“A state that cannot image its own territory cannot attribute a strike, cannot contest a false claim, cannot price its own risk.” Says kelevitch
My latest article for @SpaceNews_Inc is live on shutter control, the Gulf, and a sovereignty gap most people don’t know exists.
spacenews.com/shutter-contro…
Before there was isnad, there was nasab.
In pre-Islamic Arabia, your lineage was your passport. It decided who protected you, who owed you blood money, who you could marry, and where you stood in the tribe. So people memorized it, often reciting their ancestry back many generations, and specialists called nassabin made a craft of it. Poetry worked the same way: the ruwat carried verses from one person to the next, always with the poet’s name attached.
Then revelation came, and a culture that already asked “who are you descended from?” started asking “who did you hear this from?”
That habit of naming every link in a chain, and treating a missing or invented link as a serious problem, carried straight into hadith scholarship. A genealogy only needs a name. The hadith scholars wanted to know whether the person behind each name was trustworthy. They built jarh wa ta’dil, the science of evaluating narrators, and the rijal literature that documents thousands of them.
They checked whether two narrators could even have met, and compared parallel chains against each other.
My read is that Arab memory culture supplied the instinct, and the need to protect the Prophet’s words supplied the rigor. Goldziher and Schacht argued over how early the system really took shape, and Azami and Motzki answered them, but the continuity with the older culture of lineage is hard to ignore.
A people who could recite their grandfathers back to the beginning were well placed to build the most elaborate chain-of-transmission science in history.
The conversation that most Africans don’t want to have is that Slavery was 95% possible because Africans themselves was enslaving each other
The empire of shongai alone sold and was enslaving thousands of Africans just because they were from a different religion/tribes
The Europeans came to Africa and already found existing slave markets which they further developed
Islam did not invent slavery, nor did it originate these systems of enslavement.
But acknowledging these historical realities complicates the narrative that some contemporary Pan-Africanists would rather promote.
Reminder that this is Colonial Faux Propaganda Historical fiction
No such thing happened the so “Arab slave trade” in Africa is was invented by 19th century British abolitionists & Imperialists to justify European colonization of Africa.
which exaggerated or distorted Muslim involvement to make it appear as if it was similar in scale and brutality to the Atlantic slave trade. This was a politically motivated reinterpretation, The goal was to encourage Africans to abandon Islam, specifically because the strongest resistance to European colonialism often came from African Muslims..
The majority of slave trade that happened was not Arabs buying sub-Saharan Africans, but rather African Muslims trading within the continent often across the Sahara. like for example The Christian highland kingdom of Ethiopia. was the largest consumer of slaves in the region of east africa . the Ethiopian king was certainly the largest single slave-owner in this region but if your read colonial propaganda history it will tell you its arabs
Perhaps the greatest misconception surrounding liberalism is the belief that it represents a neutral political space in which competing ideologies can coexist.
It does not.
Liberalism has its own anthropology, moral philosophy, conception of justice, understanding of authority and theory of political legitimacy.
It makes substantive claims about the individual, society, religion, property, sovereignty and the limits of political power.
These are ideological commitments.
The fact that they have become institutionalised across much of the contemporary international order does not make them philosophically neutral.
Indeed, one of liberalism’s greatest achievements has been to make its own assumptions appear invisible.
Other political philosophies are expected to explain themselves, defend their historical foundations and justify their moral commitments.
Liberalism, meanwhile, frequently occupies the position of the examiner rather than the examined.
It establishes the vocabulary through which other systems are evaluated, determines which arguments are considered acceptable and then presents the resulting hierarchy as an expression of universal reason.
This is ideological dominance operating through the language of neutrality
لم أستغرب ما قاله ستيف بانون في تلك المقابلة التلفزيونية التي دعا فيها إلى أن تنأى الولايات المتحدة بنفسها عن دول الخليج وهي السعودية وقطر والكويت والإمارات التي تريد من أميركا ان تحمي نفطها، بعد ان غدت اميركا في غير حاجة لنفط تلك الدول، وقد أصبح نفط فنزويلا لديها ونفط خليج المكسيك ونفط غويانا القادم في الطريق، كما قال.
تصريح بانون هذا يؤكد ما قلته سابقا أنهم في اميركا عندما يحتاجوننا فقط نكون جيدين ونكون أصدقاء، وعندما لا يحتاجون لنا تتغير أولوياتهم. وهذا الأمر يجب أن يكون درسا يعيه كل قائد، ليس في الخليج وحده بل في العالم العربي كله.
ومع أني لست مصدوماً مما قاله بانون، فإني استهجن الأسلوب غير اللائق الذي يتحدث به عن وجوب تغيير السياسة الأميركية ونسف المصداقية التي يتحدثون عنها دائماً، بأن أمريكا تحافظ على أصدقائها. لكن التاريخ يشهد بغير ذلك، والحاضر كما قال ستيف بانون يقول غير ذلك. أما حين تحدث بانون عن إسرائيل فقد اختلف أسلوبه في الحديث.
Whenever I eat a delicious meal, I remember the narration about Abdurrahman ibn Auf. He had been fasting all day, and when his servants brought him a lavish meal, he looked at it and said that Mus’ab ibn Umayr, who was better than him, had been killed and left almost nothing behind and never had something like this. Hamza, who was also better than him, had been just the same. He said he feared that his good deeds were being paid out to him early, in this world, much like the verse (“you exhausted your good things in your worldly life”). Then he left the food untouched, even though he had been fasting the whole day.
These people as usual have a problem with islam and they hide under the pretext of questioning strange fiqhi positions
The three examples you list were open disputes between jurists. Presenting a disputed ruling as the verdict of Islam misrepresents how fiqh worked.
2/ Forced marriage: Abu Hanifa held that a sane adult woman cannot be compelled. Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn al-Qayyim rejected ijbar over the virgin as well, on the hadith that she isn’t married until her permission is sought. In Bukhari, al-Khansa’ bint Khidham was married against her will and the Prophet ﷺ annulled it. She was a thayyib, and the dispute over the virgin was argued from texts.
3/ A daughter conceived from zina: this is a Shafi’i position, resting on nasab never being established. Hanafis, Malikis and Hanbalis prohibit it. One minority opinion in one madhhab is being presented as Islam.
the classical books speak of the husband’s right to intimacy, and the category of rape doesn’t appear in them. But the Prophet ﷺ said there is no harming and no reciprocating harm, and contemporary scholars use that to prohibit coercion.
Now ask why these disputes exist at all. Because the imams demanded it.
Abu Hanifa said nobody may take his opinion without knowing where it came from. Malik said everyone’s words are taken and left, except the one in this grave. Al-Shafi’i said that if the hadith is sound, that is his madhhab. Ahmad said to take from where they took.
Al-Shafi’i also said he never debated anyone without wishing the truth would come from that man’s mouth. These were men reasoning in good faith from the texts as they understood them, and that good faith is why they invited correction and never asked anyone to follow them blindly
So the choice you offer, swallow every ruling or walk out, is one the jurists refused in writing twelve centuries ago. Argue a ruling on its evidence, or say your objection is with the texts and defend that. They always come w this nonsense abt ‘Muslims refuse the uncomfortable conversation’. That conversation is twelve centuries old. Questioning is the reason there are four madhhabs and libraries of khilaf. What it asks of you is method: the evidence, the usul, how a ruling gets extracted from a text instead of emotions. Someone who hasn’t read the Hanafi position on ijbar can’t tell you the tradition has no answer.
Like please tell me how can i not question a scholar saying a father can force his daughter to marry, that conjugal rape is allowed, that a man can marry his biological daughter conceived out of wedlock & so on so forth? Vous êtes soit aveugles, soit ignorants, soit malveillants.
Omar ibn Said - fulani Senegalese Muslim
The handwriting in this image is his.
Born around 1770 in Futa Toro—on today’s Senegal–Mauritania border—Omar ibn Said was a Fulani Muslim scholar who studied Arabic and Islamic sciences for about 25 years. In 1807, when he was about 37, he was captured during war, forced across the Atlantic, and sold into slavery in Charleston, South Carolina.
He fled his first enslaver, was captured and jailed in Fayetteville, North Carolina, then remained enslaved by the Owen family. In 1831, while still unfree, he wrote a 15-page account of his life in Arabic: the only known surviving autobiography in Arabic written by an enslaved person in the United States.
That matters: many surviving accounts of enslaved people were filtered through English-speaking editors, missionaries or owners. Omar wrote in a language most around him did not command. His manuscript carries faith, pressure to convert, survival, and longing for home.
He began with Surat al-Mulk, a Qur’anic chapter declaring that all sovereignty belongs to God. Later accounts called him a Christian, but his own Arabic writings preserve Qur’anic passages and blessings for the Prophet Muhammad.
Omar died enslaved in 1864, before abolition.. It is his own testimony: his name, his memory, his handwriting, page from Omar ibn Said’s autobiography, 1831. Library of Congress
My advice to young Muslims: stop reading and listening to people on social media who ‘dig into Islam’ and come out with doubts. Go and seek proper Islamic knowledge.
Look at how these doubts are framed and the pattern repeats. People arrive with a morality already built in by their upbringing and education, often secular or liberal, and put Islam in front of it for approval. What fits, they keep. What doesn’t, they call impossible to accept. Some leave outwardly, others stay and live uneasy in their faith.
One of the biggest inherited beliefs is that everyone must be the same, with identical rights no matter what. So when they see that Allah gave men some rights and women others, and gave women some rights men don’t have, they call it unjust. They lift one ruling out of the legislation, hold it against the society around them, and judge it. The hukm of Allah is a whole and has to be read as a whole.
Allah never claimed to create us identical. We are equal in dignity and in the reward for our deeds. Beyond that He says: ‘We have distributed among them their livelihood in the life of this world and raised some of them above others in degrees’ (43:32). That covers men among themselves as much as men and women. He favored some messengers over others (2:253), made four of the twelve months sacred and Ramadan the best of them, made the ten days of Dhul Hijjah the best of the year and Laylat al-Qadr better than a thousand months, and made Muhammad ﷺ the master of the prophets and the Quran the best of the books. ‘Your Lord creates what He wills and chooses; they have no choice’ (28:68).
La ilaha illallah begins with a negation. You clear out everything that is not Allah and His legislation, then you affirm. Islam is the filter, and your own sense of right is what gets filtered. A school system/society that trains people to treat the self as the measure of everything makes submission feel almost impossible and breeds arrogance but we were created to worship Him and we are His servants. Accept that and you find your purpose, and many rulings sit easier.
Allah describes earlier nations to whom the messengers came with clear proofs: ‘they exulted in what they had of knowledge’ (40:83). They were pleased with what they already knew, and that satisfaction kept the truth out.
He also says “Have you seen the one who takes his own desire as his god, and Allah leaves him astray knowingly, and seals his hearing and his heart and places a veil over his vision? Who then will guide him after Allah? Will you not be reminded?”
Even the reason we use to question Him is a mercy from Him. Seek knowledge. It gives you humility, the shubuhat fade, and you come to know your Lord
Liberalism has effectively elevated individual autonomy into an unquestionable moral authority.
The individual becomes the ultimate reference point of political legitimacy. Institutions are judged according to their ability to accommodate individual preferences, traditions are subjected to individual approval, and moral boundaries increasingly become matters of personal negotiation.
But what happens when individual preferences conflict with collective responsibilities? What happens when personal desires undermine the stability of the family, the continuity of a civilisation or the moral foundations of a society?
Liberalism struggles to provide a coherent answer because its foundational assumptions have already established the individual as the primary unit of moral consideration.
A civilisation, however, cannot survive through individual preference alone.
Families cannot function without obligations. Communities cannot endure without shared norms. Political institutions cannot maintain legitimacy without a conception of the common good. Even the most liberal societies depend upon inherited moral assumptions, social trust and collective restraints that their own philosophical framework increasingly struggles to justify.
Liberalism consumes the moral capital of traditions it simultaneously teaches people to question.
It inherits a society built upon obligations, duties, restraint and collective identity, then proceeds to reinterpret those foundations as limitations upon individual freedom.
Eventually, the foundations begin to deteriorate.