
A short thread on why I generally turn off replies (though I'd rather not, but this is what Twitter/X is, and I can't change it). (1/4)

Trans girl, all grown up now. I talk primarily about issues affecting trans youth, both from personal experience and in general.

A short thread on why I generally turn off replies (though I'd rather not, but this is what Twitter/X is, and I can't change it). (1/4)

The new Austrian/German/Swiss guidelines for trans health care for minors have been published. Overall, they look pretty good, though I think there are a few places where they could be improved. That said, they form a strong counterpoint to Cass etc. register.awmf.org/de/leitlin…

Regardless, even if the claims in the study were fully accurate, then it would (1) be likely incompatible with the claims that 100% kids on puberty blockers go on to CSH and (2) would strengthen the case for puberty blockers for diagnostic purposes. (25/25)

If authors pretty much openly out themselves as ideologues, concerns about bias are justified, especially when the data being offered is pretty sparse. (24/25)

For example, that critique literally argues that the terms "c*s" and "c*sgender" are derogatory (aside from making a mess of the etymology). It is hard to argue that such a claim is not ideologically motivated. (23/25)

Another concern is the identity of the authors. Two of them were co-authors of a critique of the upcoming German guidelines. That would not normally be noteworthy, except for the content of that critique. zi-mannheim.de/fileadmin/use… (22/25)

There are other questions surrounding coding, tracking patient identity (e.g. because of insurance numbers possibly changing as the result of a legal gender change), patients switching to private care, and others that are not adequately answered by the paper. (21/25)

This makes it rather unclear to what extent the data captures medical transitions accurately. (20/25)

Another noticeable observation is that a significant percentage of patients had billing events for fewer than four quarters out of the year. But the standard German protocol for minors transitioning requires at least quarterly therapy sessions. (19/25)

Nor does trans healthcare necessarily have an underlying F64 diagnostic code. For example, Z79.890 is another code that may be used in the case of post-op trans people. icdlist.com/icd-10/Z79.890 (18/25)

Or, for that matter, conversion therapists steering their patients away from treatment. While conversion therapy is technically illegal in Germany, there are plenty of loopholes ("exploratory therapy") that work around that. (17/25)

For starters, the study does not and cannot distinguish between patients voluntarily stopping or choosing not to undergo treatment and their parents making them stop. (16/25)

Next, the German healthcare bureaucracy distinguishes between a diagnosis ("Diagnose") and a treatment recommendation ("Indikation"). An ICD 10 code in the billing system only says something about the diagnosis proper, not any treatments/treatment recommendations. (15/25)

Patients are free to change their primary care provider or specialists every quarter with no questions asked. Billing thus is organized on a quarterly basis. (14/25)

For background, under Germany's public healthcare system, doctors need to report the underlying diagnosis (as an ICD 10 code) for any billing event to the patient's health insurance. (13/25)

However, the "diagnostic desistance" rate raises further questions about how accurate a proxy that is for desistance/detransition, because the numbers do not match up with other studies and it is reasonable to suspect that billing artifacts may be the cause. (12/25)