←
David Krizaj837 posts
David Krizaj avatar

David Krizaj

@dkrizaj

Professor of Ophthalmology & Visual Sciences Director, Vision Research Training Program, University of Utah

◷ Joined January 2011▧ 9 Photos and videos
Micah G. Allen avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Micah G. Allen@micahgallen·Nov 11

Abstract concepts like BEAUTY and FRIENDSHIP rely on sensory-motor, mentalizing, and social-interaction brain systems, challenging the assumption that they require amodal representations. This converging evidence supports a hierarchical multiple-representation framework where semantic content dictates which specific neural substrates are engaged. sciencedirect.com/science/ar…

Post attachment
Dion Dickman avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Dion Dickman@dion_synapse·Nov 11

Is the active zone scaffold RIM required at every synapse? Not even close. 🧠 Out now in @ScienceAdvances: RIM is essential at a high-Pr phasic synapse but largely dispensable at its tonic neighbor. Led by the fantastic Rebecca Stark and team! 👏 science.org/doi/10.1126/scia…

Doris Tsao avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Doris Tsao@doristsao·Oct 18

The outpouring of interest in our paper has been … a bit insane. May I make four points? 1. We have not shown that “consciousness has a frame rate.” I can see why people draw this conclusion: we report that inferotemporal and prefrontal cortex alternate between conscious and suppressed states roughly every 60 ms during binocular rivalry. Consciousness depends on many brain areas, and our paper reports results from only a few select nodes. We still don’t know how conscious access works--the actual recipe for generating conscious experience. What we have shown is that deep in the brain there is an extremely strong signal, rich enough to reconstruct a high-dimensional face in detail, that is inaccessible to consciousness. As I argued in the original tweet, this makes the problem of conscious access a lot more experimentally tractable. But to claim “consciousness has a frame rate,” one would need to have actually solved the mechanism for conscious access and shown that this mechanism operates at a frame rate. While we currently don’t know conclusively one way or the other (see VanRullen & Koch, 2003 for a review of positive evidence), I personally am skeptical that consciousness has a frame rate. I believe the brain, within posterior parietal cortex, has continuous tracking mechanisms that actively represent the persistence of matter, including ourselves as physical bodies. The coupling between these persistent tracking processes and feature representations across the brain (like those in face patches) is, I think, the essential mechanism of conscious access. This coupling need not happen at the rate of inferotemporal alternations (and inferotemporal cortex itself may not even alternate outside of the artificial situation of binocular rivalry). As an analogy: imagine the area crucial for conscious access holding a steady drone note, while inferotemporal cortex alternates between two notes, one in harmony and one dissonant. Inferotemporal content might couple to the drone only at moments of harmony, yet experience would still be continuous, because the drone itself (the tracking process that I believe is at the core of conscious perception) never stops. And areas without conflicting content, like auditory cortex during visual rivalry, could stay in continuous harmony with the drone. In sum, there is no reason to conclude from our study that consciousness is discrete, with a "frame rate." 2. Our results resemble Jezek et al. 2011 (as @jjsakon notes). Jezek et al. trained rats in two boxes that were identical except for their lighting cues, so that hippocampal place cells formed two distinct maps, one per box. They then “teleported” the rat by abruptly switching the lights. For a few seconds afterwards, CA3 place-cell activity flickered between the two maps, synced to the theta cycle (~125 ms). @StanDehaene first pointed this paper out to me, and reading it blew me away. To my mind it is the strongest evidence for a bistable attractor in the brain, because the competing maps are stored within the hippocampus itself. I think the phenomenon we see may be very similar at the circuit level: a bistable attractor network within inferotemporal cortex that alternately converges to one of two patterns, as cells in face patches work together to build a coherent representation of the input. In our case, both images are present in the input, so the competition could arise within IT or be inherited from earlier areas such as V1--recording there is an important next step. (It also still puzzles me that we didn’t see strong coherence between face patches ML and AM.) More broadly, what’s different about our paper is the brain area (inferotemporal cortex, often modeled as a feedforward DNN) and the ability to relate the two competing patterns to consciousness, with one granted conscious access and the other not. 3. Please comment on bioRxiv! The Twitter attention has been cool, but I really hope colleagues will be generous enough to post detailed commentary on bioRxiv, where there are currently 0 comments. As @seemaychou points out, peer review doesn’t have to come from just three anonymous reviewers. We would be truly grateful for your critical feedback. 4. Stay tuned This work was done at Caltech, Berkeley, in collaboration with @EngelTatiana at Princeton, funded by NIH and HHMI. I hope to share our vision soon for how we can solve consciousness @AsteraInstitute

1/ We discovered something totally unexpected about the neural structure of consciousness that overturns decades of thinking on its biological basis and brings us significantly closer to the recipe for generating conscious awareness. New preprint: biorxiv.org/content/10.64898… (led by @HesseJanis, with @FrankLanfranchi, @_conor_mcgrory, @Yuelin_Shi, and @EngelTatiana)

Jason Locasale avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Jason Locasale@LocasaleLab·Oct 7

This is the type of article Science should be publishing and commenting on. It is an actually newsworthy piece of science. But it is highly technical and will not attract many readers. Even a Nobel Prize winner may have only a couple thousand followers on social media. Rather than going for politics and clickbait, Science should be writing articles that highlight scientific advances, including ones most people know little about. This might reduce readership and revenue by pandering less to a political base. But it is a step toward truth. AAAS and Science exist to promote science, even when it does not grab headlines or induce rage.

Molecules can exist in mirror images of themselves—left- and right-handed versions. Yet the stuff of life, from the amino acids in our proteins to the sugars in DNA, has evolved a preference for one-handedness, or chirality. Why this asymmetry arose has long been a mystery, because ordinary chemical reactions tend to produce equal amounts of the two mirror images. This year’s #NobelPrize in Chemistry honors Henri Kagan of the Université Paris-Sud and Kenso Soai of Tokyo University of Science for discovering how chemistry can break that symmetry—and for providing clues to how life’s one-handed chemistry might have emerged. Learn more: scim.ag/4rQ7WFJ

Post attachment
i/o research avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
i/o research@iointelresearch·Sep 2

[THREAD] 1/ Massive new study involving over 1 million individuals: "We find that the genetic architecture of personality is robustly generalizable, minimally confounded and widely relevant to human experience." 1,260 genetic variants are identified. nature.com/articles/s41586-0…

Steve Stewart-Williams avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Steve Stewart-Williams@SteveStuWill·Aug 29

"A recent US survey reports surprisingly high tolerance for political violence on both sides of the political spectrum - and an unexpected sex difference: Women are more likely than men to say murdering a politician is sometimes justified." stevestewartwilliams.com/p/m…

Post attachment
HealthRanger avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
HealthRanger@HealthRanger·Aug 29

This is their real goal. They can't let the Amish remain unvaccinated, or everyone will notice how much healthier they are.

States are demanding that the Amish get vaccinated in order to eliminate the control group. Otherwise the states look really bad.

Jason Locasale avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Jason Locasale@LocasaleLab·Aug 29

For the life sciences to be taken seriously, they must move beyond the ragebait associated with image processing and return to the material reality of scientific work. The important question is whether a biological result is real and thus reproducible and generalizable -- not whether a website or influencer can attract attention by amplifying allegations about figures. Yamanaka’s discovery of how to create stem cells from adult cells has been replicated and generalized thousands of times. No one seriously disputes that defined factors can generate induced pluripotent stem cells from somatic tissue. An enormous scientific and commercial field was built on that discovery. The tech industry is now pouring billions of dollars into cellular reprogramming because of its potential relationship to longevity. His remarkable achievement should not be diminished by outlets turning immaterial image allegations into click-driven controversy. The rage economy has little to say about the biological meaning of the work. Its focus on trivial and irrelevant details distracts from the consequential questions raised by the science itself. The real issue is what happens downstream when reprogrammed cells are introduced into living organisms. Could they become unstable, differentiate unpredictably, or produce cancer and other diseases later for example? If people are concerned about the risks of mRNA technology, in vivo cellular reprogramming operates on an entirely different level. The tolerance for safety risk would need to be extraordinarily low if it is to be taken seriously as a longevity intervention. These are the questions science should be confronting. Instead, people are lost in the fog created by attention-seeking gossip outlets searching for the next image scandal.

Japan institute defends Nobel Prize winner amid allegations of image duplication. retractionwatch.com/2026/08/…

Ruslan Rust avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Ruslan Rust@rust_ruslan·Jul 1

Peer review rarely overturns the main result. The primary claim was unchanged in 39.9% of papers, minorly revised in 50.0%, and substantially changed in only 10.2%. So ~90% survive largely intact.

Post attachment
David Krizaj avatar
David Krizaj@dkrizaj·Jun 17

"We found that the most superficial [corneal] nerve plexus and terminals are continuously remodeled, with individual axons displaying high dynamics.' clues for regeneration? jneurosci.org/content/46/24/…

Quillette avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Quillette@Quillette·Jun 11

"A landmark study drawing on ancient DNA from nearly 16,000 West Eurasians found that directional genetic selection is not only widespread but accelerating." Stephen Jay Gould famously argued there had been no biological change in humans for 40,000 years. David Reich's latest research is making that consensus increasingly hard to sustain, write @JonEntine & Patrick Whittle.

Post attachment
David Krizaj avatar
David Krizaj@dkrizaj·Jun 9

Eppur si muove... brain motion within the skull is driven by abdominal muscle contractions that activate a hydraulic-like vascular connection between the nervous system and the abdominal cavity... nature.com/articles/s41593-0…

Daniel Friedman avatar
⟳ David Krizaj retweeted
Daniel Friedman@DanFriedman81·May 14

The Iliad and the Odyssey are foundational literary works that are also about men doing manly things and feeling manly feelings — they’re about pride and duty, they’re about friendship and loyalty, they’re about fear of death and bravery in the face of it, they’re about striving and longing. These are stories that have taught men to be men for a thousand years, that celebrate the highest versions of masculinity, and that is why so many people who are hostile to these values and ideals try to mess with these works of literature, to claim them for other audiences, to “recontextualize” them, to “queer” them and to subvert them. Men barely read today. Boys are alienated and underserved by English instruction and are falling starkly behind in reading. The “literary man,” a common type in hipster Brooklyn as recently as the mid 2010s, is basically extinct. Men are now the most underserved, underrepresented audience in books and publishing, and anyone in publishing who claims to be interested in “equity” or serving neglected audiences should be focused on this disparity. English teachers and the publishing industry should be working to get men and boys reading again and to elevate works that speak to men and boys. And that means preserving and teaching Homer, in translations which preserve the majesty and the masculinity of the original works.

David Krizaj avatar
David Krizaj@dkrizaj·May 14

...its UT range is a tiny SE corner. So I asked Gary (grynaf@yahoo.com) who curates the site. His answer: 'this is a juvenile rattlesnake. In SLC it should be a Great Basin Rattlesnake. It's venomous, so I hope nobody tried to pick it up' 😬 Caveat emptor, friends.