←
Jackie Faherty5,838 posts
Jackie Faherty avatar

Jackie Faherty

@jfaherty

Astrophysicist at @AMNH. Enthusiast for bringing the cosmos to the public @backyardworlds #womeninscience #BDNYC #manhattanhenge #astronomy #scicomm

◷ Joined March 2009▧ 1,462 Photos and videos
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·14 Jun 2024

Last night was a gorgeous sunset in #nyc . We are close to the summer solstice (six days out) so we are in the high part of #manhattanhenge effect season. At 8:08 last night the sun crossed the city grid about 2.5 degrees above the horizon. Lighting up the canyon brilliantly.

Post attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·28 May 2024

Today is the official start of #manhattanhenge season! Get your cameras ready as the day is looking gorgeous. The sun will set far enough north today that it just kisses the grid of the city before setting. It lights up the concrete jungle in perfect golden hour colors. @AMNH

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

In all, it's SUPER exciting to see such an unexpected result. And now we get to follow this thing up and search for more details about this phenomenon. It's an EXCELLENT comparative object for solar system objects, exoplanets and other brown dwarfs. So it wins on all fronts.

Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

Jupiter gets an auroral contribution from Io, it's volcanic moon. Could this thing have something orbiting it and supplying the plasma that leads to the aurora that leads to the methane emission? Way too soon to tell but certainly an enticing possibility!

Post attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

We went with an auroral explanation for the phenomenon. But we still have to find the ingredients that make that aurora happen. There's no star that this thing is orbiting so the solar wind isn't contributing to that inversion. Could it be an internal process? Maybe. Or maybe...

Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

Our object was COLD though (~480K or the temperature you bake cookies at), making it extra enticing and interesting. It's much more like Jupiter than it is like any star. And Jupiter certainly has beautiful aurora AND shows methane in emission...

Post attachmentPost attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

The aurora was an easy go to explanation for what was going on. Several brown dwarfs have been suggested as being auroral candidates. Recently Melodie Kao led a paper that showed resolved imaging of a radiation belt around one such candidate: arxiv.org/pdf/2302.12841.pdf

Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

We don't have answers to everything but we can speculate a bit...

Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

Then the speculation began: what would cause a temperature inversion? Why just the methane? Was this an internal or an external process? How does this compare to other objects? Why was this the only object showing it? Sooooo many questions....

Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

If we tried to force the model to behave like what one would expect for an isolated source (aka NO INVERSION ALLOWED) then it looked ok but it could not fit the methane emission. That meant the temperature inversion was explaining it!!!

Post attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

In order to fit the methane emission feature we required a TEMPERATURE INVERSION!!! Wow. It was 300K and centered at 1-10mbar. That means instead of getting warmer in a fairly uniform way as you dive into the object, you would hit this hot spot in the upper atmosphere.

Post attachment
Jackie Faherty avatar
Jackie Faherty@jfaherty·17 Apr 2024

To really figure it out we then went about the modeling exercise. @substellarfella has a retrieval code called Brewster that was up for the task! We added all the appropriate gases and physics, ran the models and saw something amazing as a result...