←
Jake Koch-Gallup1,615 posts
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar✓

Jake Koch-Gallup ✓

@immutablejacob

fundamental investor | prev. research @blockworks + messari

◷ Joined December 2021▧ 436 Photos and videos
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 5

this bull market feels like one where value investors actually get rewarded. i'm the type of investor who finds a project i like and holds it for years. in past cycles, fundamentals and revenue were a meme. that's changed with regulation passing and more projects producing real, sustainable revenue. holding high-quality projects should finally pay off. so i built a fundamental value investing dashboard. it ranks tokens mainly on tokenholder value accrual, then on product traction, team and governance, valuation, and dilution/supply. each token gets bear/base/bull fair values, comps, a catalyst and unlock tracker, and technical analysis. it all rolls up into a quality vs value matrix. of the 23 tokens in the first run, only $BTC and $HYPE make the buy tier on a 6-month time horizon. it was built 100% on the @blockworks MCP: price, supply, unlocks, revenue, research, etc. let me know if you'd want a live, interactive version, and which tokens i should add.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Nov 6

this is my last week at @Blockworks. after 2 years at Messari and another 6 months at Blockworks following the acquisition, i'm really grateful for the people i've worked with, everything i've learned, and the research i've published. it's sad to see one of the leading crypto research firms shift its focus away from research. i understand the decision to prioritize product, but i think independent research matters more than ever, especially as AI makes original human thinking and analysis increasingly valuable. for now, i'm taking a little time to reset and finish up my personal crypto asset valuation framework, dashboard, and whitepaper, which should be launching in the next week or so. after that, i'll be looking for new opportunities in crypto research, investing, and beyond. excited for what's next.

Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Nov 2

great report on $PEARL from @minnus & @0xMetaLight. they're net bullish, but the report backs up a lot of my bear case. some key points: 1) the "useful work" isn't happening yet. fewer than 1% of blocks match a real AI model, and gaming cards run ~82% of hashrate. 2) AI servers have no reason to mine (at today's price). an AI server gives up $1.33-$3.15 of paid AI work for each coin it mines, while a gaming card pays $0.14-$0.23 in power. 3) the only real-world example didn't last. together AI's pearl-powered endpoint launched in may at a 25%+ discount, and was deprecated a couple months later. 4) the useful mining fix has no timeline. the FP8 upgrade would make mining on an AI server about as cheap as mining on a gaming card, but there's no published date, and the draft only works on nvidia's newest chips. so older gaming cards and every AMD card could get shut out, and gaming cards run most of the network today. 5) miners sell fast. about half of pool payouts go straight to one custodian's deposit addresses, and only ~10% is still sitting in miners' wallets a week later. 6) miners who already own their gaming GPUs only pay for power, so they'd stay profitable even if $PEARL fell ~80%. which means their costs give the price little support. 7) the network is concentrated. ~90% of blocks go through pools, kryptex alone mines ~50%, and the top 1% of addresses hold ~71% of supply. 8) transparency is still missing. ~125M $PEARL was issued in launch week, 98% of it has never moved, and the lab still hasn't disclosed its holdings. the bull case depends on FP8 shipping and AI providers actually mining. until then, holders will have to absorb ~84% supply growth, about $540M of new $PEARL, over the next year.

Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 26

got some good pushback on my $PEARL fundraise post. here's my response to the main points, and how i think the team could fix them. 1) "this fundraise has been known for months." no it hasn't. it's been a rumor, and an unverified one. one of israel's largest business papers, @TheMarker, published the exact details yesterday ($55M in equity and a $75M GPU fund). that's the first time we’ve gotten actual numbers on it, and the team still hasn't confirmed it. this goes back to transparency. why isn't the team announcing or confirming this? why do holders have to find out through rumors and business papers instead of directly from the team? 2) "pearl's whitepaper clearly states that difficulty was lowered for the first 10% of supply to fund operations." the issue is again transparency. that's 210M $PEARL, ~59% of today's circulating supply, or ~$380M at today's price. we don't know how much of that the team mined, how much they still hold, or how much they've sold. one reply says the team mined less than 5% of the network. maybe, but the team hasn't published anything that lets holders check that. 3) "they raised capital to build a GPU farm to add hashrate to their own network!" yes, more hashrate is better. i agree. but if that fund mines $PEARL (which it almost certainly will), it centralizes the network around the team even more than it already is. the team ships the code and the upgrades. $75M buys roughly 2,500-3,000 H100s, which could make the lab one of the largest miners on pearl. as someone put it, "whoever controls the majority of the network's hashrate ultimately decides which chain gets secured..." so we're comfortable with the dev controlling a growing chunk of the hashrate, without disclosing how much? that takes away a lot of the credible neutrality and decentralization that make blockchains, and especially SoV assets, valuable. 4) "trying to accrue value to the token would invite additional valuation frameworks, which can only result in a lower valuation ceiling." i disagree. $PEARL is a lot less credibly neutral than other PoW assets like bitcoin, zcash, or even monero. it's also missing what monetary assets need: > low inflation (supply grows ~85% this year) > deep liquidity (~$8M of daily volume) > transparency from the team (undisclosed holdings + fundraise) > years of evidence that it works (it's 6 months old) so right now, the SoV case is weak, and a second source of value would help, not hurt. look at ethereum. it's valued as an infrastructure token (it returns value to holders thru staking and burns) and as a monetary asset (it's the main collateral across DeFi, it's the gas currency for ethereum and most of its L2s, and ~$18B of it sits in spot ETFs). a claim on value accrual gives a token fundamental support. monetary premium is the most fragile part of a token's price. when zcash's orchard bug was disclosed in may, $ZEC fell ~50% in two days even though nothing about its fundamentals changed. 5) “there is no equity/token split. pearl research labs is an equity business AI lab, completely separate from the token." this isn't accurate. they are not completely separate. the lab ships the code, the early low-difficulty window was set up to fund its operations, and its GPU fund will likely mine $PEARL. and the part that is separate is the part that makes money. that's what an equity/token split is. here is the test i use: > does the lab make money without the token? yes, it sells inference in USD. > does the token share in that revenue? no. > are any buybacks programmatic? no. > could the lab keep growing while $PEARL falls? yes. so the business and the token have to be valued separately. if $PEARL went to zero tomorrow, the lab would lose its mining subsidy, but it could keep selling inference on its own GPUs. the counter is that the team holds $PEARL, so their incentives are aligned with holders. but that only goes so far. the team also owns equity in the lab, and so do VCs who may not hold any $PEARL. when the token and the business want different things, like whether inference gets sold for USD or $PEARL, the lab will answer to its equity holders. and we still don't know how much $PEARL the team holds, whether any of it is locked, or how much they've sold. there are ways to fix this though: 1) TRANSPARENCY. disclose how much $PEARL the team and investors mined and hold, how much they've sold, who invested, and what share of the hashrate the lab controls. for a SoV asset, this is the most important thing a team can provide. it's why @blockworks has a token transparency framework. 2) FIX TOKENOMICS. accept $PEARL for inference, and burn the $PEARL that comes in instead of selling it. that adds demand for the token and helps offset miner selling. (i know. i know. "this is a SoV token, it doesn't need utility bro!!" but as i outlined above, it can/should have more than one source of value). 3) USE THE REVENUE FOR THE TOKEN, NOT THE TEAM'S AND VCs' POCKETS. most or all of the lab's inference profit should go to buying back and burning $PEARL. make it a fixed policy with burns sent to a published onchain address, not a verbal promise or something left to discretion. 4) CAP THE LAB'S HASHRATE. commit to keeping the lab's own mining under a set share of the network, and report it publicly. 5) TIME. supply growth drops to ~33% next year, ~18% the year after, and ~12% after that. by then the team could prove it's a credibly neutral dev, and $PEARL could have a real case as a SoV. bitcoin is 17 years old. zcash is 10. $PEARL is 6 months. if the team addresses the first four, i'll revisit my bearish view.

Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 25

not officially confirmed, but @TheMarker, israel's main business paper, is reporting that @prlnet's lab raised $130M from lightspeed, ribbit capital, and square peg. $55M in equity and $75M for a fund to build out GPU infrastructure. ribbit and lightspeed are also named as pearl backers on its profile in greenfield partners' disruptors 60 list. if this is real, the $PEARL bear case gets a lot worse. here's why: 1) $PEARL traded on a "no VCs, fair launch" story. pearl's code doesn't allocate tokens to founders or investors, and that part is probably still true. but the lab behind pearl is reportedly VC-backed, and nobody corrected the narrative while it pumped. 2) the value goes to the equity, not the token. the lab sells inference and gets paid in USD, and the VCs own the lab. $PEARL holders don't get any of that revenue, just diluted by new supply. so the investors can do well even if $PEARL goes to zero. 3) it goes against the "sovereignless bitcoin" pitch. part of bitcoin's monetary premium is that no company controls it. pearl's upgrades are drafted by a VC-backed lab, including the FP8 fork that would tie mining more closely to inference, the same business the lab sells. 4) the $75M GPU fund. we don't know if those GPUs mine $PEARL. if they do, the company is collecting a share of ~85% supply growth this year, on top of whatever insiders mined early. remember that about 1/3 of today's supply was mined in the first 6 days. 5) zcash had investors too (20% of its early block rewards went to founders and investors) but that was public from day 1. everyone knew who got paid and how much. pearl hasn't disclosed any of that. holders deserve to know: > who invested > whether any investors or insiders hold $PEARL > whether the GPU fund mines $PEARL a fair launch shouldn't need a newspaper to tell you who's behind it. i was a $PEARL bear on friday. i'm a bigger one now.

Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 24

early $ZEC shows what high inflation does to holders, even when the network is growing. in its first four months, zcash's market cap grew ~8x, from ~$3M to ~$22M. over the same stretch, price fell 91%, from $328 to $30, because supply grew ~84x. most of that came from zcash launching with a tiny supply, so $PEARL isn't there yet. Pearl's supply grows ~85% over the next year, not 84x. but new supply still has to find buyers before price can go up. i'm sure early ZEC holders had the same "but bitcoin had high inflation" arguments too.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 23

$PEARL miners add ~$2.2M of new supply every day. average daily volume over the last 10 days is ~$8.5M, so newly mined coins are worth roughly 25-30% of daily trading. and most mining today runs on rented GPUs from clouds, so those miners have bills to pay. over the next year, that's ~$654M of issuance against a ~$768M market cap. the market has to find almost a full market cap of new buying just to hold the price.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 23

the most common pushback on the $PEARL bear case is "bitcoin inflated like this too. would you not have bought it in 2011?" bitcoin's supply did grow 85%+ a year until aug 2011. but for 40 of those 58 weeks, it was worth under $10M. $PEARL is inflating at that same ~85% rate at a ~$768M market cap and a ~$4.6B FDV, 6 months in. the early bitcoin trade worked because nobody knew how to price it. markets price new crypto much faster now, so that mispricing is already gone.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 22

zcash:native is up ~5x in a year. $BTC is down 22%. $100 in zcash on oct. 21, 2025 is worth ~$500 today. the same $100 in bitcoin is worth ~$78. monero is also up 104% over the same window, but zcash still beat it by nearly 4x. it's now a top-10 asset at ~$21B. the next catalyst is NU7, zcash's next network upgrade. it cuts block times from 75 seconds to 25 seconds, with mainnet planned for nov. 5 if devs sign off. $ZEC is still ~20% below its september high, so it hasn’t been up only. but it’s clear people want onchain privacy.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 19

tokenized stocks just hit a record $3.6B. that's 6.6x since the start of the year, when supply was $542M. wallets holding them went from 160k in january to 5.1M today. the growth isn't just riding the stock market either. the nasdaq fell 4.5% last week and tokenized stock supply grew 3%. the top three chains are BNB chain ($1.46B), ethereum ($810M), and solana ($624M). demand is already here, and the biggest U.S. venues haven't even launched yet.

Post attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 17

appreciate the detailed corrections from @UmbraPrivacy co-founder @Abbasshaikh. i just updated solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta on the scoreboard. new 6-month horizon score is 2.7 (up from 2.3, but still underperform). the reasons behind the updated score: > NAV: $2.32M of DAO-owned cash, including the buyback vault and the DAO's AMM liquidity > NAV per token: excluding the 13.5M locked team tokens (they get nothing in a liquidation until they unlock), solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta trades at ~2.1x NAV > token sales: one 697k OTC sale at ~$0.45 in may, then a 327k buyback at ~$0.20 in sept > DAAY (dilution-adjusted accrual yield): -12.1% -> -1.5% the DAO has actually been a net buyer of its own token over the past year, which is a good sign for how the treasury is run. v1 has been charging fees for ~5 months and v2 is open to everyone. usage is still small tho. v1 did $4.87M of shielded volume from 2,239 depositors, and v2 has $262K of TVL so far. fees aren't public yet. the team is publishing them with @01Resolved soon, and i'll rerun the score when they're out.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 16

i am bullish privacy and of course ethereum:0xe76c6c83af64e4c60245d8c7de953df673a7a33d, so i wanted to see how privacy competitors like ethereum:0xa12cc123ba206d4031d1c7f6223d1c2ec249f4f3 and solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta stack up on my fundamental crypto asset scoreboard. --- let's start with @zama: short answer is (unfortunately), like many crypto projects, it is great tech with a weak token. zama is one of the leading FHE stacks with: > $647.9M of all-time shielded volume > $127.5M of shielded TVL > $104M earning yield in confidential morpho vaults but almost none of that reaches the token yet. every protocol fee is paid in ZAMA and burned. the burn is live onchain with 91,064 ZAMA burned on july 17 and another 73,300 waiting for the next batch. that works out to ~$22.5k a year of burns against an $865M FDV, or ~38,500x. the supply is also growing a lot faster than it burns. staking mints ~5% a year and the foundation releases 114.6M ZAMA a month from treasury and growth. net of burns, that's a -19.8% DAAY (dilution-adjusted accrual yield). and even if the foundation holds every tranche, it's -5.7%. only 22.4% of supply circulates, and the first team and investor cliff hits feb. 2, 2027 (550M ZAMA, ~22% of circulating), then ~302M a month after that. so even if burns grow 90x to $2M a year by next october, the base case is $0.017, 78% below where it trades today. working backwards, today's price at fair value needs burns to go from $22.5k to ~$85M a year within 5 years. that's 3,800x, or roughly 5x every year. in comparison, ethereum:0xe76c6c83af64e4c60245d8c7de953df673a7a33d does ~$4.69M a year in fees on a ~$152M FDV, and nearly all of it reaches stakers through the treasury. that's ~200x the fees at about a sixth of the size. --- now let's take a look at @UmbraPrivacy: umbra launched through @MetaDAOProject last october, raising $3M at $0.30 against $155M of commitments. that makes it an ownership token. the treasury, the mint authority, and the IP all sit with a futarchy-controlled DAO, so the team runs on a $100k/month budget and anything above that needs a DAO-approved proposal. so structurally, solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta gives tokenholders a lot more than ethereum:0xa12cc123ba206d4031d1c7f6223d1c2ec249f4f3 does. the problem is there isn't much to own yet besides the cash. v1 shielding was free and shielded TVL is only ~$100K. the first fee sources only went live this week: > v2 (still invite-only) > the uUSDv stablecoin (umbra keeps 25% of the yield) the treasury holds ~$1.4M of stablecoins, or ~$0.06 per outstanding token. at $0.46, solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta trades at ~7.8x that, so the market is paying ~$9.5M for a business with no revenue yet. it has also funded operations by selling treasury tokens, ~3.2M UMBRA over the past year or ~13.5% of outstanding supply. net of a small buyback, that's a -12.1% DAAY. the positive is that insider tokens only unlock at price targets (2x to 32x the ICO price), and nothing unlocks for at least 6 months. my base case values the business at ~$6M, roughly where the ICO priced it, plus the cash. that gets to $0.23, ~50% below today after a +136% month. --- final scores at a 6-month time horizon: > ethereum:0xe76c6c83af64e4c60245d8c7de953df673a7a33d: 3.0, neutral > solana:PRVT6TB7uss3FrUd2D9xs2zqDBsa3GbMJMwCQsgmeta: 2.3, underperform > ethereum:0xa12cc123ba206d4031d1c7f6223d1c2ec249f4f3: 2.2, underperform FHE and privacy on solana could still become a big part of onchain privacy, but the tokens need to start capturing usage to be valuable.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Jake Koch-Gallup avatar
Jake Koch-Gallup@immutablejacob·Oct 16

ethereum:0xca14007eff0db1f8135f4c25b34de49ab0d42766 is up 258% since august. while stablecoins on starknet are down 7% to $141M. that's expected for now since price moves first and capital takes months to bridge over. ethereum:0xca14007eff0db1f8135f4c25b34de49ab0d42766 doubled after oct. 8, when starknet said it is "actively considering" leaving ethereum to become its own L1. but if that happens, stablecoins are extremely important. as an L1, starknet can't lean on ethereum's security. ethereum:0xca14007eff0db1f8135f4c25b34de49ab0d42766 has to secure the chain, so its value rests on staking demand, fees, and monetary premium. all three are easier to justify with more activity onchain, and stablecoins are the base that activity runs on. ethereum:0xca14007eff0db1f8135f4c25b34de49ab0d42766's current market cap is ~$642M, ~4.5x the stablecoins on starknet. if the oct. 22 vote passes, watch starknet's stablecoins over the next few quarters. a growing base would help justify the rerating.

Post attachment