←
David Waldner5,471 posts
David Waldner avatar

David Waldner

@davidwaldnerdc

I teach Middle East Politics, democratization, development, state building, and qualitative methods at UVa. Rationalist who believes irrationally in the Mets.

◷ Joined July 2014▧ 116 Photos and videos
David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

@GerryMunck'srecent tweet proposes that my new book, Qualitative Causal Inference and Explanation, makes an important contribution. This brief thread introduces the argument and its potential importance. 1/7

Post attachment
Gerardo L. Munck avatar
⟳ David Waldner retweeted
Gerardo L. Munck@GerardoMunck·Nov 14

Rethinking Process Tracing Process tracing methods are a core feature of qualitative research. But @davidwaldnerdc in Chapter 7 of his new book makes a strong case that these methods have important limitations, in that they do not address possible sources of bias and can lead to false positives. After reading this chapter, I am having a hard time seeing process tracing as I used to.

Post attachment
David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Sep 29

The frontier of AI alignment theory: aligning robot behavior with the law. Very cool approach!

As robots move from research labs into our hospitals, workplaces, and homes, safety will need more than obstacle avoidance. We will need to align robot behavior with the law 🧵

0:07
Gerardo L. Munck avatar
⟳ David Waldner retweeted
Gerardo L. Munck@GerardoMunck·Aug 22

Reading Pearl & Waldner on Causal Inference Since @davidwaldnerdc's new book on qualitative causal inference draws on @yudapearl's seminal work on causal inference and DAGs (directed acyclic graphs), I have pulled 𝘊𝘢𝘶𝘴𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘵𝘺 off my bookshelf & will read them side by side

Post attachment
Gerardo L. Munck avatar
⟳ David Waldner retweeted
Gerardo L. Munck@GerardoMunck·Aug 21

David Waldner’s Three Models of Inference In his new book, @davidwaldnerdc makes a case that qualitative researchers have largely relied on a detective model of inference, while quantitative scholars have increasingly used an identification-based approach to causal inference. The novelty of Waldner's book is that he elaborates an identification strategy suitable to qualitative research that he calls qualitative causal inference. The more I think about this book, the more I am coming to the view that Waldner is on to something important.

Post attachment
David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

The book concludes with a discussion of causal explanations, which are distinct from causal inferences. Qualitative causal inference promises explanations that satisfy explanatory depth, density, relevance, and unification. 7/7

David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

The side-door path offers a principled response to the fundamental problem of causal inference. I also propose diagnostic instruments and remediation measures to manage the implications of systematic errors. 6/7

David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

I propose three new concepts – hypothetical interventions, invariant causal mechanisms, and event-history maps – to probe each path for causal continuity along the front-door path and causal discontinuity along the error-inducing back- and side-door paths. 5/7

David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

The bias-free graph implies three criteria for valid, unit-level inference: one each for the front-, back-, and side-door paths. QCI explains each criterion and its attendant assumptions and provides practical guidance for the method’s application. 4/7

David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

Because causal graphs are non-parametric, they visually represent the presence or absence of systematic bias. Qualitative causal inference distinguishes a bias-saturated casual graph from a bias-free causal graph. 3/7

Post attachment
David Waldner avatar
David Waldner@davidwaldnerdc·Aug 21

All causal claims require an explicit identification strategy to rule out systematic bias due to confoundingness, endogeneity, spuriousness, or measurement error. Process tracing does not incorporate an identification strategy and so is vulnerable to false positives. 2/7

Gerardo L. Munck avatar
⟳ David Waldner retweeted
Gerardo L. Munck@GerardoMunck·Jul 30

David Waldner on Qualitative Methods Assisted by my Turkish coffee, I am digging into @davidwaldnerdc’s book for a second read. Learning about front, back & side-door paths, invariant causal mechanisms, event-history maps, & the connection between causal inference & explanation

Post attachment
Ihtesham Ali avatar
⟳ David Waldner retweeted
Ihtesham Ali@ihteshamali·Apr 25

An MIT professor taught the same math course for 62 years, and the day he retired, students from every country on earth showed up online to watch him give his final lecture. I opened the playlist at 2am and ended up watching three of them back to back. His name is Gilbert Strang. The course is MIT 18.06 Linear Algebra. Every machine learning engineer, every data scientist, every quant, every self-taught programmer who actually understands how AI works learned the math from this one man. Most of them never set foot on MIT's campus. They just opened a free playlist on YouTube and let him teach. Here's the story almost nobody tells you. Strang joined the MIT math faculty in 1962. He retired in 2023. That is 61 years of standing at the same chalkboard teaching the same subject to 18-year-olds. The interesting part is what he did when MIT launched OpenCourseWare in 2002. Most professors were skeptical. They worried that putting their lectures online would make their classrooms irrelevant. Strang did not hesitate. He said his life's mission was to open mathematics to students everywhere. He filmed every lecture and gave it away. The decision quietly changed how the world learns math. For decades linear algebra was taught the wrong way. Professors started with abstract vector spaces and proofs about field axioms. Students drowned in the abstraction. Most never recovered. They walked out believing they were bad at math when they had simply been taught in an order that nobody's brain is built to absorb. Strang inverted the entire curriculum. He started with matrix multiplication. Something you can write down on paper. Something you can compute by hand. Something you can see. Then he showed his students that everything else in linear algebra eigenvectors, singular value decomposition, orthogonality, the four fundamental subspaces was just a different lens for understanding what the matrix was actually doing under the hood. His rule was strict. If a student could not explain a concept using a concrete 3 by 3 example, that student did not actually understand the concept yet. The abstraction was supposed to come last, not first. The intuition was the foundation. The proofs were just confirmation that the intuition was correct. The second thing Strang changed was the classroom itself. He said please and thank you to his students. Every single lecture. He paused mid-derivation to ask "am I OK?" to check if anyone was lost. He never used the word "obviously" or "trivially" because he knew exactly what those words do to a student who is one step behind. He treated 19-year-olds learning math for the first time the way he treated his own colleagues. With patience. With respect. With the assumption that they belonged in the room. For 62 years. The result is something that has never happened in the history of education. A single math professor became the default teacher of his subject for the entire planet. Universities in India, China, Brazil, Nigeria, every country with a computer science department, started telling their own students to just watch Strang's lectures. The University of Illinois revised its linear algebra course to do almost no in-person lecturing. The reason was honest. The professor said they could not compete with the videos. His final lecture was in May 2023. The auditorium was packed with students who had never met him before. He walked to the chalkboard, taught for an hour, and at the end the entire room stood and applauded. He looked confused for a moment, like he genuinely did not understand why they were cheering. Then he smiled and waved them off and walked out. His written comment under the YouTube video of that final lecture was four sentences long. He said teaching had been a wonderful life. He said he was grateful to everyone who saw the importance of linear algebra. He said the movement of teaching it well would continue because it was right. That was it. No book promotion. No farewell speech. No legacy management. The man whose teaching is the foundation of modern AI just thanked the audience and went home. 20 million views. Zero ego. The entire engine of the AI revolution sits on top of math that millions of people learned for free from one quiet professor in Cambridge. The course is still on MIT OpenCourseWare. Every lecture, every problem set, every exam, every solution. Free. The most important math course of the 21st century is sitting one click away from you. Most people will never open it.

Post attachment