
Stu, let’s at least pretend to be fair to the science. For 45 yrs the Dietary Guidelines have said to eat less protein foods and more refined carbohydrates. Those guidelines distorted the nutrient density of the US diet, and the health outcomes are obvious. The new DGA (based on those 30 highly controlled RCT studies), target a range for protein to replace refined carbohydrates. When nutrient rich protein foods are used to replace nutrient poor, refined carbohydrates health outcomes improve. The protein range is presented as a goal, not are requirement, and the intention is to shift the focus from the minimum RDA to a more moderate target within the Acceptable Macronutrient Distribution Range. Currently, nearly 20% of women over 60 y or 18-22 y are below the RDA and nearly 45% of adults are below recommended protein intakes. The narrative that everyone eats too much protein is false. The new DGA recommend prioritizing protein food choices. The DGA does not add protein supplements on top of unhealthy diets, it targets nutrient rich protein foods to replace ultra-processed foods. So, the true question isn’t solely an issue of defining a protein deficiency, it’s recognizing a carbohydrate gluttony and diets that are nutrient poor. Are people better off consuming nutrient-rich protein foods or cookies and donuts?
You can’t fix a protein deficiency that doesn’t exist. The US protein target (1.2 to 1.6 g/kg/day) rests on 30 trials of dieting adults with obesity, applied to everyone, with no link to exercise. Ten years on, nobody will be much healthier. Protein is great. It is not magic.














