←
the EMCrit Crew5,836 posts
the EMCrit Crew avatar

the EMCrit Crew

@emcrit

We are EMCrit. We explore an obsession with Critical Care and Resuscitation. Editor in Chief: Scott Weingart

◷ Joined April 2009▧ 957 Photos and videos
the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Nov 14

EMCrit 438 - HyperCRITical 002 -Vasopressin as a 2nd pressor by rote? -Phenobarb vs. diazepam -HAVL as First Choicehyperangulated -big-dose potassium... @PulmCrit and I agree on some and argue about the rest [#FOAMed for Now] emcrit.org/438

Post attachment
the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Oct 29

EMCrit 437 - Massive Lithium Overdose with @NephroTox (tox + nephro in one human): -Gastric Decon -Who to dialyze -Why nephrologists are vampires and so much more! [#FOAMed for now} emcrit.org/437

Post attachment
the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Oct 18

EMCrit 436 - When you RSI Shocked Patients, they Tend to Die 8 years later, we are bringing HNI out of the expert-only realm so anyone can intubate shocky patients safely without causing post-intubation arrest & hopefully not causing any BP/CO drop at all... [#FOAMed for Now] emcrit.org/436

Post attachment
the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Oct 3

EMCrit 435 – Procedural Sedation Part VI: I break down the new ACEP unscheduled procedural sedation guidelines, call out the absurd pretense surrounding 'deep sedation', and lay out where emergency sedation needs to go in 2026. emcrit.org/435

Post attachment
the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

In conclusion, thank you for the RCT. Please be nicer if you can. I'm still not sure whether these devices are a free ride or not. I welcome your comments, and I will put on my asbestos suit. 8 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

Now, seemingly, what you objected to in the show notes of my post: I'm pretty sure you didn't listen to the actual podcast, because I bent over backwards to say that "I'd love to see more literature on these triple-lumen dialysis catheters. I can make no firm conclusions about infection rate or flow rates," but in the show notes, I think the words "potentially may increase infections" may have sent you to actually reply to my post. My very lukewarm contention was predicated on the Truveta data (DOI: 10.1177/11297298251352470), which did indeed show an increased infection rate with the triple-lumen catheters. Now, this study is retrospective. It is a database survey. It is by no means strong evidence, and, like I said, I did not have this RCT to evaluate. That being said, the increased relative risk of infection in that trial, with the incredibly confounded results of the RCT you posted would still leave me standing by: potentially, there is an increased infection rate. I don't think that is a myth. I don't think it's been debunked. I certainly think your RCT is helpful in making us feel a little bit better, but this is, in my mind, still an unanswered question as to whether these triple-lumen catheters are as safe as a dual-lumen catheter that you don't touch. We also anecdotally have a bunch of experience that the flow rates on these devices are not as good, though the data I have seen has not borne this out. 7 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

The strangeness was even quoted in the pictures you put in your post. They demanded at least 30% of the TLCs be used between procedures. I don't want to see 30%. I want to see 100% of the TLCs used between procedures. Obviously, that's the entire point of the evaluation: to see what happens when you keep messing with dialysis lines. That's the study we're expecting to see, and that's not what we see at all here. What this study nicely shows us is that the mere presence of an additional lumen does not, in and of itself, cause an increased infection rate compared to a DLC. I would have told you that just going in, before the RCT, the presence of a blocked or unused lumen does not cause increased infection. Now, accessing that lumen mutliple times, to put things in or take things out might, and this study does not evaluate that because they used the dual lumen between procedures, inexplicably, almost as often as the TLCs. They didn't use the triple lumen as much as we actually would in a real-life ICU setting when this is the patient's only central line. I'm not seeing the real utility of this trial to answer the questions I actually want to ask. A bunch of the pts in the TLC arm also had additional central access. 6 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

That's not even the strangest part... The DLCs were used between RRT a mean of 3 times over the duration of the lines. What the heck were they doing on the dual-lumen catheters other than RRT? They are used almost the exact same number of times as the TLCs between RRT sessions. 5 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

We have data on the 393 of the patients who had their catheters cultured on removal. In those patients, the TLCs (triple lumen caths) were used a mean of 4.3 times over the entire duration of the catheter. Some of those TLCs were not used at all outside of RRT. This is not quite what we think of when we see a trial of TLC vs. DLC dialysis caths. Our expectation is that use would reflect the real world: These lines are being accessed all the time if you're putting in the TLC specifically to act as a substitute for a secondarily placed central line. 4 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

However, some peculiarities do emerge upon further examination: The TLCs were in median of 5 days. Not much time for infection, but still not a big issue. but then something weird does emerge when we look at interprocedural use (i.e. using the line for anything except during RRT, like blood draws, med administration, etc.) 3 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 22

So this was a manufacturer-sponsored pre-clearance RCT. Doesn't discount it just based on that, but it does make one look slightly askance at the results. But that wouldn't be a problem in and of itself.... 2 of 8

the EMCrit Crew avatar
the EMCrit Crew@emcrit·Sep 21

EMCrit 434: Temporary Hemodialysis Catheters Delays Are to the Patient's Detriment! We cover catheter sizing, site selection, the two jumps of dilation microskills, pre-dilation vascular confirmation, and so much more! emcrit.org/434

Post attachment