Jasper Wiese has been handed a three-match suspension (four if he doesn't attend tackle school).
"A Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC), chaired by Roddy MacLeod (Scotland), joined Aggrey Chabeda (Kenya), and Ofisa Tonu (New Zealand) convened to consider the red card, and concluded a sanction of 4 weeks for the mid-range entry point offence. The player has the option to apply to undertake the World Rugby Coaching Intervention Programme. Successful completion of the programme would reduce the sanction to 3 weeks."
It is inconceivable that the technical table made a mistake. There are checks and balances in place at more than one source for all timers (cards, HIA, Blood, etc.). WR uses an APP called Switch which runs timers, the official timekeeper also uses an APP for all timekeeping events, normally something like Rugby Timer; then the movement recorder immediately notes the time on the referee yellow card report form (which referee completes post match), a competent technical table also notes the time separately on paper (notepad) should technology fail at any time (which it can). Rule of thumb for team managers is to also note the time (stadium clock) in which the card was issued and in terms of a yellow card, simply adds 10min to the stadium clock time to know when the player can return. So in case of Lucu being sent off at 39:09 his return time (stadium clock or broadcaster clock) should be 49:09 - simple calculation.
Also understanding card timers pause with the timekeepers clock, and stadium clock whenever there is a time-out.
To have all these fail is simply incomprehensible.
Rough work on it.
39.09 - yellow card issued to Lucu
39.34 - lineout throw from Marx.
40.24 - conversion made
Clock runs during TMO review, try disallowed
42.35 - end of the half, Dupont kicks into touch, no rewind after review.
6.33 left on yellow clock
7.30 left on Lucu's yellow when the countdown reappears at 40.33
46.55 - Lucu returns
Rassie Erasmus was right. Sam Prendergast has been cleared for this weekend's Test.
He has not been banned for his hip-drop tackle on Fiji's Peceli Yato.
“The committee unanimously determined that the player had proved that the citing should be dismissed”
Using the words “match fixing”? Not good. Not advised.
But he is being held accountable now.
Referees are reviewed on every single match they ref, and rated on their performances. That’s a level of accountability. Maybe more could be done on transparency.
Governing bodies? Nothing. They are in charge, who can actually say otherwise?
A lesson for RUGBY from football:
Every football fan thinks the ref hates their club. Can’t all be true. It isn’t.
The people above the refs? Different story.
Everton: charged Mar ‘23. Docked points Nov ‘23.
City: charged Feb ‘23. Guilty Sep ‘26. Still no sanction.
Ronaldo: elbow, 3-game ban, 2 suspended. Free for the World Cup.
Balogun: red card at the World Cup. Ban wiped before the next game.
Rugby:
Sexton: not even playing. Walks onto the pitch, swears at the officials. 3 games. All World Cup warm-ups.
Wessels: no clear footage, accuser believed. 9 weeks.
Furlong: nine camera angles, accuser “honest but mistaken”. Cleared.
Refs aren’t biased.
But being the governing body doesn’t make you fair.
Rassie's comments were always going to result in a ban.
Dropping 'match-fixing' even if frame it as a question was going to be the final nail in the coffin.
He had to know his comments could get him in kak and he persisted.
And no, his points won't be addressed.
SA Rugby confirm that they have requested a full misconduct hearing.
SA rugby statement:
SA Rugby is requesting a full misconduct hearing for Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus following his sanctioning by an independent World Rugby panel for comments made in a press conference in Dublin on Monday.
An SA Rugby spokesperson said that the organisation respected the process but had requested an opportunity for its coach to contextualize his comments and assure the panel that it was not his intention to allege that any match official had acted with ulterior motives.
SA Rugby trusted that such a hearing could be expedited considering the seriousness of the charge.
SA Rugby will not make any further comment until the hearing could be completed."
In respect to the sanction, the panel determined that the conduct clearly amounts to disrespecting the authority of the match officials by impugning their integrity. Therefore, the panel reviewed a number of elements of the commentary including the timing and reach of the statements, combined with the allegations of bias or bad faith, and found that the comments attracted a six-match automatic suspension.
"Having considered the comments which related to the match TMO, the standing Match Official Abuse committee*, chaired by senior officer Adam Casselden SC (Australia) determined that the threshold for serious misconduct had been met. The panel determined that the comments suggest that match officials acted with bias/prejudice or deliberately influenced the outcome of a match, and when the conduct is considered as a whole a reasonable person would conclude that the conduct constituted an unacceptable attack on the credibility and competence of the match officials. "
Rough work on it.
39.09 - yellow card issued to Lucu
39.34 - lineout throw from Marx.
40.24 - conversion made
Clock runs during TMO review, try disallowed
42.35 - end of the half, Dupont kicks into touch, no rewind after review.
6.33 left on yellow clock
7.30 left on Lucu's yellow when the countdown reappears at 40.33
46.55 - Lucu returns
Someone else picked up on this too. They posted screenshots showing the time he was sent off and the time he returned, with the match clock visible in both.