
Analyzing the 1930s Great Plains Shelterbelt, a large-scale forestation program across the US Midwest, from Florian Grosset-Touba, @annapappp, and @ctaylor463 nber.org/papers/w35695

environmental economics, agriculture, climate, satellites, ancient dna, fiction. past @columbia, @areberkeley. asst prof at harvard @kennedy_school.

Analyzing the 1930s Great Plains Shelterbelt, a large-scale forestation program across the US Midwest, from Florian Grosset-Touba, @annapappp, and @ctaylor463 nber.org/papers/w35695

10/ Finally, suggestive signs migrants reshaped where they landed. Using fossil pollen records, we find that destinations that drew migrants from a given origin saw vegetation drift toward that origin's, with cereals rising under farmers and the tree–grass balance shifting. Movement may have nudged ecology, not just followed it. [drive.google.com/file/d/1GeE…]

9/ People even migrated to stay in their climate. When home warmed, later generations tended to settle somewhere cooler, partly offsetting the shift. Migration kept their environment roughly constant as the climate moved underfoot.

8/ Warming widened where crops could grow, coinciding with Neolithic farmer expansions; cooling expanded grasslands, tracking Bronze-Age steppe expansions. A model using climate and the local subsistence mix recovers the timing of these episodes.

7/ Migration also tracked climate itself. We use reconstructions of Holocene temperature across the region and ask how movement responded as the climate warmed and cooled.

6/ And which dimension mattered depended on how you lived. Farmers matched on growing-season heat and soil; herders on rainfall; foragers stayed closest to home. No single geographic confounder explains matching on three orthogonal gradients at once, or the farmer/herder split.

5/ Even beyond travel cost, migration falls with ecological distance: differences in temperature, rainfall, and soil. A one SD ecological gap deters movement about as much as 700 km of extra terrain. People settled where the environment matched what they knew.

4/ And how far people moved tracked how they lived. Pastoralists were the most mobile group in our data; their wealth, livestock, walks to new pasture, while farmers and foragers stayed closer to home.

3/ And people and populations moved far. Linked pairs span 1,550 km on average. One Yamnaya-associated burial near Samara (c. 3200 BCE) is closely related to people 2,600 km east in Siberia and 2,200 km west in Europe within a few centuries: one lineage spanning the continent.

2/ The hypothesis: know-how was tied to environment. Knowing how to farm a cool growing season or herd an arid steppe didn't transfer to a new climate, so people should have moved toward places that felt ecologically familiar, matching what their skills were built for.

1/ What moved people before states, markets, or borders? We turn ancient DNA into a direct measure of prehistoric migration. When two ancient individuals share a long segment of inherited DNA (identity-by-descent, IBD), they share a recent ancestor, so someone in that lineage moved between their burial sites. Counting these links between places, and dating them, gives a directional map of migration across 10,000 years of western Eurasia.
Using ancient DNA data to measure migration over the past 10,000 years shows that human mobility followed climate corridors and migration acted as adaptation to climate change, from Peter Huybers, Marco Tabellini, @ctaylor463, and Francesco Toti nber.org/papers/w35371

Very much enjoyed moderating last night’s panel discussion on the topic of “Frontiers in Climate-Economics Research: Dynamics, Uncertainty, and Policy Implications,” featuring Charles Taylor (Harvard Kennedy School), James Rising (University of Delaware), and Olivier David Zerbib (CREST, ENSAE, Institut Polytechnique de Paris). The conversation covered a broad range of important issues and the panelists brought perspectives that were distinct yet complementary, which made for an engaging discussion and no doubt a valuable one for our @MFRProgram Modeling Climate-Economic Dynamics workshop participants and the young scholars in attendance. #EconTwitter #ClimateEconomics #ClimateDynamics #ClimateUncertainty #ClimateChange

But adaptation carries a cost. Where irrigation expands, aquifer levels drop and soils grow saltier — both visible from satellite. Adapting to climate change today can erode the future resource base [drive.google.com/file/d/12dx…]

Using soil/sediment thickness as a proxy for groundwater potential, I find drying raises irrigation only where water is reachable below. Recent climate drying explains up to 8% of global irrigation growth since 1960 — a pattern that holds both worldwide and across US counties.

The evidence on farmer adaptation to climate change is mixed. But adaptation is hard to see — it may come thru slow, fixed investments like irrigation. Over the last 50 years, many places got wetter and many got drier. Farmers can make up for lost rainfall by digging a well.

Aside: historically, irrigation was from surface water. Canals were critical to urbanization and early state formation, and the earliest maps were drawn around the rivers and irrigated deltas of the ancient world's cities. Ptolemy's Geography (150 CE) upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped…