


European research project examining surveillance, intelligence and oversight | Teams from @KingsCollegeLon @SciencesPo @WZB_Berlin @SNV_Berlin @UJML


With a little of delay, I'm delighted to announce the publication of the 2nd volume in our New Intelligence Studies series: Intelligence Oversight in times of Transnational Impunity, co-edited by @didierbigo @EmmaMcCluskey15 & @FelixTreguer and in OA 👇 urlz.fr/oV03

10/10: By attending to practices, the article brings to the fore the limits of liberal democracy and the struggles for other forms of democracy.

9/10: This article challenges the normative assumptions centring on liberal, functionalist, and technocratic views at the expense of more radical and agonistic understandings of democracy.

8/10: Academic discussions of intelligence oversight have mainly taken place within the field of intelligence studies, a field historically derived from a strong Anglo-American state-policy lineage and grounded within functionalist, state-centric epistemologies.

7/10: We propose to approach the question of what constitutes democratic oversight through the analysis of struggles around three elements of intelligence oversight: inclusion, secrecy, and contestation.

6/10: The article challenges dominant views on what constitutes legitimate and effective intelligence oversight, arguing that these democratic practices reconfiguring oversight remain contested or contained by dominant views.

5/10: We analyse three moments of struggle around what counts as intelligence oversight across Germany, the UK, and the US, elucidating their democratic stakes.

4/10: The article uses a practice-based approach to argue that oversight takes much more agonistic, contentious, transnational, and public forms.

3/10: The article argues that oversight is mostly understood as an expert, institutional, and partially exclusive arrangement that is supposed to strike a balance between individual freedom and collective security.

2/10: According to the article, the literature on intelligence oversight has tended to implicitly or explicitly follow liberal and technocratic ideas of democracy.

1/10: What does 'democratic' mean in democratic intelligence oversight? A new article tackles this question and situates it within broader debates about democracy.

🔴 Publication alert! Our colleagues @RonjaKniep, Lina Ewert, @berna_leon, @FelixTreguer, @EmmaMcCluskey15 & @claudia_aradau published this research paper in Review of International Studies. A short thread on the main takeaways 🧵: cambridge.org/core/journals/…

He echoes as well the work of our colleague @FelixTreguer:

Our colleague @berna_leon explains in @_infoLibre some of the findings of our three-year-long project on intelligence oversight:
En la segunda parte de esta serie especial sobre inteligencia para @_infoLibre hablo sobre la falta de controles democráticos que existe en España. ¿Qué cabe proponer para vigilar a los vigilantes? infolibre.es/opinion/columna…

Last but not least, a thank you to all survey participants! @_frichter and @twetzling will present some results at the conference today: eventbrite.co.uk/e/intellige…