
Interesting new paper comparing AI and human reviews: arxiv.org/abs/2611.17811

Professor of Medicine at @UChicago. Decoding the human microbiome. BlekhmanLab.org

Interesting new paper comparing AI and human reviews: arxiv.org/abs/2611.17811

When LLMs review a paper, they draw 50% of their weaknesses from the appendix. For human reviewers it's about 8%. The general trend: human reviewers focus on the big picture, overall presentation and support for the major claims. AI reviewers nitpick.

Is the Bitter Lesson coming to genomic prediction? An untuned tabular foundation model matches or beats specialized methods biorxiv.org/content/10.64898…


Is it time we abandon recommendation letters in academia? Letters have ~zero signal to noise ratio, and with AI they are easy to generate. A 10-minute call is much more informative. Compare today’s 3-page "top 1%" letters with Darwin’s 1851 letter for Huxley (2 sentences):

Why does every AI Bio company sounds exactly like Theranos? "a CRO but really fast" (with no tech innovation, no experience in biology) sounds a lot like "a blood test but from a really small amount"
Today we're launching Petrichor (YC F26), a wet lab for frontier AI labs. We run experiments in parallel and return the data from every step.

Some concerns are valid: data sovereignty, underrepresented languages, and asking “what AI is for” are real issues. Indigenous knowledge is useful. But blurring science and values, under the stamp of @ScienceMagazine, means both science and Indigenous knowledge lose credibility

The editorial is incorrect about fundemental science concepts. It calls “Western science” linear and purely reductionist, which is obviously wrong. It says AI is trained to use it as a “control”, also wrong. No citations at all for any claim in this piece.

Public trust in science is critical, especially now. This trust relies on the idea that “science” means real claims we can test and revise. So when a @ScienceMagazine editorial describes a “unifying life force” as part of science, it's a problem
"In Lakota science, there are four parts—matter, energy, relationality, and a unifying life force" That @ScienceMagazine, arguably the world's preeminent science journal, would publish this is mind boggling.

This is an insane figure. Monthly arxiv submissions
What is biology research for? Expanded version of my PLOS Biology Perspective, with very recent developments from arXiv and bioRxiv. This field is moving fast. blekhman.substack.com/p/what…

I feel like you could overlay this with a graph of GitHub PRs over time and they would match exactly. So many parallels in the spam problems facing GitHub and preprint servers in 2026.
arXiv submissions. Look at the last couple of months. Insane

What is biology research for? Expanded version of my PLOS Biology Perspective, with very recent developments from arXiv and bioRxiv. This field is moving fast. blekhman.substack.com/p/what…


The authors didn't do anything wrong here - they clearly disclosed their AI use But, as a reviewer/editor, I just cannot bring myself to read AI-generated papers. I don't reject the paper, I just step down as a reviewer. I simply can't justify spending any of my time reading it
Peak peer review. (We submitted to ICLR) #iclr2027


It's time, calling for a “Rebuild American Science Act”: - Double the NIH & NSF budgets - Limits on executive interference - End forward funding - Rebuild the research training pipeline - Full transparency of success rates - Permanent H-1B fee exemption for universities