←
Eric Biber897 posts
Eric Biber avatar

Eric Biber

@eric_biber

Law professor UC Berkeley. Posts reflect my own personal views, not those of UC Berkeley.

◷ Joined June 2017▧ 9 Photos and videos
Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

But again, will courts take this path? I would prefer not to test that with a Trump Admin that is committed to large-scale land disposal. 11/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

The APA failure to inform plus the FLPMA requirement for information for the decision gives you a legal violation besides NEPA and the land sale easily meets irreparable harm. 10/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

I do think that APA requirements for agencies to act in an informed manner help with enforcement of statutes like FLPMA. For instance, the tradeoff for land sales in FLPMA would be well informed by a NEPA analysis, and failure to do it could be a basis for court p.i. 9/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

More broadly, this is an example of a broader issue with BAAJA. Without NEPA, we will be depending a lot on other statutes to constrain the executive. I'm not sure statutes like FLPMA are up to that. 8/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

It might be worth carving out an exception for land-use sales from BAAJA, given the irreversible nature of those decisions, and the fact that remand is a completely ineffective remedy for violations here. 7/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

So the question is whether FLPMA's broad provisions, plus land-use plans (which can be amended though there is a public process period) can provide enough constraint on an Admin that is pushing all the boundaries it can. 6/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

In practice, to my knowledge NEPA litigation has been a primary tool to fight proposed land sales. But BAAJA requires only remand if there is only a NEPA violation, allowing the project to proceed. If the project is a land sale, that is that, there's no way to undo it. 5/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

There aren't any limits on how much land can be sold. The main other constraint is that land sales have to be consistent with land-use plans and that is probably the major obstacle here, since most current BLM plans do not call for sale of much land. 4/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

And those public objectives would "outweigh other public objectives and values". That's a very broad standard, giving the agency lots of discretion. 3/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

That's because the primary authority for federal sale of public lands is FLPMA, whose primary restriction on sale is a very general requirement that sale will serve "public objectives" that can't be achieved on non-federal lands. 2/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 17

The recent proposal from the Trump Admin to sell federal public lands highlights a potential risk of BAAJA. It might facilitate sale of federal public lands. 1/x

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 15

Any of these approaches might help facilitate passage of the bill overall, without unduly compromising the policy goals of the drafters. More details at this blog post. legal-planet.org/2026/11/15/… 9/9

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 15

A narrower approach is to only allow vacatur after a remand order if there is irreparable harm as well as a continued NEPA violation. Or only if there is bad faith agency noncompliance. 8/9

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 15

There are a range of approaches. Allowing general vacatur for NEPA violations after a remand might be too broad, since the uncertainty of whether vacatur might occur after a remand might deter agencies from starting projects in the initial 180 days. 7/9

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 15

Perhaps judicial power to enforce remand orders with contempt and sanctions remains under the bill (that is not explicit, but likely). But I’m also skeptical those tools are enough to constrain this Admin. 6/9

Eric Biber avatar
Eric Biber@eric_biber·Nov 15

The agency can keep refusing to do NEPA, with a court only able to order remand, while the agency finishes the project with no NEPA at all. That seems unacceptable. But this Admin might well try that approach. 5/9