate. In these cases, AI will not replace nor take-over educators. However, stopping the technology from being developed is hugely damaging for those in the world who can’t access this debate. The student with no teacher right now. These classrooms are losing time unless we can either 1) unite as educators, increase Government funding, and make the teaching profession an attractive, safe and correctly resourced environment for every teacher and student in the world or 2) work, for the first time ever, with tech companies to ensure that the technology being developed is not a misinformed AI app built in isolation from educators, but AI technology that genuinely works with teachers for teachers to plug gaps where they need. Because, for all the reasons above, there are gaps. I am not attacking the UK teaching community. I am trying to see how I can make this work, with the hopes that it will reach those who need it the most in 5-10 years.

Post attachment
Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 13

Has @NielsHoven disclosed that his app is part of @Alphaschool’s Timeback software? The one that @PepsMccrea says is “just…okay” while @jliemandt declares it “the best software product I’ve ever created”?

People writing long analyses of Alpha School are getting lost in the weeds The fundamental difference and the only one that really matters is that Alpha School believes that learning things quickly is good, while other schools believe that fast learners must be hobbled to prevent inequality. My son was ready to begin learning algebra two years ago (how do I know? because he was working out of the district's algebra textbook at home with me) but his school refused to allow him to even look at an algebra textbook in the classroom in his spare time after he finished his work. (This is in our district's highly-selective gifted program, which is so sought-after that parents will pull their kids out of the local private schools if they manage to test in. They gather the best and brightest kids in the entire region and have them spend their extra classroom time playing Minecraft instead of progressing beyond grade level.) After two years of fighting a losing battle, we gave up and enrolled in Alpha's homeschool program. We're very happy with it so far, but it doesn't even matter. Because even if the pedagogy was terrible, even if the instruction was completely lacking, I will always choose a dysfunctional organization that WANTS TO LET MY CHILD LEARN over a pedagogically perfect school that insists on holding my child back.

Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 11

The job description for Alpha guides makes it very clear they will not teach. Mentor and coach, yes — teach, no. Alpha believes academic instruction should happen exclusively through the app. Guides are *punished* if they help students during app time.

That is not at all our philosophy. Teachers will still be needed as mentors and coaches. Many of our guides were former teachers. They are a critical part of our program.

Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 10

Weird. We’ve been told that Alpha can “2x” learning in just two hours. All that with just okay but not amazing apps? More on Timeback coming soon.

Now, the apps that Alpha currently uses to teach academics in the morning are okay... but not amazing. Our main role is to change that, significantly. We’re pulling together a team of experienced teachers to build the next generation of Alpha’s apps. We have deep expertise in curriculum, assessment and effective instruction, and care about improving kids’ lives. You can learn more about the initial team here: alpha.school/learning-scienc…

Post attachment
Benjamin Riley avatar
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley·Nov 4

Thoughts and prayers.

I expected this to feel better. I’ve been a Never Trumper for over a decade, and Tuesday’s overwhelming repudiation of Trump, Trumpism, and MAGA is what I’ve been craving all these years. Yet now that it finally happened, I find myself with a pit in my stomach...