Many are debating how to price AI's promise. Few are pricing in what happened to the machinery that sets prices, and how often and badly it can now misprice the best businesses on the planet.
THE TWO CLOCKS, an essay: Long-term ownership in a passive market
Ian Buck was on the Nvidia call, but nobody asked him by far the most important question of how the company will maintain Jensen's insane product leadership and pace of innovation?
find myself rooting for Jensen without having nearly all of the needed facts to arrive at the right conclusion, which means what a post by Team Jensen.
here is Claude's breakdown of the strategy and psychology, which seems mainly correct to me:
********
This post is a negotiating document written in the form of an apology. Jensen can’t force his way back, so the whole thing is built to make a “no” from the board as expensive as possible while handing them a face-saving way to say yes.
Why he posted today
He chose the earnings day on purpose. NVIDIA will host a conference call on Tuesday, November 17, at 2 p.m. PT (5 p.m. ET), and Kress then holds a company-wide staff meeting on Wednesday. Posting before the call does 3 things:
1) It sets the agenda for Kress’s first call. Every analyst now has to ask whether a Huang return is on the table. Kress either rejects him publicly, in front of the market and 150,000 petitioners, or she dodges and the door stays open. Both outcomes help him.
2) It runs a live test of what he’s worth to the stock. Shares of Nvidia are bouncing after founder Jensen Huang broke his silence. The board gets to watch his value show up in the stock in real time.
3) It works whatever the numbers show. A strong print, and he built the machine. A weak print or a shaky Kress, and they need him back. Posting after the call would have looked like riding a good print or circling a bad one. Posting before it puts him on record either way.
There’s an undercurrent about Kress too. The Wall Street Journal reported, citing an anonymous source, that Jensen Huang described Collette Kress as “a deer in the headlights” during a presentation earlier this summer. Employees will read his post the night before her all-hands. He casts her as a caretaker without ever naming her.
What each paragraph is doing
Paragraph 1 (gratitude). He opens with popular support before he admits anything. “People I’ve never met” tells you the support goes beyond insiders. He’s establishing the support behind him before he concedes anything.
Paragraph 2 (America). This is the paragraph that matters most. The real threat to him is the national security story and the export-compliance story. Bessent said on TV he wants to get an explanation on this culture of non-compliance at Nvidia and cited reporting that only 1% of the chips sold in Singapore remained in Singapore. Jensen never responds to any of this directly. He answers with 53 years in the country, citizenship, “nowhere but in America,” “I love our country.” He’s answering a loyalty question with a declaration of loyalty without restating the charge.
Paragraph 3 (the apology). The wording is precise. He made “serious mistakes in my personal life.” This sentence draws the boundary of the scandal around his private conduct and keeps it away from the export and compliance issues. The investigation is examining whether Huang had been a target of a foreign intelligence effort, and Bessent is pushing toward corporate conduct. Jensen is fencing off the ground he can survive on. “I created problems for the Board that I deeply regret” is aimed straight at the 10 people who decide. It accepts that they had to act, which makes reversing easier for them. “Cooperating with the investigation” names the investigation as the gate, which sets up the next move: clear the probe, then come back.
Paragraph 4 (the ask). “Many continue to reach out to me directly” is the sharpest line in the post. It tells the board that customers and partners still call him and not the interim CEO, so the relationships go wherever he goes. He never states a threat. His allies do it for him. Musk posted that “critical deals will be lost” without Huang, and an employee letter said “Elon Musk has assured us that there are positions for all Nvidia employees at Space and Terafab should we choose to join”. This is good cop, bad cop. Allies carry the stick and Jensen holds the olive branch.
“Answer these calls” frames a return as answering a call to duty. Ambition becomes service, and any refusal reads as the board overriding what employees, investors and customers want.
Then “and America” appears in the conditional. He adds the country to the list of stakeholders in a corporate board decision. This invites Washington into the boardroom, specifically the part of Washington that likes him. President Donald Trump called Jensen Huang on Tuesday and urged Nvidia’s then-CEO to fight for his job. Bessent is on the other side. The “America” framing sets the President’s loyalty against the Treasury Secretary’s demand for a shake-up, and leaves the board in between.
The game theory
Before this post the board had cover: he resigned, and the board was simply running a search. After this post, any outcome without Jensen is the board actively turning down a founder who said yes publicly, with 7,000+ self-identified Nvidia employees among the more than 150,000 signatures pushing for him. The burden of justifying the outcome has moved onto the board.
At the same time, “If the Board of Directors decides” is a golden bridge. It confirms their authority and lets them reverse course later, saying the facts came in and they decided on their own. Look at how closely it matches the Gerstner and Baker letter: “If after all the facts are known the Board decides that it is not in shareholders’ best interest to have Jensen Huang back as CEO, that is the Board’s prerogative,” The sentence structure is nearly identical. Add the FT’s reporting that allies are building a “war room” of Silicon Valley executives to press Nvidia’s board to reinstate Huang and to seek White House support, and this reads like a coordinated script. I can’t confirm the coordination. The matching language is the evidence for it.
This is the Altman November 2023 playbook almost exactly: an employee revolt, a ready-made alternative employer (Musk and Terafab playing the role Microsoft played), investor letters, and a humble statement of love for the company. The differences make this one harder. Altman never admitted misconduct, and no cabinet official went on Sunday TV demanding an outside CEO. Bessent also put a clock on it: he wants answers within the next 10 days, which runs to roughly November 25.
Over the past week, I’ve been overwhelmed by the love and support of friends, industry colleagues, and people I've never met. Thank you to everyone who has shown kindness to my family and me. It means the world to me.
I came to the United States 53 years ago, and becoming an American citizen is one of the greatest gifts and proudest moments of my life. NVIDIA has been my life’s work. Building it into the company it is today alongside my colleagues has been a privilege and an honor. Nowhere but in America could a company like NVIDIA be possible. I love our country, and I love NVIDIA.
I did not live up to the standards expected of everyone at NVIDIA, and I have made serious mistakes in my personal life. I created problems for the Board that I deeply regret. I own my mistakes completely, and I am committed to cooperating with the Board’s independent investigation.
Since my departure, I’ve seen an outpouring of calls from NVIDIA’s employees, investors, business partners, and customers for me to return as CEO. Many continue to reach out to me directly as the company navigates complex technology, market, competitive, and geopolitical dynamics. NVIDIA is a once-in-a-generation company. If the Board of Directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO.
Thank you again to everyone who has shared their good wishes. I am profoundly humbled by your support. To my family: I love you, and I will spend the rest of my life being worthy of yours.
Jensen
for all of us who wanted nothing more than for Jensen to stay at nvidia: he's beloved by SHs and the board can be replaced quickly as it is declassified / whole board stands for election every year. So why step down instead of fight? and why hire Melinda Haag and Walt Brown from Paul Weiss, two of the best white collar defense lawyers in the country, instead of the best proxy fight lawyers?
in the meantime, Bill McDermott is somewhere right now rehearsing the most impassioned plea one has ever heard about why he needs to be NVIDIA's next CEO.
in a perfect world where SHs fully understood the situation and reasonable minds would agree Jensen's actions could be separated from his fiduciary duties as CEO, maintaining trust with employees, customers, govts, etc, of course SHs would want Jensen to stay.
But this proposal is literally backwards. SHs elect board members to be their reps in situations like this. If the board said he needs to go, they would be concluding the above is unfortunately not possible. If the NVIDIA board simply passed the decision back to SHs, the board should just all resign.
Importantly, what information would SHs even be working with here in a vote? If the board's conclusion were that going through a lengthy investigation would be pointless at this stage in light of new information received in the last 24+ hours, clearly they would be saying there's a lot more to it than we might know. If the board moves, they would have to be concluding that they’ve seen something very inconsistent with Jensen staying…otherwise ousting him quickly would clearly be a disastrous decision by the board.
A much better solution for NVIDIA’s board, shareholders, customers and employees (and America) would to (a) finish their investigation and (b) make @JensenHuang the chairman if it comes to that.
To clarify: if you think giving China some H200s over the next 2 years could catapult them past the US in an insurmountable way, you should probably be anti export. This seems like a stretch to me. If you think exporting H200s will keep Huawei from achieving scale, this seems to have made more sense 12-24 months ago, but looks like Beijing has made its call and is rationing imports to protect Huawei. So being pro export for this reason also seems like a stretch.
Agreed, but if China has already decided that it will ultimately require its companies to figure out how to develop satisfactory hardware within the country, what are those for and against exporting less powerful Nvidia GPUs really arguing about? The pro export crowd should view older Nvidia chip sales as temporary / unsustainable and therefore not worth spending much time on, and the anti export crowd should also view these sales as not worth losing sleep over since it shouldn’t prove to the the reason China caught up and stayed there if that happens.
Lots of thought provoking takes on $NVDA last 24 hrs from technologists and investors...but almost nobody in the investor camp is talking about how getting close to management can affect your judgment and process. Key man risk has sat near the top of every nvidia pre mortem for years. Most of us gave it a low probability on a 5-7 year view, while a report says the key man had a sex scandal PR firm on retainer for a year, per Wired. so if you’ve spent considerable time and effort building close relationships here, the 1x1s, conferences, dinners, podcasts, etc, and you enjoy the access (it makes your process feel heavier, and it's fun!), and you’d like the access to continue, can you be as curious and flexible right now as you might be if you'd engaged in none of it. For long horizon selective investors, the cost of management access is badly underweighted imo, especially now that most of what you’d want to know for what matters most for the LT is public.
Agree on crowding. but note I didn't say duration alone. every year the market disagrees with you, growing FCF/sh shrinks the years of FCF you paid for upfront. Compounding FCF/sh is the ultimate catalyst.
one of the very key things that are missed here is one very large assumption: AI, commoditisation of alt data, general crowding or simply increased capital formation on similar strategies drives shorter term alpha decay
within this is a huge assumption that more perfect information increases the efficiency of the price mechanism at T0
however, we're ignoring that this type of situtation is actually probably more likely to exacerbate bias (AI driven or human driven)
which in turn creates 2 things, higher likelihood of mispricing at T0 which results in potentially higher vol in the short term while presenting plenty of opportunities to capitalise on this for the contrarian investor
admittedly investment style and process is not as simple as fundamentals only, all the other factors have to be considered but I don't the answer is just 'more duration' albeit that does help
investors equipped with existing contrarian skills with a deep understanding of what type of catalyst drives a narrative switch for you to get paid on that position will be even more valuable going forward
But given these dynamics, what type of multiple should owners of the SpaceX equity put on the compute rental revenues, particularly when we’re in the short compute situation?
I'd encourage anyone interested in investing to mostly disregard this kind of smart-sounding rhetoric. If short-term prices trade less on fundamentals, the payoff for a long horizon gets bigger, as long as fundamentals still win over 10+ years. The only claim that kills "old school investing" is that they don't. The price could be bigger drawdowns along the way. Maybe it takes 10 years to show. But if you're right on the business, and your entry point is such that the years of free cash flow you’re paying for upfront is manageable and will quickly shrink as the business grows, and your capital can wait, the stock will eventually get too cheap to ignore. Sure, if you can skillfully protect against some of the path pain, you'll be better off. But the idea that winning over the next 20, 50 and 100 years comes from something other than investing makes no sense.
I’m not sure how you can observe what just happened over the past week and takeaway that anybody should be leaning into “old school” stock picking but let’s unpack why a bit:
"buying cheap companies": lets start with the fact that in a world where a larger share of the market's x-sectional vol is factor vol vs. idio vol (x.com/0xFaust12/status/21009…) that "cheap" is not a sufficient criteria for an investment to follow your thesis. Being blind to factor exposures of the position, counterparty dynamics like crowding, and short term fundamental trends are all forces that can/will move your position against you even if you have long "duration". In practice, buying a "cheap" company means holding a position(s) with negative to neutral momentum, positive residual volatility, negative perhaps negative profitability which are generally deleterious bets to be making and will present a drag on your total return during your holding period.
"accepting volatility and holding for 2-5 years": I don't have too much new to say here other than the fact that it is more likely your "long duration" horizon will result in you holding 50-60% drawdowns vs. 20-30% ones (you can confirm empirically), so in trying to be more clever than the pods you will in fact have constructed a much worse quality return stream for yourself (cough cough Lone Pine, Eminence, etc). Moreover, old school fundamental investing does not make use of risk models in the modern sense and, per the above, in a market increasingly trading less on fundamentals, your approximation of risk will be even less relevant leading to the deeper than expected drawdowns noted above.
I couldn't get the thought out of my head so I had to map it out.
This chart shows the COVID winners from April 2020-Dec 31 2021 plotted against the AI Bottleneck 40 from April 2025-today.
Look at the overlay and look at the correlations, it's jaw-dropping!
What matters now is further productizing the new trajectory. When looking at political, financing and public equity markets, the message is clear that it’s time for the labs and others to show a steady march to AI handling 10%+ of today’s knowledge worker equivalent work by 2031.
I said at the time - and repeatedly since - that things changed in November 2025, that the pace sped up, and that we were on a new trajectory. There's no denying now that was true. So, for the record: things changed again in September 2026. We are on a new trajectory.
Listening to this, seeing the insanely quick ARR ramp of Anthropic, OpenAI and other successful AI natives, and now seeing Anthropic basically miss its ideal IPO window begs the question of whether fast growing AI natives that are capital hungry should IPO sooner. When an AI native finds strong product-market fit, ARR is off to the races. But the consequence could be susceptibility to hitting the dreaded growth decel almost as fast. If this dynamic proves out and these companies will need a lot of capital to reach their next S curves, maybe we get more companies IPO’ing earlier going forward.
DoorDash’s inference spend has plateaued the last 1.5 months after rising 20x this year, according to co-founder Andy Fang.
He’s been discussing with Tony Xu: “if we’re seeing ROI from the spend, wouldn’t we want to spend more?"
FOODY: “Are you able to share how much you guys are spending on inference right now?”
FANG: “I’ll say a stat, that I think our inference spend has gone up 20x since the beginning of the year.”
FOODY: “How much do you expect it to go up over the next 24 months?”
FANG: “Well, I would say even the past month and a half, it’s plateaued. It hasn’t shrunk, but it’s definitely flatlined. I think there’s definitely efforts we’ve had internally to curb the spend. [...] And I was just talking to Tony, our CEO, about this earlier today. If we’re seeing ROI from the spend, wouldn’t we want to spend more, right? And so I think that’s the thing everybody’s trying to figure out, is where are those opportunities? Because let’s say if you’re generating revenue from token spend, you would spend that token spend all day, right? But I think a lot of what we’re focused on as an industry right now, quite frankly, is cost efficiency and all that stuff.”