←
John Hawks25,923 posts
John Hawks avatar

John Hawks

@johnhawks

I'm a paleoanthropologist. I explore human fossils and genomes to understand where we came from and what we share with our ancestors.

◷ Joined July 2009▧ 2,571 Photos and videos
John Hawks avatar
John Hawks@johnhawks·28m

Hominin teeth from an unexpected corner of China, gnawed by porcupines in a cave full of orangutan teeth. Protein data suggest a deep lineage, possibly Homo erectus. Still, some parts of the analysis gnaw at me. johnhawks.net/p/another-reth…

Niko McCarty. avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
Niko McCarty.@NikoMcCarty·Nov 15

I spent the last three months trying to start a scientific journal inside of Asimov Press. Everybody says journals suck, that they’ll become outdated with AI, and that we need to adapt and run more publishing experiments. I agree! Journals are also not fun to read; PDFs are uninspiring, and we should be making more interactive versions of these texts. After looking into this, though, I think most journal editors would like to run more experiments, but they’re effectively stuck in a valley of death because of the publishers and indexers. For a journal to be considered “real,” in a sense, and attract submissions, it often needs to be indexed by Clarivate or another major indexer. Clarivate also calculates the Journal Impact Factor. But these indexers have many dumb requirements. Clarivate, for example, requires access to full-text PDFs. So you can’t, as a journal seeking inclusion in Web of Science, just get rid of PDFs and move to a digital, interactive model; you would need to do all the digital stuff and THEN ALSO generate static PDFs to satisfy the indexer. This is one of the reasons journals don’t run more experiments; it’s a logistical headache. And if a journal steps too far out of line, it can lose indexing coverage or its impact factor. This is what happened to eLife. It ran an aggressive experiment with peer review, lost its impact factor, and saw submissions fall 55 percent between 2024 and 2025. Much of its content is still indexed, and it has substantial funding from big institutional donors to help it survive. Many journals don’t have this luxury; they depend on publishing fees or subscriptions, and if that revenue dries up, they risk going out of business. If you want to build a journal that is super creative and unique without worrying about these constraints, then, you need philanthropic or institutional funding, or you need to convince scientists not to care about impact factors and submit to you anyway. (But the latter is hard because many universities still weigh the perceived “quality” of the journals scientists publish in when deciding whom to promote.) It seems like one of the only ways forward, then, is to completely abolish the indexers or pass some kind of federal policy that prohibits universities from promoting people on the basis of impact factors. TL;DR: Don’t misdirect your anger at the journals. The problem is with the people above the individual journals, especially the publishers and indexers. Academic publishing is filled with perverse incentives.

John Hawks avatar
John Hawks@johnhawks·Oct 26

“It’s probably just chance — when the climate was nice enough, they could make it there,” Dr. Hawks said. “They kept trying, again and again, and to me that’s the bottom line of humans, that throughout the Pleistocene, we just kept coming.” nytimes.com/2026/10/26/scien…

Panos Ipeirotis avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
Panos Ipeirotis@ipeirotis·Sep 19

Everything at the end will look like a Nature/PNAS paper: a quick 6-pager for humans, and a humongous 150-page supplement with all possible experiments and analyses (mainly for the machines to read and review). Together with an automatic verification/reproducibility package that ensures that whatever the paper says is verifiable. And at the end everything will seem like before, but underneath everything will have changed.

Panos Ipeirotis avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
Panos Ipeirotis@ipeirotis·Sep 19

The use of AI in research is producing three tribes. The gatekeepers — the Pangramiani — care about provenance: research is a profession, authorship matters, and AI should be banned, discouraged, or marked through disclosure. The AI cultists care about results: if knowledge advances, who cares whether it came from a human, a machine, or both? Pangram delenda est. And now a third tribe is emerging: the curators/storytellers. As AI starts cracking increasingly hard mathematical proofs, discovery itself becomes less scarce. The human role shifts to understanding the result, judging its importance, connecting it to what we know, and explaining it to everyone else.

John Hawks avatar
John Hawks@johnhawks·Sep 27

Vanguard Cave, Gibraltar, is known today for Neanderthal behavioral evidence, including a remarkable controlled hearth for production of pitch from gum rockrose. In 2021, the team discovered a chamber sealed for more than 40,000 years, results to come! johnhawks.net/p/a-visit-to-v…

John Hawks avatar
John Hawks@johnhawks·Aug 31

Dunbar’s number is one of those concepts that is just further entrenched by every demonstration that it’s not true. The final boss of 1990s pop science myths.

The famous limit of 150 friends a human brain can supposedly hold turns out to rest on a calculation too wide to support any specific number, let alone the one everyone quotes siliconcanals.com/n-the-famo…

DaFreg avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
DaFreg@djfreg1·Aug 26

Paleoanthropology needs to abandon the notion of a geographical "origin" - a very simplistic monolineage concept invalidated by overwhelming fossil and molecular evidence of a complex reticulate network for the entire recognized Homo existence period. Even at (much) deeper time depths, and given a biased and fragmented fossil record, disputed lithic evidence plus historical biases, the presumption of a single "origin" biogeography is also problematic in light of hominid and hominin hybridization - often the result of contact between previously separated biogeographies. This was clearly a multi-regional evolutionary process dominated by punctuated phases of gene flow between highly mobile, adaptive and intelligent species, and probably reaching back into the Miocene as Eurasian hominine-like fossil discoveries would suggest.

John Hawks avatar
John Hawks@johnhawks·Aug 25

“In broad strokes, it appears that the modern human population evolved from a merger of two ancient groups around 300,000 years ago, roughly 80% from one, and 20% from the other.” Who were these stem populations? Here is some informed speculation. johnhawks.net/p/modern-human…

Małgorzata Kot avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
Małgorzata Kot@omimea·Aug 24

Meet the most glamourous Neanderthal knife ever. See the shiny spot, left by the knapper exactly in the middle? Tell me, they were not aestetically sensitive. #RajCave what a cave

Post attachmentPost attachment
Michael 英泉 Eisen avatar
⟳ John Hawks retweeted
Michael 英泉 Eisen@mbeisen·Aug 21

I know people think the Monty Hall problem is a game show trick or a silly math puzzle, but the fact that most people get the logic wrong can have real world consequences. I'll walk you through an example I teach in my undergraduate Human Genetics class.

Post attachment