Caring waaaay too much about ads since '08 Building @URLLoveIt_: Monitor the changes that actually impact your ads & business. Ad creative: Adcrate.com
I've spent almost $1 billion advertising on FB since '08 and this is something I see advertisers getting wrong all the time:
🛑 Stop focusing on FB CPMs (and CPCs)! They don't matter that much.
❌ Turning off ads due to high CPCs or CPMs can be turning off top performers.
🧵👇
Too many marketers talk about reducing friction on landing pages, like it's a bad thing.
The goal shouldn’t be to reduce friction.
In many ways, it's the opposite.
Add friction!
So much friction that it burns.
I want to make a landing page with so much friction that it burns the customer so much that they need to buy my lotion immediately.
You gotta leave room for stuff you can't measure but Meta can and does.
Meta knows waaay more about users and your ads that you can't see.
Think about the number of people who see but don't click the link on your ads every day.
You can't know if someone watched 90 seconds of a top of funnel ad, read every comment on it, clicked to your IG profile, watched five organic posts, and shared the ad to their partner, but didn't click the link.
No way for you to know:
A. What a single user did all of that, but it's normal high-intent behavior.
B. What the next ad will be after they do all that or why, but Meta knows.
C. How many ads someone saw, engaged with, or clicked, before they converted.
D. Why or how Meta sequenced the ads that got them to buy.
E. How any of this interacted with your other efforts, like emails...
This is a problem with both in-platform and third party data.
At scale, with good data, if Meta wants to spend on ads or ad sets, that's a good sign.
How should you deal with this?
1. Remember that humans are imperfect and marketing isn't exact.
2. Have a higher CPA and ROAS tolerance for ads and ad sets for colder audiences.
3. Focus more on ads and ad sets ability to spend instead of CPA or ROAS
4. Focus on total account CPA and ROAS more than granular levels that overlap
5. Study your audience segment breakdown ratio (new vs engaged) to better understand where your budget is going for those ads and ad sets.
6. Trust Meta more (when it's optimized properly and getting lots of good data!)
If you're optimizing for the wrong actions or not giving Meta enough data, none of this will work well.
Don't worry about your brand's [METRIC] vs anyone else's.
The only benchmark that matters is your own performance from last [TIME PERIOD].
Beat that, and you win.
The "why" behind a lot of performance shifts is often explained by something changing somewhere along the funnel.
Like the website, reviews, or Google search results.
That's why I made @urlloveit_: to help answer that "why"
urlloveit.com/why
This Meta "measure conversions on customer devices" change is coming next week.
Should you opt out?
Who will win and who will lose from this?
Meta's documentation of the change says:
"Your attribution window and attribution model don't change. Measuring conversions on customer devices affects which conversions can be measured, not how they're credited to your ads."
Sooooo, they're saying your attribution window and model don't change, buuuuuut they're also saying they're going to be able to get credit for more conversions, which means...
I expect to see different results depending on what attribution setting you’re using.
Losers:
Anyone using Standard Attribution, especially 7dc1dv and, even more if you have a lot of other traffic sources. Standard attribution already gives Meta credit for sales it didn't cause (view-throughs from people who were buying anyway). Now Meta can see more of those sales, so it gets to over-credit an even bigger pool.
This will improve your in-platform metrics, which changes how it optimizes your campaigns.
If you're using bids or cost caps: the system will spend more because it's getting "more conversions" but if they're not actually driven by the ads, you're spending more for the same results you were getting before.
Look out for more unusual delivery to certain ads and lower-quality placements.
Winners:
Using Incremental Attribution. More conversions captured = more opportunities for Meta to identify more conversions that were actually driven by Meta.
Regardless of your attribution setting, if you're relying on external tracking (Northbeam, Triple Whale, etc), you're likely going to see the gap broaden between your in-platform metrics and your external tracking.
Should you opt out? I wouldn't recommend opting out of this change. Generally, more data is better than less, but only if that data is being used to improve your results, not just to give Meta more credit for conversions it didn't cause.
That’s why we built URL Love It.
Capture what matters to your customers and your business every day, so when the numbers move, you see what your customers saw and understand "why" before you make unnecessary changes.
Start protecting your business now urlloveit.com/check-the-page
Maybe it's Meta.
Orrrrrrr maybe it's the way your brand shows up in Google search results.
Look at this one little change that happened to a brand we track.
Went from a generic “BBB Complaints” snippet on Google search results to "F BBB rating."
Imagine an IG user sees your ad, then Googles reviews of your brand and this shows up.
How many people do that every day?
How many sales do you lose?
1? 5? 10? 100?
How would that impact your CPA?
Would you notice?
Your CPA goes up.
You check the ads.
Same creative, same targeting, nothing broken.
So you start swapping creative and moving bids and budgets around.
Meanwhile the problem is on page one of Google and you have no clue about it:
$1.5+ million spent on this ad I shot.
It just turned 2 years old 🎂 and still spends $1k/day today.
Happy birthday ad #399! May you keep spending and never fatigue.
I don't trust Meta's ad optimizations 100%, but I trust it more than humans.
Even with $0 of spend, Meta can analyze an ad and predict its relevance and performance.
$5 of spend can get a bunch of impressions that Meta can get learnings from in terms of who even pays attention to that ad.
There's so much stuff that Meta doesn't/can't report out on, so we can't see it.
With limited data, the system will tend to favor more attention-getting ads, which isn't always what sells efficiently. So yeah, it's imperfect, but it's also better than its ever been and better than any human.
It can get it wrong, but at scale and over time with good data, it gets it right overwhelmingly.
Meet me in... Bangkok!
If you're anywhere near Thailand (orrrr looking for a getaway) next month, you're not going to want to miss this.
Stacked lineup and I'll be dropping insane knowledge bombs.
DM me for more!
When I build the agenda for Scaling or Failing in Bangkok, it looks different than my events in the US.
In the US, everyone’s already exposed, so sometimes I might do 2 or 3 Meta topics..this guy's perspective, that guy's perspective.
But in Asia I can really only do one, because they're not exposed to a bunch of the same.
So it's basically less variety of the same topic and more variety across ALL topics.
December 7-8, right before Affiliate World Bangkok. Link below.
This Meta "measure conversions on customer devices" change is coming next week.
Should you opt out?
Who will win and who will lose from this?
Meta's documentation of the change says:
"Your attribution window and attribution model don't change. Measuring conversions on customer devices affects which conversions can be measured, not how they're credited to your ads."
Sooooo, they're saying your attribution window and model don't change, buuuuuut they're also saying they're going to be able to get credit for more conversions, which means...
I expect to see different results depending on what attribution setting you’re using.
Losers:
Anyone using Standard Attribution, especially 7dc1dv and, even more if you have a lot of other traffic sources. Standard attribution already gives Meta credit for sales it didn't cause (view-throughs from people who were buying anyway). Now Meta can see more of those sales, so it gets to over-credit an even bigger pool.
This will improve your in-platform metrics, which changes how it optimizes your campaigns.
If you're using bids or cost caps: the system will spend more because it's getting "more conversions" but if they're not actually driven by the ads, you're spending more for the same results you were getting before.
Look out for more unusual delivery to certain ads and lower-quality placements.
Winners:
Using Incremental Attribution. More conversions captured = more opportunities for Meta to identify more conversions that were actually driven by Meta.
Regardless of your attribution setting, if you're relying on external tracking (Northbeam, Triple Whale, etc), you're likely going to see the gap broaden between your in-platform metrics and your external tracking.
Should you opt out? I wouldn't recommend opting out of this change. Generally, more data is better than less, but only if that data is being used to improve your results, not just to give Meta more credit for conversions it didn't cause.