←
John Arnold10,777 posts
John Arnold avatar✓

John Arnold ✓

@johnarnold

Co-chair of Arnold Ventures. Reality is more nuanced than the headline.

◷ Joined October 2013▧ 1,386 Photos and videos
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 17

Cool to watch from the Senate gallery tonight as legislation to modernize energy permitting took another huge step forward, with a strong, bipartisan 70-27 vote.

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 16

The drip, drip, drip of industries convincing politicians that they need taxpayer subsidies to compete globally.

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 16

The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) was passed in 1970. It was designed to require projects with a federal nexus to have to consider the environmental impact, not a permitting law. The legislation was just 5 pages long. As such, judicial interpretations and litigation have shaped how the law is interpreted in practice. NEPA review became a major component of project approval, capable of delaying projects even though it doesn't create a new permit requirement. The 13 circuit courts have interpreted NEPA very differently, although the role of courts was curtailed in the "Seven County" Supreme Court case last year. That unanimous ruling said courts need to refer back to the original law and defer more to federal agencies. The ruling created significant uncertainty about the future of NEPA. Much is unknown about the scope of environmental reviews required, judicial remedies, and procedural requirements in a post-"Seven County" world. Remember, NEPA was just a 5-page law written >50 years ago. It needs to be updated and clarified so developers and objectors understand the requirements and the process. Either developers spend the next decade guessing what the new rules are as challenges get tested in the courts, or Congress can clarify and modernize the law. The authors of BAAJA understand this issue and have clarified the role and process of NEPA in the bill. Opponents of a project can raise their hand, express their concern, have the issue adjudicated, and have a decision made on the merits. The process will get to yes, or to no, in a timely manner that allows the good projects to be built better, faster, and cheaper. If BAAJA passes, Congress will have set a clear framework that balances the needs of today's society while respecting the lands, air, water and wildlife we treasure.

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 15

NYT, WSJ, WaPo, and Bloomberg don't often all agree. They do on supporting passage of BAAJA.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Jeff Navin avatar
⟳ John Arnold retweeted
Jeff Navin@jeffnavin·Nov 12

Against my better judgment, I’m weighing in here, on the dumbest policy discussion platform in the world, to talk about permitting reform. As background, I was Chief of Staff and Deputy Chief of Staff at the Energy Department in the Obama Administration; I worked for seven years in the Senate Democratic Leader’s Office; and I served as Chief of Staff in the House. I co-founded the largest energy transition advisory and advocacy firm in the United States 13 years ago. I have worked directly or indirectly on nearly every major piece of energy and climate legislation in the past two decades, as well as many other pieces of legislation outside of energy. I’ve also worked as a political researcher for multiple campaigns and the DSCC, where I cataloged politicians’ and candidates’ votes and positions. Today, I spend nearly all of my time talking to policymakers, clean energy companies, advocates, and journalists on energy and climate issues. The idea that there will be anywhere near 60 votes in the Senate for a clean-energy-only bill in January is not based in reality. I have no idea where this idea came from, but it ignores mountains of evidence and seems to underpin the arguments of everyone on here saying we’re somehow going to get a bill that excludes oil and gas if we wait. First, and very obviously, every candidate in 2026 ran on reducing gasoline and electricity prices for consumers. One post-election analysis found that only six victorious Democrats used the word “climate” in their election night statements, while 166 discussed affordability. I couldn't find a single Senate candidate who flipped a seat who mentioned it. Voters sent a clear mandate to focus on affordability, and they are rightly irate that Washington has pushed ideological issues favored by special interest groups ahead of the issues they care most about. After getting trounced in 2024 for ignoring inflation, Democrats won by promising to focus on those issues. Second, very few Democrats in the Senate support anything remotely close to a keep-it-in-the-ground agenda. Next Congress, 19 members of the Democratic caucus who voted for cloture on the motion to proceed on this version of the permitting bill will return. They’ll be joined by James Talarico, who has endorsed all-of-the-above and vowed to protect oil and gas jobs. Mary Peltola has explicitly called for more oil and gas development. Scott Colom supports natural gas. Both Adam Hamilton and Annie Andrews endorsed an “all of the above” strategy, which includes oil and gas. They will join the 14 members of next year’s caucus who declined to strip the natural gas-carrying Mountain Valley Pipeline from the 2023 debt limit bill. Senator Kaine offered an amendment to remove the provision expediting the pipeline’s completion. Senators Bennet, Brown, Coons, Fetterman, Hassan, Hickenlooper, Kelly, King, Murray, Ossoff, Padilla, Reed, Schatz, and Schumer voted against that amendment. The year before, 27 members of next year’s caucus voted to advance Senator Manchin’s permitting amendment, which would have completed MVP. Both Bennet and Warner voted to approve the Keystone XL pipeline. Senators King, Murphy, and Blumenthal all urged FERC to expedite the Algonquin pipeline expansion. Fetterman, Kaine, and Hickenlooper have all supported LNG exports (as did the Obama Administration). Senator Gallego released an energy plan last December that called for clear timelines for oil and gas pipeline permitting. Roy Cooper’s administration approved the Atlantic Coast Pipeline’s water permit in 2018 when he was North Carolina’s governor. Mary Peltola has introduced legislation to open ANWR and NPR-A to drilling. Next year, the caucus will contain only 14 senators who co-sponsored the Senate Green New Deal resolution. Three of them voted for cloture this week, including Senator Heinrich, who is leading the charge on permitting. That’s 10 Democrats out of 56 who supported the GND and opposed cloture on permitting. This does not mean that a majority of the Democratic caucus will push for new oil and gas infrastructure. But much of the commentary here implies that Democrats will only support renewables and Republicans will only support oil and gas infrastructure. The record doesn't support that idea. This, of course, doesn’t even get to the fact that we will need more than a few Senate Republicans to support a permitting package in the next Congress. Getting those Senators will require compromises that will likely push some Democrats to vote no. So you’ll very likely need more than four. A bill that gets Fetterman, Murkowski, and Curtis could easily lose Sanders, Warren, Markey, and Merkley. So then you’d need more GOP votes. This is how legislation works. The IRA was the exception, not the rule, and it nearly died before it passed. It was that hard to get Manchin and Sanders on the same page, and it didn't need a single GOP vote. Many of the groups opposing permitting didn’t like the IRA. And, of course, a bill that doesn’t get signed by the President is about as useful as any tweet on this hellscape of a website. There seems to be a very real disagreement about what would make this bill “better.” There is no “clean energy only” version of the bill that can pass the next Congress. NEPA and the NHPA are, at best, fundamentally outdated at a time when we need to build as much clean energy infrastructure as possible, as quickly as possible. Those who argue that these two statutes are the only way to achieve meaningful engagement with the sovereign tribes and frontline communities lack imagination. Remember that under both NEPA and NHPA, Dakota Access got built - adjacent to tribal land and under the Missouri River. Acting as if these laws, written long before climate change was a known crisis, are sacred and should not be touched ignores their reality. Saying that the nation-to-nation relationship between sovereign tribes and the federal government is only a function of “historic preservation” is quite insulting to tribes. Since NEPA and the NHPA were signed into law, more than 250,000 miles of pipelines have been built in the United States. NEPA is actually a pretty poor tool for killing infrastructure. It is, however, great for lawyers. And finally, the policy window is open now. There is no guarantee it will remain open indefinitely. In 2009, with overwhelming Democratic majorities, we got eight Republicans to vote for cap-and-trade legislation in the House. It passed by seven votes after 44(!) Democrats voted against it, and it died in the Senate without a floor vote. It took us 13 years to get another big climate vote via the IRA (which was, again, not good enough for some of the activists). There is no guarantee oil stays below $100/barrel or that the economy doesn’t slip into a recession or the wars in Iran and Ukraine stay confined to those countries. Macro events could create even more pressure for policies that support oil and gas or crush the appetite for a debate on permitting. I’ve worked on nuclear, solar, wind, electric vehicles, transmission, energy storage, and just about every other form of clean energy technology. I haven’t lobbied on behalf of any of the oil and gas bills I cited above, nor have I lobbied for oil or gas companies. I’ve worked with many of the NGOs supporting this bill, and many of the NGOs opposed to it. I’ve spent many decades working on policy, building coalitions, and trying to instill a sense of urgency on climate policy. Reasonable people can oppose this bill for many reasons. But don’t delude yourself into thinking there are 56 votes against fossil fuel infrastructure, or that there is a viable path to a permitting deal that will keep oil and gas in the ground in the next few years. Any permitting bill will need to be bipartisan, and once policy windows close, there is no guarantee they will open again soon. In short, no legislation is perfect. This bill is very clearly a net-positive for the climate. We cannot solve climate change without policy changes that lower emissions. The status quo is not good enough. There is an opportunity to move the needle today, and we should take it. I look forward to all of the thoughtful, constructive comments on this post, which will once again prove that this is the best place on earth for substantive policy discussion. I will take suggestions to delete my account in good faith, and I recommend that anyone serious about policy do the same.

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 12

An underrated benefit of living in a growing city is that blighted houses and abandoned buildings get redeveloped rather than remaining eyesores.

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

The bullwhip effect has suppliers suffering the greatest financial pain. But suppliers have learned through experience. The compute and power supply chain companies have been weary of the AI cycle. Many required multi-year guaranteed offtake commitments or large cancellation penalties from credit-worthy counterparties before expanding capacity, preparing for if/when demand sagged. So maybe those at the end of the chain make it out ok if the cycle goes bad. Those at the front of the chain would suffer the losses. 7/7

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

Softbank ordered extra equipment in anticipation of shortages. But if demand doesn't meet expectations, they end up with extra equipment and sharply cut back future orders. If others in the industry made a similar decision and overestimated demand, well that's the bullwhip. 6/

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

5) Order cancellations: Customers sharply reduce or cancel orders as they recognize the excess 6) Bust: Suppliers experience a disproportionately severe downturn, often cutting prices, production, and investment. 5/

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

3) Amplification: Suppliers interpret increased orders as evidence of even stronger demand and expand production capacity 4) Oversupply: Actual demand fails to match inflated orders, leaving excess inventory and production capacity 4/

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

Here is the process in which it happens: 1) Demand increases: Strong end-customer demand growth creates shortages along the supply chain 2) Overordering: Companies order more from their suppliers than they need to protect against shortages and long delivery times 3/

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

From AI: "The bullwhip effect is a supply-chain phenomenon in which relatively small changes in end-customer demand cause increasingly large fluctuations in orders, inventory, and production further up the supply chain, often resulting in overinvestment, excess inventory, and sharp subsequent contractions." 2/

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

I read how Softbank lost $3.7 billion cancelling a gas turbine order and thought this is setting up as a textbook case study of the bullwhip effect that decimated the telecom and fiber optics in 2001. The caveat is that suppliers may have negotiated better contracts this time. 1/

Post attachment
John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 11

Voters sent a clear message last week that they are deeply concerned about affordability. The rising costs of healthcare, housing & energy are putting real pressure on families. But affordability can't just be a campaign slogan; it must be a governing philosophy. There are two main ways to address high costs: subsidies and supply side reforms. Subsidies have their place, but also serious problems, particularly in an environment of limited fiscal capacity with $2 tln annual deficits and the 10-year at 5%. More importantly, subsidies often treat the symptoms of high costs rather than their causes. Supply side reforms address the underlying problem. They expand capacity and competition, reduce costs for all Americans and do so without adding to the national debt. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is among the most important energy affordability bills this century. It helps the energy system deliver on multiple priorities by lowering costs, improving reliability, reducing emissions, creating jobs, strengthening energy independence, and supporting economic growth. These goals transcend party lines. That's why two Democrats and two Republicans, representing very different states, ideologies and priorities, were able to negotiate a comprehensive bill that provides greater certainty for projects and streamlines environmental reviews while preserving the right to raise and adjudicate legitimate objections. It's also why the bill received 73 votes in the Senate yesterday, the first of several votes needed to make it law. This bill is not perfect. No bill is. It includes some Republican priorities and some Democratic priorities. But mostly it includes American priorities that aren't partisan, like ensuring data centers pay 100% or more of their costs, establishing clear rules for responsible development, limiting executive authority to favor one energy source over another, and making better use of the infrastructure we've already built. Politicians spent months telling voters they understood their concerns about affordability. Now they have a chance to prove it.

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 10

Fantastic post about why many well-intentioned government policies and philanthropic interventions fail to produce their intended results because we vastly overestimate our understanding of human behavior and our ability to change it. experimental-history.com/p/w…

John Arnold avatar
John Arnold@johnarnold·Nov 10

Dept of Unintended Consequences: "Plain packaging—where you strip cigarette boxes of their attractive branding—seems like a no brainer, but in Australia, it looks like the policy caused smokers to switch to cheaper brands and to smoke more." via @a_m_mastroianni

Post attachment