
Five Lessons from a Losing School Board Candidate As some of you might know, I ran for the Indianapolis school board this year. If you didn't know, it's because I deliberately kept that political work on other social media channels. And I intend to keep it that way, other than to acknowledge that this was not an especially good year to run as an Independent in a district that is 80 percent Democrat—even against three Democratic opponents. But I mention the race now because I came away with several observations from the campaign trail that seem worth sharing, particularly with my friends in the school reform community. I acknowledge that these observations are anecdotal. But they were far too prominent to ignore, and I think they offer some important warning signs. Here you go, in no particular order… The public is genuinely clueless about school funding. And we haven't made it easy for them to become informed. My local district spends, at minimum, $22,000 per student. That's the number I used in my campaign because it was the lowest of three different published figures, ranging from $22,000 in the district's own budget to as high as $31,000 in federal reporting, with state figures falling somewhere in between. But most people simply didn't believe the number. Chalkbeat even included a disclaimer in my candidate profile saying they couldn't confirm the figure, despite my having provided three sources supporting that amount or more! And among those who did believe it, many struggled to contextualize the number—or simply responded reflexively that the schools "need it!" Okay. Maybe they do need more than HALF A MILLION DOLLARS for every classroom of 25 students. Granted, that money supports much more than the classroom itself. But wouldn't it be nice to have some understanding of where all that money goes? And why, with that level of funding, can't we pay teachers more? Why is ANY teacher still spending personal funds on classroom supplies? I've seen polling suggesting that much of the public, including many teachers, believes schools spend only around $5,000 per student. That level of misunderstanding represents a failure of the media, policymakers and those of us working to improve schools. And, frankly, it's also a failure of teachers unions, which have done a remarkably poor job of translating available education funding into better teacher compensation. "Cuts" to school funding remain a powerful rallying cry—even when the reality is more complicated. Indiana lawmakers have enacted property tax reforms that limit the growth in revenues schools and other local governments had anticipated. But limits on projected growth are typically portrayed as actual funding cuts. That distinction matters. The resulting controversy helped fuel an extraordinary round of school operating referenda, with 27 of 39 proposals passing statewide. That included the Indianapolis referendum, which, for the first time, will share proceeds with charter schools. That last point might seem to contradict my next observation. Except that charter schools were themselves frequently blamed for the need for the referendum. Of course, plenty of blame also fell on Indiana's Republican-led legislature, which has been repeatedly accused of "starving" urban districts like Indianapolis. Yet even as IPS has lost enrollment over the years, its overall funding has often remained steady or increased—meaning that per-pupil funding has continued to rise. And still, the narrative that urban schools are being systematically defunded remains remarkably powerful. All of this points to a growing need for policymakers—and, I would argue, the media!—to do a much better job of reporting PER-PUPIL funding levels, distinguishing actual cuts from reductions in anticipated growth and examining how much funding genuinely reaches classrooms. The charter school brand is in trouble. Yes, I know. Charter schools have always been polarizing. I've been involved in these battles since 1995, so none of that is news to me. But Indianapolis is a city where more students now attend charter schools than attend the traditional district, and where multiple studies have found stronger academic outcomes among charter students. You might think that would make the charter school brand somewhat less controversial. Apparently not. Especially among some of the educated, politically engaged voters I encountered, the word "charter" seemed almost toxic. You would have thought every charter school in Indianapolis had been named after our current president. (None has, of course.) This was one of the more surprising and troubling observations from the campaign. It suggests that even where charter schools have become a major part of the educational landscape, the political narrative surrounding them may be moving in the opposite direction. There's much more I could say about this, but I'll save some of that for another day. Academic performance seemed not to matter much. I've grown accustomed to the familiar explanations for poor academic performance in urban districts: poverty, student demographics, special education needs, language barriers and so forth. But this time, academic performance itself almost seemed like a dead issue. And that was genuinely strange to me. In the final days of the campaign, I raised concerns about the district's low participation in career and technical education. And that actually seemed to get some attention. But the fact that roughly one-quarter of third graders weren't reading proficiently, or that approximately 80 percent of students weren't meeting certain state academic benchmarks? Those numbers seemed almost accepted as inevitable. The winning candidate rarely discussed academics beyond emphasizing the importance of reading. Another candidate suggested that academics were fine and would largely take care of themselves if families would simply stop leaving the district. In a district facing such serious academic challenges, that apparent lack of urgency was confounding. And for those of us who believe that academic outcomes should be central to public education, it ought to be deeply concerning. The definition of "grassroots" can be remarkably selective. One of the more frustrating aspects of the campaign was watching the teachers union and a relatively small group of politically active parents and community members establish themselves as the district's "real grassroots." Their influence was unmistakable. Voters embraced their slate cards, and the media frequently reinforced their grassroots credentials. Yet the network supporting my campaign included parents and students who, demographically and experientially, looked much more like the families actually served by the district. Our coalition, however, was routinely dismissed as a "charter group." Meanwhile, a self-described Parent Council, composed largely of middle-class white women in a district serving a student population that is roughly 80 percent minority, was readily accepted as the authentic grassroots voice. To be clear, those parents have every right to organize, advocate and influence elections. And the winning candidate also enjoyed support from several left-wing activist organizations, including the Democratic Socialists of America, whose members may well have represented a genuine grassroots political movement. But a successful political organization is not necessarily representative of the families whose children attend the schools. And that distinction seemed largely lost in the public conversation. So what does all of this mean? There are certainly more observations I could share. But these five stood out most, and I think they deserve some serious reflection from those of us who have spent years—or decades—working to improve public education. We can continue to debate school funding, charter schools, accountability and academic performance among ourselves. But if voters don't understand the funding, distrust the educational options, aren't especially motivated by academic results and look elsewhere for their political cues, we have a much larger challenge than any particular school board election. For whatever may be learned from a losing school board candidate, I hope these observations offer something useful. And perhaps the most important lesson is this: If we want education reform to succeed, we need to understand not only what makes schools better, but what actually persuades the public to demand better schools.

















