←
Catholic Answers25,298 posts
Catholic Answers avatar

Catholic Answers

@catholiccom

Catholic Answers is a media ministry that serves Christ by explaining and defending the Catholic faith. See all the ways we do it. 👇

◷ Joined February 2011▧ 6,433 Photos and videos
Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Oct 28

We just crossed 7,500 subscribers on Substack and we’re grateful to everyone who has joined us. In an internet built around outrage, clickbait, and hot takes, 7,500 people have chosen something different: serious Catholic thought. For nearly 50 years, Catholic Answers has been on the front lines helping people understand and defend the Faith through radio, books, articles, and now Substack. The platforms can change but mission doesn’t. Subscribe to become part of the mission: substack.catholic.com

Post attachment
Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·14h

Regarding Trent Horn: we can confirm that, as of October 30, 2026, Trent has departed from his role as a staff apologist with Catholic Answers. During his time here, he was a stalwart apologist and evangelist, and he made important contributions to the growth and success of the Catholic Answers apostolate. We wish him well in his future endeavors. Beyond that, we're not able to share additional details. For nearly fifty years, Catholic Answers has been dedicated to explaining and defending the Catholic faith. We have had the privilege of working with many talented men and women who since have gone on to serve the Church in a variety of other ways. Although in the life of an apostolate the names and faces may change, the mission of Catholic Answers remains. Our commitment to explaining and defending the Faith is as strong today as it has ever been, and we look forward to the work still ahead.

Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Nov 16

"When I was an evangelical," writes Catholic author Casey Chalk, "we were encouraged to memorize Bible verses that we believed to most succinctly capture the heart of the gospel." These included: “For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Cor. 5:21). “He who did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all, how will he not also with him graciously give us all things?” (Rom. 8:32). “But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed” (Isa. 53:5). Chalk explains that all of these verses were used to support an understanding of salvation known as penal substitutionary atonement. Such a concept effectively means that the guilt of mankind’s sin was transferred to Christ, so God treated Jesus as a sinner, or even the personification of sin, thus necessitating God’s wrath upon him. “Whatever sins I, you, all of us have committed or shall commit, they are Christ’s sins as if he had committed them Himself,” says Martin Luther in his Commentary on Galatians. “Christ is here exhibited in another view, as transferring to himself the punishment due to us, and wiping away our guilt in the sight of God,” writes Calvin in his Institutes of the Christian Religion. But is that the best reading of these verses? There are strong theological and exegetical reasons to say no. First, it is an odd sense of justice indeed that involves transferring punishment from the guilty to the innocent, which does not solve the problem of guilt for committed sins. Indeed, such a framework might actually imply that “one injustice (sin and incurred guilt) is followed by another one (guilt is transferred from the guilty to the innocent),” one that implicates God himself. Moreover, why can God not simply forgive the sins? “Is God the Father so ruthless that someone must necessarily suffer the punishment for sin, and if it is not the sinner himself, then it can (must?) be his beloved Son?” This is a cold, ruthless form of justice, in which God simultaneously loves and hates. What, then, are we to make of the verses above? And what DID Jesus' sacrifice on the cross mean? Read more here: bit.ly/4zRBgPl

Post attachment
Doctor Karlo avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Doctor Karlo@doctor_karlo·Nov 16

Is Wine in Mass an Abomination?

1:25
Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Nov 13

TikTok: "Europeans forced Native Americans to convert to Catholicism or die" Fact check:

1:26
Doctor Karlo avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Doctor Karlo@doctor_karlo·Nov 13

Is the Bible Pro-Wine?

1:23
Shameless Popery avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Shameless Popery@ShamelessPopery·Nov 12

Abortion and Separation of Church and State?

0:18
Doctor Karlo avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Doctor Karlo@doctor_karlo·Nov 12

THIS Protestant Explanation of Paul’s “Traditions” Fails

1:44
Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Nov 12

In his wide-ranging interview with President Donald Trump, 60 Minutes correspondent (and devout Catholic) Ross Douthat asked the President if he could forgive his political enemies if it was the only thing standing between him and eternal life. After some back and forth, Trump finally said, "The answer is no. I want to be honest, no...I do hate some of my enemies. I think they’ve been terrible. Look what they’ve put me through, the weaponization." Douthat pressed harder, saying, "Mr. President. You have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me that before the judgment throne of God you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you? Come on. Help me out here." Still unmoved, Trump said, "I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will." Instead of invoking the president’s “most charmed and remarkable life,” perhaps Douthat could’ve more effectively pivoted to scriptural common ground with his Protestant brother in Christ: namely, the Lord’s Prayer. Why? Read more here: bit.ly/4euMGzM

Post attachment
Shameless Popery avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Shameless Popery@ShamelessPopery·Nov 11

This is very strange. I did a 2.5 hour debate with James White defending the proposition that the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice, only to have an online Protestant apologist falsely claiming that I don't talk about the Eucharistic Sacrifice, and hold to views that "are actually out of step with even [the Council of Trent itself." No evidence is given of this assertion, and when @ErickYbarra3 asks, "Do we have evidence that either @Trent_Horn or @ShamelessPopery denies that a real and proper sacrifice takes place upon the altar?," he answers "I never claimed that they denied this." Very strange behavior.

A lot of the popular-level Roman Catholic apologists today are actually quite dull on the subject of Eucharistic Sacrifice when compared with the vast majority of Roman theologians after the Council of Trent. For example, they commonly just say that "the Mass is a re-presentation of the sacrifice of the Cross," or simply "applies the sacrifice of the Cross" while being unaware that most confessional Protestants also agreed to this without any difficulty. The real issue was that Roman Catholic theology has always historically held to the idea that a real immolation of the sacrificial victim is necessary and essential to the nature of a proper and external sacrifice. Without it, you merely have an oblation---but not a sacrifice. The views held by the Catholic Answers bros are actually out of step with even Trent itself, since they hold to something more like the view of Gabriel Vazquez or perhaps Maurice de la Taille, who were criticized on this very issue by other prominent authors, such as Emmanuel Doronzo. If you want the best survey possible, check out L'Idée du sacrifice de la messe by Marius Lepin. It is a 900-page study of all the different theories, and ultimately comes to the conclusion that the majority of them are wrong and inconsistent in explaining how some immolation of Christ occurs in the Mass.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Shameless Popery avatar
⟳ Catholic Answers retweeted
Shameless Popery@ShamelessPopery·Nov 10

Too Religious for Politics, Too Political for Church?

1:14
Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Nov 10

"The Church taught for 1500 years that heaven was in the sky" There is simply no solid ground for such a sweeping historical claim. At most, you could point to about five centuries of mainstream Latin theology (c.1150-1650), which placed Christ’s risen body and the saints in a real, bodily “empyrean” heaven above the stars. But the same sources deny that God is located in the sky, and they separate heaven from the visible sky. But more to the point: there is no creed, council, or pope in the first 1500 years of Christianity that defined where heaven is. The Church did not settle this question. And if someone wanted to redefine "the Church taught" to mean "lots of theologians speculated," well, there is still no consensus of theologians across the centuries on this question. That is why two recent popes could, without reservation, say that the depiction of heaven or God as being "in the sky" is not to be taken literally. Pope Benedict XIV: “All of us today are well aware that by the term ‘heaven’ we are not referring to somewhere in the universe, to a star or such like; no. We mean something far greater and far more difficult to define with our limited human conceptions” (General Audience, Aug. 15, 2010). Pope St. John Paul II: “In the context of revelation, we know that the ‘heaven’ or ‘happiness’ in which we will find ourselves is neither an abstraction nor a physical place in the clouds, but a living, personal relationship with the Holy Trinity. It is our meeting with the Father which takes place in the risen Christ through the communion of the Holy Spirit” (General Audience, July 21, 1999)

One more time: 1. Witnesses supposedly saw Jesus ascend to the sky and understood that to be where heaven was. 2. The church taught for 1500 years that heaven was in the sky. 3. Angels were given wings because heaven was in the sky.

Catholic Answers avatar
Catholic Answers@catholiccom·Nov 10

This pope dismantles one of Eastern Orthodoxy's favorite arguments 👇

1:00