
Thread: Pumped storage seems to be all the rage for "firming" renewables. This ran through my head last night and I got thinking, what's the scale required? /1

Network Engineer, IT Director, firearms enthusiast, Director - C4NE.ca Passionate about Nuclear Energy, Hydro-Electric and music. Centrist. savepickering.ca

Thread: Pumped storage seems to be all the rage for "firming" renewables. This ran through my head last night and I got thinking, what's the scale required? /1

Turns out shutting down two perfectly good reactors at Indian Point, which supplied roughly a quarter of downstate New York's electricity, on the promise that renewables and Quebec hydropower would replace them was... ill-advised. Natural gas filled much of the gap. The Quebec transmission line arrived five years after the reactors closed, and now Hydro-Québec is warning that drought may force it to curtail exports. @NRDC @riverkeeper
" New Yorkers were told for years that this cable would help replace Indian Point: by Riverkeeper in 2017, by Hydro-Québec and the developer in 2021, and by the governor’s office this June."

" New Yorkers were told for years that this cable would help replace Indian Point: by Riverkeeper in 2017, by Hydro-Québec and the developer in 2021, and by the governor’s office this June."
On Friday, Hydro-Québec said it could suspend power deliveries to the United States for brief periods. Its reservoirs are low. Québec’s dams run on rivers, and the rivers have been short for three years. In 2023, three northern rivers hit record lows. In 2024, four more did. This year the typical river is running 16 percent below normal. Hydro-Québec puts the three-year shortfall at 108 terawatt-hours, about two-thirds of what New York uses in a year. For years Québec sent New York about 10,000 gigawatt-hours a year. In 2023 that fell by three quarters. In 2024 it reversed. Last year and again this year, New York has sent more power to Québec than it got back, even counting the new cable into New York City. Since the cable opened in May, it has delivered about 1,100 gigawatt-hours to the city. Over the same months, the older lines upstate sent 2,600 north. Where did the northbound power come from? About half from New York’s gas and oil plants. About half from more imports, mostly from Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Almost none from New York’s own dams. New Yorkers were told for years that this cable would help replace Indian Point: by Riverkeeper in 2017, by Hydro-Québec and the developer in 2021, and by the governor’s office this June. When the grid operator studied the closure in 2017, it counted on three new gas plants. The cable is not in that study. For winter, grid planners count on zero megawatts from the cable, November through April. Last Saturday the cable delivered about 790 megawatts to New York City. New York sent 800 back north. Sources: NYISO interface flows and fuel mix; Hydro-Québec third-quarter bulletin, 2025 results and Supply Plan 2027–2041; Québec environment ministry river gauges; The Globe and Mail, Nov. 13, 2026; NYISO Indian Point deactivation assessment, Dec. 13, 2017. Satellite images: NASA, Copernicus Sentinel-2.

Rolling 14-day Ontario power mix:

Rolling 14-day Ontario power mix:

I think for today we should all play a little game I like to call, "Which critical public utility or service will be brought down by abject stupidity, gross negligence or a poorly planned network patch/update?"

On this day in Canadian Nuclear History: - In 1966 at 4:26PM @AECL_EACL Douglas Point achieved first criticality. The first large-scale commercial CANDU unit, the Douglas Point design would end up underpinning the Indian IPWHR reactor program after ties with Canada were severed when India used a CIRUS research reactor to develop nuclear weapons material.

These are the usuall suspects who physically attacked @EricGMeyer at COP in 2018 in Katowice, becasue we had a banner with renewables and nuclear power. In 2018 they had 598 likes on facebook. Today they have 597.

Remember those times the @ONcleanair said Ontario could shutdown its nukes and rely on Quebec imports? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
[Hydro Quebec] "says it is dealing with its four driest consecutive years since hydrological data began to be compiled in the 1940s." gas into "green" alchemy continues: ON imports to US exports theglobeandmail.com/business…

[Hydro Quebec] "says it is dealing with its four driest consecutive years since hydrological data began to be compiled in the 1940s." gas into "green" alchemy continues: ON imports to US exports theglobeandmail.com/business…

On this day in Canadian Nuclear History: - in 1992 @opg Darlington Unit 1 entered commercial service. Record holder for the longest uninterrupted run of a thermal plant in history at 1,106 days, D1 went down for refurb in 2022, returning to service in 2024.


Rolling 14-day Ontario power mix: #FollowFriday Friendly Canadian🍁 Electricity Bot Network🤖 @skelectricity @nlelectricity @nselectricity @nbeelectricity @qcelectricity @ReliableAB

Note that the Sir Adam Beck generating station at Niagara Falls was built in 1922. It’s over 100 years old, and its concrete experiences far more stress than anything at Pickering.
the big ending is given to an anti-nuke kook, but no concrete structure lasts 90 years? I bravely live on a waterway controlled by older dams upstream and downstream I’m okay with scaremongering about invisible radiation, but must we frighten those around the CN Tower? 8/9

Matthew McClearn has [another] good column on Darlington nuclear GS today those with a subscription can read on the Globe and Mail site. good, imo, to see OPG's performance questioned, but there are a few issues I’ll address. #1-ffs: the refurb period was 10 years - not 20 1/9

🤣🤣🤣
copilot, fix all microsoft servers. make no mistakes.