
Want to help teachers improve? Get specific: principalcenter.com/specific

Author of 3 books on instructional leadership Founder, BinderK12.com Books & PD: PrincipalCenter.com

Want to help teachers improve? Get specific: principalcenter.com/specific

Students are not inanimate objects. Their effort matters for learning. So we can’t say “If the student hasn’t learned it, the teacher hasn’t taught it.”

Trying to make educators totally responsible for student learning squeezes out the most important party: the student. There’s no learning without student effort.

We should take responsibility for what we control, like what and how we teach. When we try to take responsibility for things we don’t control, like student attendance, behavior, and effort—and ultimately learning—we see maladaptive efforts and weird unintended consequences.
Maybe schools SHOULD take responsibility for delivering a curriculum—which they can actually ensure—rather than trying to take responsibility for student learning, as if students are inanimate objects without any agency or free will. 🧵

So we’re back to judging teaching on its own merits, not based on student outcomes. Thoughts?

When a school is doing everything right…how can you tell? They won’t get perfect results, because every school has a mix of students. How can you judge the quality of teaching? You have to examine the teaching.

This means it’s very hard to tell whether good or bad results are the result of good or bad teaching vs student selection—and of course, it’s always a combination. And here’s the twist…

We don’t like to talk about this, but it’s extremely easy to select for student characteristics. Sort by zip code, or make parents fill out a form to enroll, and you’ll skew your population far more than seems intuitively possible.

Here’s the core issue: how can you tell, from outcomes alone, whether a student was taught well or not? Don’t outcomes also depend on the student?

The only problem is that it seems not to work very well—neither for identifying the schools doing a subpar job, nor for getting them to do a better job.

If schools are doing a subpar job, holding them accountable for learning will keep them from getting away with it. They’ll have no choice but to deliver the goods. Seems fairly logical.

I’m sure there’s history I’m unaware of behind this idea that schools should take responsibility for student learning, not just teaching. But I think the basic rationale goes like this…

Maybe schools SHOULD take responsibility for delivering a curriculum—which they can actually ensure—rather than trying to take responsibility for student learning, as if students are inanimate objects without any agency or free will. 🧵
Absolutely. Whether your kid is gifted or falling behind, parents are left fighting for appropriate support. Education seems more focused on delivering a curriculum than ensuring children actually learn. We've lost the rigour & the independent data parents need to demand better.

Two cautions about using AI to help write your résumé or cover letter, so it doesn’t sound generic

Learning apps will never replace great human teachers. Retrieval quizzing? sure. But the classroom dynamic of teacher and students can never be replicated by a machine. The interactions, the moments, the collective, with the teacher orchestrating it all. You will not beat this no matter how many apps you make and however good they are.

It’s impossible to overstate what a textbook example of selling out this is. The evidence hasn’t changed. Only one thing changed. Before & after the $$$: