←
Jim Meigs28,026 posts
Jim Meigs avatar

Jim Meigs

@jamesbmeigs

Columnist for @WSJFreeEx newsletter from @WSJOpinion; Sr fellow @ManhattanInst; Former @PopMech EIC. I beg to differ.

◷ Joined September 2009▧ 1,012 Photos and videos
Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·4h

Boy, there is so much good stuff in the @WSJFreeEx newsletter today. @jackbutler4815 on how Trump treats Xi "not as the hostile head of an antagonistic great power but as a rival real-estate developer with whom he can come to agreeable terms." @DrDominicGreen on the execrable Roger Waters. Edward Conlon on Mamdani's NYPD reorganization. @PeerReReview says DEI "has a new lease on life" in medical schools. And lots more

Ian Kingsbury avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Ian Kingsbury@PeerReReview·Nov 11

Nearly half of those sent the survey didn’t respond.

Post attachment

Nearly 97 percent of transgender people who received hormone therapy as teenagers did not regret it five years later, a study found. Though some patients did regret medically transitioning, those rates are relatively low compared to other medical interventions. wapo.st/4C44lZp

Matthew Yglesias avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Matthew Yglesias@mattyglesias·6h

Electrification is dramatically more expensive if you impose a renewables-only requirement on it than if you allow an all of the above approach to electricity generation.

Democrats are desperate to talk about affordability, reticent to talk about climate change. Yet preventing more frequent floods or fires would save trillions, while electrification with renewables is as cheap as it's ever been, writes Ryan Cooper. prospect.org/2026/11/18/clim…

Post attachment
Kyle Smith avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Kyle Smith@rkylesmith·7h

And his brand is "I'm the non-crazy Dem" ! (Direct taxes are unconstitutional, did they not teach you that at Harvard)

JUST IN: Pete Buttigieg calls for a national wealth tax & an “international agreement” to curb foreign tax shelters if wealthy Americans try to leave.

Alex Trembath avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Alex Trembath@atrembath·Nov 17

It’s because BAAJA is better on the merits than whatever messaging bill Merkely and Huffman will draft next year that Trump would veto anyway.

Why are Dems helping pass BAAJA in a lame-duck session? If the bill is so great, why not let the new Dem Congress consider it? Why the rush to pass it in a legislative setting that empowers outgoing lawmakers who are shielded from voter accountability? The answers are a tell.

Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·4h

It's great to see liberal pragmatists making the case for BAAJA. In our polarized time, this kind of genuine bipartisan compromise is so rare. There are parts the left doesn't like, parts the right doesn't like. But overall, BAAJA fixes some huge problems holding back progress. It shouldn't take courage to stand up for a sensible policy compromise that's good for the country. But it does. So we should salute the people doing it.

Hey, it's me, again. I want to zoom out on BAAJA for a second, because it’s easy to get lost in the weeds & debates about edge cases. I care *a lot* about this bill. Wanted to remind myself why. The status quo is *terrible* for both climate and affordability. We built 888 miles of high-voltage transmission in 2024; we need 5,000 a year. More clean capacity is waiting in interconnection queues than the entire existing grid. Residential power prices are up about a third since 2019. Demand is surging, and bc clean power can’t connect, we're building a bunch of gas. If this current trend continues, gas could supply half of US power by 2040. The administration is using permitting as a weapon to stop wind and solar projects, including ones already approved. And local restrictions on wind and solar now cover twice as much of the country as in 2022. I worked in the White House when we passed the IRA. As @BrianCDeese noted, if we had a bill like this in place first, it would have been game-changing. We invested hundreds of billions to put clean energy on sale, then watched projects get stuck in interconnection queues, permitting delays, and fights over who pays for transmission. The money was not the binding constraint; the ability to build was. Let’s not make the next Democratic administration learn that lesson twice! It's easy to oppose stuff. But BAAJA is a *really, really big deal.* This is the first real federal framework to plan, pay for, and permit big power lines: mandatory planning between regions, clear rules on who pays (based on who benefits), and federal backstop siting that actually works across most of the country. It also ends incumbent utilities’ automatic right to build every new regional line. It will also help actually get projects online, by requiring grid planning and interconnection be done together, and stopping speculative projects clogging the queue. It should protect from political sabotage. Approved projects can’t be yanked for political reasons, and developers can sue if an administration targets a technology like wind for unfair treatment. It's the strongest data center accountability legislation in the country to ensure they pay *more* than the costs they cause and that households don’t foot the bill for AI’s grid upgrades. This is the most important thing Congress can do for clean energy and affordability right now. We can fight about the emissions and affordability modeling about this narrow bill. But the truth is that this is the necessary but insufficient foundation *every future climate and affordability policy will be built on.*

Jane Flegal avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Jane Flegal@JaneAFlegal·6h

Hey, it's me, again. I want to zoom out on BAAJA for a second, because it’s easy to get lost in the weeds & debates about edge cases. I care *a lot* about this bill. Wanted to remind myself why. The status quo is *terrible* for both climate and affordability. We built 888 miles of high-voltage transmission in 2024; we need 5,000 a year. More clean capacity is waiting in interconnection queues than the entire existing grid. Residential power prices are up about a third since 2019. Demand is surging, and bc clean power can’t connect, we're building a bunch of gas. If this current trend continues, gas could supply half of US power by 2040. The administration is using permitting as a weapon to stop wind and solar projects, including ones already approved. And local restrictions on wind and solar now cover twice as much of the country as in 2022. I worked in the White House when we passed the IRA. As @BrianCDeese noted, if we had a bill like this in place first, it would have been game-changing. We invested hundreds of billions to put clean energy on sale, then watched projects get stuck in interconnection queues, permitting delays, and fights over who pays for transmission. The money was not the binding constraint; the ability to build was. Let’s not make the next Democratic administration learn that lesson twice! It's easy to oppose stuff. But BAAJA is a *really, really big deal.* This is the first real federal framework to plan, pay for, and permit big power lines: mandatory planning between regions, clear rules on who pays (based on who benefits), and federal backstop siting that actually works across most of the country. It also ends incumbent utilities’ automatic right to build every new regional line. It will also help actually get projects online, by requiring grid planning and interconnection be done together, and stopping speculative projects clogging the queue. It should protect from political sabotage. Approved projects can’t be yanked for political reasons, and developers can sue if an administration targets a technology like wind for unfair treatment. It's the strongest data center accountability legislation in the country to ensure they pay *more* than the costs they cause and that households don’t foot the bill for AI’s grid upgrades. This is the most important thing Congress can do for clean energy and affordability right now. We can fight about the emissions and affordability modeling about this narrow bill. But the truth is that this is the necessary but insufficient foundation *every future climate and affordability policy will be built on.*

isabelle 🪐 avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
isabelle 🪐@isabelleboemeke·10h

We should shame Germany forever for its nuclear policy. Because it didn't just wreck its own industry, it infected the rest of Europe too. Industrial suicide at scale.

Sverige har lyckats med något historiskt. På bara några år har vi förvandlat ett land med nästan gratis, stabil el till ett land där folk får ångest varje gång de öppnar sin elräkning. Det är en bedrift som få länder matchar. Förklaringen är enkel och elegant: de rödgröna stängde kärnkraftverk som producerade el dygnet runt, året om, och ersatte dem med vindkraftverk som producerar el när det blåser lagom mycket. När det inte blåser importerar vi istället el från kolkraftverk i Tyskland eller gas från länder vi helst inte vill nämna. Resultatet? Rekordhöga priser i södra Sverige och politiker som förklarar att det här är precis så det var tänkt. När elräkningen landar på 12 000 kronor i januari får man höra att det är Putins fel. Eller klimatets. Eller marknadens. Aldrig att det kan ha något att göra med att man medvetet monterat ner den enda energikälla som faktiskt levererar planerbar el i stor skala. Nej, lösningen är mer av samma: fler vindkraftverk till havs, fler solpaneler som inte ger något i december, och fler utredningar om hur man ska kompensera hushållen för den politik man just genomfört. Samtidigt exporterar Sverige el till kontinenten när det blåser bra, för att sedan köpa tillbaka dyr el när det är kallt och vindstilla. Det kallas ”europeisk solidaritet”. Svenska villaägare kallar det något annat när de sitter i mörkret med vinterjackan på och funderar på om det är värt att sätta på ugnen. Det vackraste är ändå retoriken. Man talar om ”grön omställning” medan elpriset gör att folk tvingas elda med ved eller stänga av elementen. Man talar om ”framtidens energi” medan industrierna hotar att flytta. Och när någon påpekar att Norge och Finland har lägre priser tack vare mer kärnkraft, blir svaret att Sverige är mer progressivt. Så nästa gång elräkningen kommer: tänk inte på den stängda reaktorn i Barsebäck eller Ringhals. Tänk på de vackra vindkraftverken som just nu står stilla. Det är framsteg. Det är moral. Och det är, enligt de ansvariga, det enda ansvarsfulla valet.

Post attachment
Jared Isaacman avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Jared Isaacman@rookisaacman·16h

I am a fan of just about every spacecraft and launch vehicle that has ever carried humans into space, in all their glory and with all the imperfections. Some were products of the best technology and engineering available at the time. Others were shaped by political considerations or a fear of letting go and taking an even bigger leap. Regardless, they all have a place in the extraordinary history that is human spaceflight. If there was ever a time to play favorites, though, it is now. Think of what is operational or nearing so.. Dragon, Starliner, Orion, not to mention the international crewed vehicles. And then consider what is coming with Starship, Blue Moon, and whatever else industry and other space agencies are working on that has yet to be revealed. For an enthusiast, there are more options now to admire, with an increasing share of the investment and risk carried by private industry rather than the taxpayer. A reality that might dampen the political and budgetary volatility that has constrained ambitions for generations. When we once again look back on Earth from the Moon, and someday Mars, I would like to believe the elation and reverence of having arrived will far outweigh our attachment to the hardware that got us there.

Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·Nov 17

I never thought I'd say this, but man, I miss Mayor Adams. "Peaceful protest is a constitutional right. Violent rioting is a crime. And confusing the two is a dangerous failure of leadership."

There is a reason New York City has not experienced the kind of violent riots we have witnessed in Paris and other major cities around the world. We had the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized unit of highly trained officers prepared to confront violence before it spiraled out of control. Let me make something absolutely clear. Peaceful protest is a constitutional right. Violent rioting is a crime. And confusing the two is a dangerous failure of leadership. The SRG was not created to silence peaceful protesters. It was created to protect New Yorkers when demonstrations crossed the line into violence, to protect businesses from destruction, peaceful demonstrators from violent agitators, and police officers from being assaulted. Now City Hall is dismantling that specialized unit, introducing unarmed civilian de-escalation teams, and restricting the tools available to police. I support de-escalation. Every responsible police officer does. But de-escalation is a strategy, not a substitute for the ability to confront violence. You cannot reason with a brick flying through a storefront. You cannot negotiate with a Molotov cocktail. And you cannot send a social worker to do the job of a specially trained police officer confronting a violent mob. The NYPD will still have officers responding to protests. But the question City Hall has failed to answer is why New Yorkers will be safer without a dedicated unit specifically trained for these dangerous situations. What happens when peaceful protesters are attacked? When businesses are being destroyed? When police officers are surrounded and assaulted? Who responds? How quickly? With what training? And with what tools? These are not hypothetical questions. These are the decisions that determine whether a dangerous situation is contained or an entire neighborhood descends into chaos. I spent four years as mayor and 22 years as an NYPD officer. I know the difference between protecting someone’s right to protest and allowing someone to use that protest as cover for violence. The right to protest does not include the right to terrorize. And protecting civil liberties should never require surrendering public safety. City Hall may believe dismantling the SRG is a political victory. But if violence erupts, the people paying the price won’t be the activists applauding this announcement or the politicians celebrating it at City Hall. It will be the police officer who gets assaulted. The small-business owner whose livelihood is destroyed. The peaceful protester who gets caught in the violence. The innocent New Yorker who simply wants to get home safely. New York City’s Public Safety is not a laboratory for ideological experiments. Our police officers are not expendable. And public safety is not something you gamble with to score political points. City Hall should reverse this decision before New Yorkers discover the consequences the hard way.

Post attachment
Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·Nov 17

Mamdani shows exquisite concern for the sensibilities of the people disrupting city life and threatening Jews and other enemies of the DSA left. But he shows little concern for the rights of people whose lives are upended. For the mayor and his team "the sight of uniformed officers with long guns and heavy vests is intimidating," @yaelbt writes. She says the real question shouldn't be "who those officers intimidate, but who they protect from unmanageable chaos." As usual, Mamdani sides with the worst people. wsj.com/opinion/free-express…

Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·Nov 17

Mamdani's decision to disband the NYPD's Strategic Response Group rests on several dishonest claims: It assumes an armed police presence "escalates" (rather than prevents) conflict. It redefines street violence as "free speech." And it posits that "inexperienced civilians with no arrest powers but a cool acronym will maintain order," writes @yaelbt in today's @WSJFreeEx newsletter. [link next]

Jim Meigs avatar
Jim Meigs@jamesbmeigs·Nov 17

Today I asked my favorite aviation reporter for her take on the FAA ground stop. She said, "Any time something like this happens, I just call Bob Poole."

Bob Poole has been doing the most serious work of any human alive to drag the U.S. Air Traffic Control system kicking and screaming into the 21st century over the objections of useless politicians. Here's what he says about this weekend's clusterFUBAR: reason.org/aviation-policy-n…

Jim Geraghty avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Jim Geraghty@jimgeraghty·Nov 16

"In effect, Russia’s demands would mean that the countries that joined NATO after 1997, including Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic, and the three Baltic nations, could no longer host troops or weapons." To me, the proper response to these demands is a seven-page fax, with the first page just being a giant letter “F” and you can probably guess the contents of the next six pages.

Tom Cotton avatar
⟳ Jim Meigs retweeted
Tom Cotton@SenTomCotton·Nov 13

NATO nations withdrawing from *their own* borders is a preposterous demand by Russia. Putin has proved once again that he’s not serious about a negotiated peace. Further talks are a farce at this point. Putin will only agree to stop the war when he knows he can’t win. We need to help Ukraine prove that point. nytimes.com/2026/11/13/us/po…