←
Charles Marohn13,211 posts
Charles Marohn avatar

Charles Marohn

@clmarohn

Books: Strong Towns | Confessions of a Recovering Engineer | (Bestseller) Escaping the Housing Trap

◷ Joined September 2008▧ 666 Photos and videos
Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Jun 18

If you're wondering where I'm spending my time online these days, it's the Strong Towns Commons. Smart people. Challenging conversations. No outrage machine. Just people trying to better understand how to build stronger places. commons.strongtowns.org

Post attachment
Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·8h

This is the way New Yorkers talk to each other, not Minnesotans. That doesn't make it untrue, but it does make it uncomfortable. For Minnesotans.

Very surprised by the reaction to this, and how political it is! I don’t dislike Minneapolis, don’t think it’s hell incarnate. You can live a perfectly fine life there -- work in corporate for Target, have a small home in Brooklyn Park, maybe share a lake cabin with friends/family up north -- but it’s also noticeably deteriorating from the center outwards, turning into a shell losing its heart. The downtown, even adjusting for pedestrian malls, is lifeless to despondent. Like a lot of US cities the action has moved towards the edges, and the center is left to wither into occasional sports events. Staying downtown, especially on a weekend, you feel trapped. I’m currently in a hotel in Sioux Falls, out next to the Walmart, and I feel liberated. I’ve got so many shops, restaurants, bars, and even two bookstores! It is far more alive here than central Minneapolis, and especially St. Paul. As I’ve written before, in many American town centers (Indianapolis for example) the only long-term committed residents are the homeless, and so everything becomes about them: bathroom codes, limited outdoor seating, shuttered public spaces, etc. This further discourages people from moving downtown, and the downtowns are kept alive by government money: a large open-air social service that, even by that metric, has failed. Some argue this is just how it will be in the remote work age -- suburbs grow, centers shrink. Well, there's nothing preordained about that, as the rest of the world shows. Plenty of Americans would move back towards the center if the center offered them anything close to the quality of life the edges do -- which isn’t hard to do. Enforce laws on the books, care more for the 98% of the public, rather than the 2% of the anti-social who ruin it for everyone else --

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Nov 14

They put a highway engineer in charge. Predictably, the engineer chose brute force. Predictably, it turned into a disaster.

Happy Exploding Whale Day to all who celebrate.

3:24
John T. Reuter avatar
⟳ Charles Marohn retweeted
John T. Reuter@johntreuter·Oct 28

For me, the crux of this is the correctly cited need for “trust in local government’s capacity.” Without strong and effective local governments, any pro-housing agenda will fall apart.

I speculate in *Agenda for Abundant Housing* that the differing scale economies of automobility vs transit explain part of the transition to postwar "2nd-wave" NIMBYism Less speculatively, scaling transit with density seems important to preventing legit backlash to reform 👇

Post attachment
Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Oct 27

Housing advocates should reject this framing. “By whatever means” is an ugly, divisive way to approach people whose cooperation we need to get housing built.

Local governments must be stripped of their legal authority to ration homebuilding and return land use control to the landowner by whatever means. State is best used as a tool to delete local land use laws, it can be used negatively, but it's all we have right now.

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

There are no banks that have, as their reserves, bundled securities of 30-year auto loans. Nobody buys a car thinking it will appreciate in value and be worth more in 30 years. It's an absurd talking point.

"Devaluing"? Do you think it is bad that used cars lose value? The difference between mid century filtering and filtering today is we should build new housing in cities where people want to live.

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

Institutionalizing decline and devaluing large swaths of America so that housing becomes affordable is a strategy, it's just not my strategy.

Why do so many poor people in Philly today live in the rowhome mansions of the early 1900s Nouveau Riche? Filtering is how suburban sprawl occurred and cities became poor. Very obviously it is an affordability strategy.

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

This might be the reality in a few core cities, but for nearly all Americans, there is a massive difference in price between the home they start in and the place they end. We shouldn't make policy nationally based on Silicon Valley economics.

What you call "luxury condos" aren't expensive compared to starter homes. Why would stacking more people vertically be more expensive? It's not.

Jarrett Walker avatar
⟳ Charles Marohn retweeted
Jarrett Walker@humantransit·Sep 23

One of the best podcasts I've done on the public transit challenge in the US. A great conversation with @clmarohn, the founder of @strongtowns. Please share. podcast.strongtowns.org/e/th…

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

One last thing on the disingenuousness of the housing discourse here..... This dude uses quotes as if I've said this. I haven't. I've literally written 2.5 million words available online -- just quote me. You don't have to make shit up.

This tweet is unavailable

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

I've literally said that every neighborhood everywhere should be upzoned. I've been saying that since Strong Towns was formally founded in 2009. Why is saying filtering + building more entry level housing so threatening?

This tweet is unavailable

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 24

Dude, keep sharing my stuff. You're demonstrating my point. Going from starter home to luxury condo is a choice for a select few. It's not the common path for nearly all Americans, but perhaps most Americans you know.

dude @StrongTowns I literally know five couples who have done exactly this

Post attachment
Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 15

I think Austin is giving us a fascinating real-time experiment. Maybe the reforms really have lowered the price at which substantial housing production can be sustained. If so, that's important and I want to understand it. Let's keep watching the data.

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 15

Also that “pre-pandemic average” is the 2000–2019 average. That includes the housing crash and years of depressed permitting that followed. If we're comparing to pre-pandemic rate of housing production, wouldn't something like 2012–2019 be the more meaningful comparison?

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 15

Your more interesting claim is that reforms have made pre-2019 production levels “sustainable” at much lower rents. Maybe! That would be important and exciting, but how can we know they're sustainable when permitting hasn't stabilized yet?

Charles Marohn avatar
Charles Marohn@clmarohn·Sep 15

I'm puzzled by this as a response @aarmlovi. I didn't argue that falling rents cause builders to stop building. I argued that as rents decline, production slows. Your chart seems to show exactly that. Metro permits have fallen from 50.9k to 24.4k and the line is still declining.

Austin permitting continues to print above pre-pandemic averages, even as real rents have fallen ~30% below 2019 levels Builders are not "withdrawing supply". They're still building! YIMBY reforms made pre-2019 permitting rates sustainable at substantially lower real rents

Post attachment