University of Illinois research lab where stats meet baseball history. Creators of peer-reviewed era-adjusted WAR. Featured in NYT. Babe Ruth is not the GOAT.
The stats you use to compare baseball players across eras are not era-adjusted, even if they say they are.
WAR, OPS+, ERA+, etc do not account for changes to the talent pool and competition.
A 10-WAR season in 1925 is treated as identical to a 10-WAR season in 2025. It is not.
It's a good list overall! But someone is missing...as usual.
The omission is further validation for writing the following articles with it's subject buried
eracurveball.substack.com/p/…
Every active MLB player who I think has at least a 50% chance of making the Hall of Fame, as of today:
Trout 100%
Scherzer 100%
Judge 100%
Betts 100%
Ohtani 99.9% (10 seasons)
Freeman 99%
Jansen 99%
Sale 99%
Altuve 95%
Kimbrel 90%
Goldy 90%
Harper 85%
Arenado 85%
Machado 85%
JRam 85%
Cole 80%
deGrom 75%
Lindor 75%
Skubal 50% (2 CYAs)
Aroldis 50% (DV)
Soto 50%
Current results after ~1200 votes
Top 13 are all deserving
In my view, any voter out there should:
A. Select the top 4
B. Give Lester up/down vote (1st timer)
C. Give Torii up/down vote (possible last-timer)
D. Fill out the remaining 10 slots with any of the remaining top 13
"Cole Hamels is ultimately a no"
That is a natural place to land when you are stuck in thinking that the pitching statistics from wins to WAR are remotely comparable across eras.
When you use stats that are era-adjusted-accounting for talent pool, competitive environment, and pitching usage-then Hamels's standing rises considerably.
For example, he ranks 35th all-time among pitchers in era-adjusted JAWS. He's ahead of Smoltz, Marichal, Bunning, Drysdale, Kid Nichols, Koufax, etc.
It may not be the sexiest case as judged awards. But I'm sure the 2008 Phillies appreciated having him en route to a winning the World Series, as he won the NLCS and WS MVPs!
I think Cole Hamels has a better case for the HOF than most (ultimately a no), but you can in fact vote for Felix and not Hamels. It all comes down to peak performance:
Felix: 1X Cy Young, 2X Cy Young Runner-Up, 2X ERA Title
Cole: 1X Top 5 Cy Young Finish
From 2009-2015, Felix was one of the best pitchers in baseball. Cole just was never in that conversation.
Check out this project over at University of Illinois that attempts to model adjustments for players based on the era they played in… really interesting stuff. Technical and thoughtful.
Babe Ruth is automatically invalidated because he played against plumbers in a segregated league
This argument is just as silly as ignoring external contextual factors which shape statistical expressions of the game's greatest players.
While I think that Babe Ruth is one of the most overrated players by the general public, he absolutely belongs in the Inner Circle-even from a true talent standpoint, historical significance aside.
Ruth is firmly top 10 by era-adjusted WAR. I do think that his standing would fall if we modeled more factors (see here for a discussion: eckeraadjustment.web.illinoi…). But, all things considered, I think Ruth would still land in the top 10 all-time.
Fun project, and nice work by @sn_mlb@PaulHembo@TheWARmonger_!
Sporting News 140 Greatest Players
The Inner Circle
Baseball history can be cleanly divided into two acts - before Babe Ruth picked up a bat and after he turned the home run into its most valuable currency and grandest spectacle.
Another great inner circle selection!
Ohtani's run of 4 consecutive seasons ranks #1 all-time among 4-year peaks by our era-adjusted stats.
The greatest sustained peak in baseball history is certainly worthy of inclusion in the inner circle!
eckeraadjustment.web.illinoi…
*Greatest, of course, as defined by these metrics.
Sporting News 140 Greatest Players
The Inner Circle
Decades of evidence declared two-way prowess an impossibility, and then a miracle befell us in the person of Shohei Ohtani.
He also put up the 10th best season all-time by era-adjusted OPS!
The stat accounts for talent pool, competitive environment, and handedness-specific park factors.
See more here: eckeraadjustment.web.illinoi…
Agreed!
I recently wrote a HOF case study for a certain active pitcher. The essay is both stats and narrative. The narrative attempts to elevate lore behind the player with some color.
I fed the essay into Claude to see if I should post it. Claude stripped away the color and returned something boring! But it did correct some typos which was nice.
Here is the essay for anyone interested: eracurveball.substack.com/p/…
I hate *everything* about this advice
I’m vigorously pro-humanity, artists, and originality; the unique potential of human creativity and ingenuity is BIG with me. AI should be used as a tool, not a substitute.
Becoming part of this homogenized, genericized, fungible, copycat, viral-for-views ecosystem doesn’t HAVE to be your destiny.
GO FORTH AND BE AUTHENTIC
To be clear, Walter Johnson and Lou Gehrig are entirely defensible selections. We're splitting hairs among some of the greatest players ever, and reasonable people can disagree.
My point is simply that era-adjusted statistics make a compelling case for reconsidering some of the traditional inner circle choices.
No project can be perfect, and this is where I think the inner-circle selection takes a bit of a hit.
Walter Johnson's traditional WAR totals benefit from a smaller historical talent pool and pitching workloads that aren't directly comparable to those of modern starters. After adjusting for those factors, several pitchers surpass him in era-adjusted JAWS (see screenshot).
Among them:
Roger Clemens
Greg Maddux
Randy Johnson
Tom Seaver
Lefty Grove
Justin Verlander
Clayton Kershaw.
Pedro Martínez is also remarkably close.
Of course, statistics aren't everything. But several of these pitchers have compelling cases.
I suspect part of the difficulty is that Walter Johnson is the safer consensus choice. Clemens is a Pariah, while Randy Johnson and Maddux are difficult to separate. Verlander and Kershaw present another close call.
If I were making the selection, I'd replace Walter Johnson and Lou Gehrig with Randy Johnson and either Mike Schmidt or Greg Maddux depending on how many pitchers one wants in the inner circle.
That's not a dismissal of either legend. It's a recognition that historical reputation and era-adjusted baseball greatness don't always point to the same names.
Sporting News 140 Greatest Players
The Inner Circle
With an effortless delivery and a hissing fastball, Walter Johnson made pitching look as natural as playing catch and hitting a hopeless endeavor.
Ty Cobb remains elite after adjusting for talent pool size!
Our method cuts about 35 WAR off his total due to Cobb competing during a much smaller talent pool.
But Cobb earned about 150 WAR. Cutting 35 off that total still lands top 10 all-time. His batting average also remains firmly within the top 10 among players with 8000 PAs.
That said, his JAWS sits at 10th among position players. And its likely that he gets passed by Trout.
Cobb is still close to inner circle!
eckeraadjustment.web.illinoi…
Sporting News 140 Greatest Players
The Inner Circle
The defining player of the dead-ball era, Ty Cobb turned the diamond into a battlefield on which blood was spilt -- rarely his and often yours.
Great inclusion of Josh Gibson!
We have preliminary era-adjusted stats for Gibson, and they support this inclusion. He's the best catcher all-time, and his rate stats rival Babe Ruth!
Sporting News 140 Greatest Players
The Inner Circle
Josh Gibson went to his grave knowing what few acknowledged then and many do now - he was Babe Ruth’s equal at the plate, and he did it while playing baseball’s most demanding position.