←
Hannah Barnes7,826 posts
Hannah Barnes avatar✓

Hannah Barnes ✓

@hannahsbee

Award-winning journalist, broadcaster & best-selling author of “Time to Think” bit.ly/TimetoThinkBook. Formerly investigations for New Statesman and BBC

◷ Joined February 2009▧ 286 Photos and videos
Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 17

Cass quoted in Guardian on the draft conversion practices Bill (from BBC interview?): “I can’t support this bill as it has too many problems, including the risk to parents,” she said. “It would have to be radically changed to be workable and I am not sure that is possible.” theguardian.com/politics/202…

Katie avatar
⟳ Hannah Barnes retweeted
Katie@Katieabcgirl·Nov 17

UHSussex entered MSSP in Jan 2022, the month my daughter died preventably & the year the Trust had a spike in perinatal deaths - & concluded in their own investigations that 35% of those may have been preventable (as per New Statesman investigation). Ineffective to say the least.

Emily Townsend avatar
⟳ Hannah Barnes retweeted
Emily Townsend@emilyltownsend·Nov 17

🔴 Revealed: Hospitals stuck for years in ‘ineffective’ NHSE maternity scheme Six trusts have spent > 4 years in NHS England’s maternity improvement programme, which experts & families now say is “not fit for purpose” @sathNHS on list since Dec 18 hsj.co.uk/patient-safety/rev…

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Write-up in the Times: “Hilary Cass withdraws backing for Labour’s conversion therapy ban” The paediatrician has warned that the legislation could expose doctors to vexatious complaints for following a cautious approach to gender dysphoria thetimes.com/uk/politics/art…

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

My apologies for some pretty bad typos. I’m not the greatest typist and was trying to post quickly while still listening to the evidence session

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Hard to see how government’s draft conversion practices bill survives without some serious amendment, following Baroness Hilary Cass’s criticism. She has said she cannot support it currently.

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Cass explains that the Bill treats something treating something - gender identity - as a stable belief, when it is actually something that, for many, is changeable. She points out that it is also something intrinsically very sidfficult and distsressing to discuss for young people and parents alike. It is not the same as sexual orientation.

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

In case there is any doubt, Labour MP Naz Shah asks, "do you support this Bill as drafted?" Cass says, "No"

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Asked whether the Bill could have a "chilling effect on whistleblowing" which was relied upon in the case of the Tavistock Gender identity Development Service (GIDS), Cass replies, "Yes".

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Next, Cass talks about how difficult the situation is now - before any legislation - for clinicians practising in an exploratory way. She mentions Dr Anna Hutchinson, who gave evidence to the committee last week. She has had to have security with her before when she’s given talks - "and that’s not normal in any area of medicine.”

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Cass gives another example she heard during her review of a mother who had been in an abusive relationship with husband. Daughter was going through anorexia and also had some medically unexplained symptoms. The father left the family home and the daughter began identifying as trans male. Mother tried to be supportive, but not using preferred pronouns. Father, who was very angry, reported her to social services for not supporting the gender transition. At time she spoke to Cass, it was 11 months into investigation by social services. "I think that was father being vexatious." But with the Bill he could just as easily report her to the police “people who are angry have the potential to do the wrong thing”. The qiestion is how we guard against that.

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Olivia Bailey, who originally introduced the Bill, asks whether clarity on certain points would help and allow Cass to continue to support a ban. Cass responds that "the devil is int he detail" and that she would need to see the text.

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

"I am still concerned because unfortunately, the polarisation is worse now than when we came out with report." Cass says it is “very clear that there are malign actors who feel that my report and the exploratory approach that I describe is conversion therapy – that’s what they label it as and I think there is definitely a wish to push back on the changes that have come about because of my review and this is potentially one way to undermine it.”

Hannah Barnes avatar
Hannah Barnes@hannahsbee·Nov 16

Baroness Browning asks Cass about what she said in her review about the role of psychological therapies unhelpfully being overshadowed by debate about conversion therapy. Having seen the language in the Bill, is she still concerned? Yes is the reply...