←
Craig Tindale33,571 posts
Craig Tindale avatar

Craig Tindale

@ctindale

A few of my thoughts on hard-to-understand issues. I write only to help awaken everyone from their slumber.

◷ Joined December 2008▧ 2,344 Photos and videos
Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·14h

Everything was better in the 70s . It really was better . It was simpler . You could go see AC/DC at a small pub in Sydney and Bon was the singer . David Bowie was still young and cool . I could go on

WE DON'T KNOW!

2:23
Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·16h

There is a rich history of different theories of what happens after AI singularity , we hear the most about the doomer one where AI takes over the world and renders us extinct somehow . There are other theories of singularity that are much more optimistic . This essay is about the evidence we have that it doesn’t turn out like an Arnie movie . The extension theory has AI as just another tool , it’s brilliantly useful but it’s never quite good enough to take us over. If you go further than the extension theory you have some kind of merge between human and technology , trans humanism . I don’t rule that out but not in the next 10 years . It’s just not that smart yet . I called this essay the Era of Judgement because that’s what the next 10 years is about . Human judgement . Folks are going to be very surprised it turns out a shortage of humans is AI limiting factor . Sure they will be the right humans they won’t be every human but super intelligence might limited by super human operators . Just like planes need pilots my guess is so does AI . The extension theory is like Ironman - Jarvis helps you all day and machine’s augment and extend out physical capabilities . Think of it like teams of horses , some maybe able to master 50 horses , others 5 . Agents are similar I have around 100 doing things . My AI agents run out of screens or memory so I have a team agents to manage them and help me so I don’t lose track of things . I’ve joined all the LLM coding platforms together and there are agents who manage between the models . I’ve got a tutor agent that watches me and improves my moves . It’s a bit like having a tennis coach . It’s like some people can play guitar and others cant , and a few can do it really well . It’s an human to ai spectrum just like everything else . It’s a useful thinking essay . Useful in the sense I’ve set out many of the issues in a way folk thoughtfully consider .

Craig Tindale @ctindale Nov 16 Article The Era of Judgment Evidence from the frontier labs of how AI will extend human productivity Read the full essay, with all sources, on Substack: https://ctindale.substack.com/p/the-era-of-judgment The Death of Socrates, Jacques-Louis David, 1787.

Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 17

What I’ve been saying for some time . The AI gurus we ask about the future of the world are the wrong folk to ask because they know about AI not the future of society . Most of them aren’t worldly , they’ve been nerds locked away talking to screens most of their life .

Marc Andreessen explained why the people who invented AI are the worst people to ask about its future, using a mistake Thomas Edison made in 1877... Geoffrey Hinton won a Nobel Prize in 2024 for the work behind modern AI. When people ask Hinton where AI is going, he believes "rampant unemployment" and UBI for everybody. "People think, because he's one of the inventors of AI, that he must be the guy who knows." Andreessen's answer is Thomas Edison. Edison invented the phonograph in 1877. To him, Andreessen says, the use was obvious. Every family would buy a record player and a library of discs with sermons from the great preachers of the time. Then the machine went on sale. "Immediately, of course, it's music. It's ragtime, and swing, then it's jazz. And Edison's just completely horrified." "If Edison didn't know what the phonograph was going to get used for, the idea that Joe AI entrepreneur is going to be able to forecast the economic implications... No. That's not going to happen." Inventors, he says, are "too buried in the specifics of the here and now." He includes himself. "I don't know if there's anybody that can predict big cultural, or economic or social trends, but it's certainly not somebody who's been in the lab for 20 years, including myself."

2:00
Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 17

If he keeps performing like this he has a run nobody predicted . Lets see .

GP Q@argosakiNov 17

MILLER TIME Telling it like it is…

2:50
Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 17

The plans being pushed at COP31 are for machines that suck carbon out of the air are not a viable solution. They plan to build machines at a scale so large they literally can’t be built. That’s their solution ? Take the direct air capture plants mentioned in the Guardian article , that the IPCC models rely on and are being pushed so hard at COP31 . To do the job the pathways assign them would cost on the order of $27 trillion USD in today’s money and cover half a million square kilometres of land. You’d need to dedicate 25% of the world’s metals supply’s to them for the next 20 years . They would take up more land than the entire state of California. The single biggest plant currently under construction, designed to catch half a million tonnes a year, is already years late and still not running. This one cost $1.2-1.5 billion . Scaled up to the numbers the models use, you would need tens of thousands of them. Each one has to move roughly 1,500 tonnes of air for every tonne of carbon dioxide it captures. The energy to run a fleet that size would take a quarter to three-fifths of all the energy the world uses today. ALL OF IT . Isn’t it an insight into our world of today that we have governments mulling over how to build something they literally have no hope of building . It couldn’t get sillier than if someone proposed to build a staircase to the moon The crop-burning version is worse. The middle pathways ask for 3 to 7 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide buried every year by 2050 from burning biomass and storing the exhaust. FFS Right now the entire world removes about 1.3 million tonnes a year with every newer method combined. That is what fossil fuels put into the air in 18 minutes. So we have people busy at COP31 , 99% of whom haven’t built anything in their lives , proposing that we build the biggest machines ever built by humanity . The required jump is five thousand times larger than we’ve currently built . The land for the fuel crops and new forests in those pathways is on the scale of two-thirds the area of Australia. One pathway needs energy crops on land equal to 94 per cent of Australia. The water demand is about 8 per cent of all the fresh water the world currently withdraws. That is land and water that also have to grow food. None of this is in the models. The models put a price on the machines and then ignore the copper, steel and concrete required to build them. Copper is already projected to fall a quarter short of demand by 2035. A new copper mine takes about 17 years from discovery to production. Most of the acid used to extract copper comes from cleaning fossil fuels, the same fuels the plans want to stop using. The models never check whether the mines, the metal or the factories exist. They simply assume the machines will be there in unlimited numbers at a fixed cost so the equations balance. Capture capacity worldwide is a fraction of one per cent of what the pathways require, and even that capacity is not the same as carbon successfully stored. The numbers required for the 2050 targets are larger than the entire oil industry, larger than the land available without colliding with food, and larger than the metal supply the world can produce on the timeline given. The COP31 talks are treating the idea as something that can be written into an agreement and then delivered. The materials, the land, the energy and the working plants do not exist at anything close to the scale demanded. The climate change fanatics are delusional . Not because there is no climate change , but because there is more in the pipeline than can be stopped by any of these methods , COP31 is people busy on the beach building very expensive sandcastles hoping to stop the tsunami. The proposal is not just difficult. It is fucking impossible on the evidence the models themselves supply and then set aside. theguardian.com/environment/…

Craig Tindale @ctindale Oct 12 Article Net-Zero by 2050 Came From Computer Models. So Did the Fictional Fantasy Machines That Make It Work. The decarbonisation models behind Australia's 2050 date require carbon removal Direct Air Capture (DAC) machines at many thousands of times the scale of anything anyone has built, and leave the

Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 16

X won't let me promote this to the COP31 conference audience because it labels it as political messaging. UN policies have accelerated climate change, yet nobody knows how badly they screwed up because it is kept quiet.

Craig Tindale @ctindale Nov 15 Article THE STUPIDEST THING THE UNITED NATIONS EVER DID. The UN Accidentally Sped Up the End of the World We Knew #COP31Turkiye On 1 January 2020, a United Nations agency detonated the climate bomb. The International Maritime Organization, the UN body that

Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 15

Russ Vought runs the White House budget office, which controls how federal money is spent. He is moving fast before Democrats take the House. Russ also wrote Project 2025 and coined the term “ Cold Civil War” . These are the opening salvos in that war . A four-hour nationwide flight grounding on Friday became a $50bn "emergency" within 48 hours. The day before, Vought had asked Congress for $30bn for air traffic control. Democrats point out that $12.5bn approved in 2025 still sits unspent. The same week, Trump ordered Senate Republicans to "IMMEDIATELY" pass $350bn for the Pentagon through a fast-track budget process that needs only Republican votes and can't be blocked by Democrats. They must move before a new Democratic senator is sworn in on 15 Dec. Republican senators Rounds and Tillis warn it raises the risk of a government shutdown. Both demands land on the 11 Dec deadline to fund the government. This isn't about runways. It's the White House locking in money and leverage before the new Congress can stop it. The full picture: (Cold Civil War: The White House Against the House )

Craig Tindale @ctindale Nov 10 Article Cold Civil War: The White House Against the House A president wins an election and issues orders. The orders go to agencies staffed by career officials who were there before he arrived and expect to stay after he leaves. Some orders stall in review,

Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 14

Project 2025 wrote the plan. 2025 put its writers in the posts: Vought holds the money, Berry Labor’s lawyers, Carr the FCC, Winfree advises the Fed chair, Ratcliffe runs the CIA, Homan the border. Project 2027 runs it against a Democratic Congress. x.com/ctindale/article/21202…

Post attachment
Craig Tindale avatar
Craig Tindale@ctindale·Nov 14

Since 1789 Congress has decided what public money is for. Trump is changing that without amending the Constitution: he holds money until it expires and controls who pays it out. From 3 Jan 2027 a Democratic Congress tests whether the old order still holds. x.com/ctindale/article/21202…

Post attachment