←
Drew Bailey2,141 posts
Drew Bailey avatar

Drew Bailey

@drewhalbailey

education, developmental psychology, research methods at UC Irvine

◷ Joined December 2018▧ 49 Photos and videos
Tyler avatar
⟳ Drew Bailey retweeted
Tyler@tw_watts·Oct 21

You have probably heard someone in program evaluation say "this program CAN work," and then point to a subgroup effect. Maybe it's right... but we think a lot of this heterogeneity is idiosyncratic and impossible to replicate. Read more here: substack.com/home/post/p-221…

Tyler avatar
⟳ Drew Bailey retweeted
Tyler@tw_watts·Sep 30

The U.S. federal government spent nearly 2 decades funding "gold standard" RCTs for educational programs. What did we actually learn from all of that work? Our new blog post takes on this question and asks whether we can do better in the future: substack.com/home/post/p-218…

Juan Camilo Cristancho avatar
⟳ Drew Bailey retweeted
Juan Camilo Cristancho@JuanCamiloCri10·Sep 13

New paper out today in Educational Researcher, in collaboration with Carolina Maldonado-Carreño, @drewhalbailey, Greg Duncan, @e_escallon, and @ErvynNorza journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.… We examine what happens inside early childhood classrooms when a homicide occurs nearby

Jeremy Freese avatar
⟳ Drew Bailey retweeted
Jeremy Freese@jeremyfreese·Sep 4

Ariely and a lot of “replication crisis” social psych contributed to an erroneous view of the human world, which is that little things cause big things. Instead, big things are caused either by other big things or systematically correlated agglomerations of little things.

Ariely is a much bigger issue than Arday ever was. Arday was an aberration, but nobody with a fully functioning brain takes any of that stuff seriously anyway. He was evolving in fields that are themselves aberrations. The real issue behind Arday was the people who hired him and their political agenda, as well as the fact that nobody dares to speak up against an obvious farce. Arday himself wasn’t the biggest issue in his own story. Ariely, on the other hand, was supposed to be a serious scholar and a real “academic star.” I actually took one of his online courses and was quite impressed. A lot of smart people not only took him seriously but also devoted years of their lives to studying behavioral economics without knowing they were building on quicksand. That’s a lot of resources and years wasted.

Drew Bailey avatar
Drew Bailey@drewhalbailey·Aug 13

If the federal government really cares about what works, they ought to fund a good evaluation. They should also be open to experimentation with programs that mimic the conditions under which early programs showed the most beneficial effects to children and society. 4/6

Drew Bailey avatar
Drew Bailey@drewhalbailey·Aug 13

I worry that this policy is likely to increase the risk of negative effects of a government funded program on child outcomes. This is a risk worth taking seriously, and an outcome that would conflict with conservative American values, as I understand them. 3/6

Drew Bailey avatar
Drew Bailey@drewhalbailey·Aug 13

But it's true that effects seem to have gotten smaller, I think largely because counterfactual conditions have improved for US kids. This is good for kids, but raises challenges for the design of early education programs. 2/6

Drew Bailey avatar
Drew Bailey@drewhalbailey·Aug 13

I co-authored some papers linked in this piece. My work doesn't find that "Head Start has Never Worked". Indeed, we've written about how the effects of high-quality early education programs are sometimes positive, including in the long-term, on real life outcomes. 1/6

The New York Times claims that Head Start “works,” ignoring research showing that any improvement in cognitive skills among its intended beneficiaries fades out by third grade. Sadly, the Trump administration has backed off plans to pull the plug on this quintessential Great Society program, which has sucked up $240 billion in taxpayer funding since its inception in 1966. But if not now, when?  My latest in City Journal: city-journal.org/article/hea…

Paul Novosad avatar
⟳ Drew Bailey retweeted
Paul Novosad@paulnovosad·May 30

Authors can't be trusted to run their own robustness checks. In 17 AER papers, only 12/211 robustness checks "fail" with p > 0.05 (white). In robustness checks chosen by 3rd parties, almost *half* of them fail (blue). 1/

Post attachment
Drew Bailey avatar
Drew Bailey@drewhalbailey·Mar 11

I think this paper is really important. Favoring unbiased estimators can actually increase bias when coupled with selective reporting, and we have lots of reasons to think that economists are doing plenty of this.

Excited to share a new paper with @jfischman, just accepted at JEL. We argue that empirical research tends to be biased and overconfident due to a weakness in the dominant econometric framework: insufficient attention paid to humans “in the loop” with the research process. 1/

Post attachment