
The government proposal to ban ‘rape myths’ is a breach of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), right to a fair trial. This is incorporated into English law by the HRA 1998. This is a little complex but important please stay with me. Under the Sexual Offences Act 2003 it is a defence for a defendant to say that he reasonably believed the complainant was consenting to sex. Or to put it in another way the Crown must prove BRD (make the jury sure) that not only did the defendant commit the actus rea of the offence, which is sex without the comp consent, but also that he knew she was not consenting. This is the mens rea of the offence. So a defendant can say, even if the comp did not consent I believed she was consenting AND that belief was reasonable in the circumstances. (Therefore def cannot claim a Casanova defence i.e. no woman can resist me etc) If the jury are not sure on this point, the defendant is entitled to an acquittal. I don’t think this defence is claimed that often, or that it is a particularly attractive one but it IS a defence. What the complainant does at the time of the act IS relevant to the defendant’s BELIEF as to whether she consented or not, and whether it was a reasonable belief. The government is saying – it is a myth that a complainant will resist physically or verbally, that some women stay silent or freeze etc. This can be true in certain circumstances. This goes to question of whether she consented. But it also goes to whether the defendant knew she was not consenting. However, if a defendant is saying, I believed she was consenting because she did not say no, or physically resist in any way, and everything up to that point gave me a reasonable belief she was consenting then this is absolutely relevant to the defence and MUST be put to complainant so she can reply. Now, perhaps a legislative exception will say, rape myths are banned unless it compromises a fair trial, and the judge rules this evidence must be left to the jury for a fair trial to be achieved. It is still legislative overreach. Happy to be corrected by defence counsel.






















